As opinion polls give Ukip a boost, it's time to ask what Britain's third party really wants

Like many political figures, in private Ukip leader Nigel Farage is charming, playful and witty - but his views are political poison

Click to follow
The Independent Online

However abrasive they may be in public, political figures are often privately charming, and Ukip leader Nigel Farage is no exception. A few months ago, I took part in a BBC Schools Question Time with him; that a hard-right ideologue who left the Tories in disgust not long after they booted out Margaret Thatcher could win the affection of state-school sixth formers underlined his strength. Unlike, say, the rather dour hang-and-flog-em journalist Peter Hitchens, Farage is jovial, playful and often witty. Political poison, too. Continuing a debate after the recording on why poorer children did worse at school than their more affluent peers, he suggested that genetics played a role: I winced.

It remains to be seen whether Ukip is solidifying its position as Britain’s third party, but recent opinion polls and by-elections seem to point in that direction. As the not-so-strange death of Lib Dem Britain continues apace, Ukip is filling the vacuum. In yesterday’s ComRes poll for the Independent on Sunday, it registered 14 per cent – approaching half of the Conservatives’ poll rating. On average, the candidates it fielded in May’s local elections won the same level of support; over 5,000 Rotherham residents opted for their candidate in the recent by-election; and Farage is confident that Ukip will win the biggest share of the vote in the 2014 European Parliamentary elections. Its membership is apparently being bloated by Tories fleeing in disgust at the prospect of equal marriage. For now, at least, Ukip is on the march.

Despite frequent suggestions from the right that the BBC is some sort of pinko-lefty conspiracy, Ukip’s rise has been aided by generous media exposure. On the Beeb’s flagship political programme Question Time, for example, Nigel Farage has appeared more times since 2008 than any politician, except Vince Cable. And his deputy, Paul Nuttall, appeared twice this year alone. But Ukip has escaped much proper scrutiny, even as it becomes a permanent fixture in British politics.

Today’s Ukip supporter is rather different from a few years ago. They are no longer affluent, middle class ex-Tories who are primarily obsessed with fleeing the sinister clutches of the EU. As Matthew Goodwin, an expert on far-right extremism, put it, it now “ tends to do best among working-class voters who find its populist attacks on immigrants, Muslims and the political establishment attractive”.

Yesterday’s poll bears that out: Ukip enjoyed the support of nearly a fifth of skilled workers, significantly more than middle-class professionals.

Neither can Ukip voters simply be dismissed as “the Thatcherite Tory Party in exile” as Peter Hitchens put it. More than four out of 10 Ukip voters oppose George Osborne’s cap on tax credits and benefits, compared to just 15 per cent of Tories; and 43 per cent want an increase in spending on public services, a view shared by just over a quarter of Conservative voters. Forty per cent believe the Government “is cutting spending too deeply” – more than the remaining Liberal Democrat voters who subscribe to such a view. It all shows what a potentially fatally unstable coalition Ukip is: after all, Nigel Farage assails Osborne for not making enough cuts.

Indeed, Ukip’s economic policies are a hard-right wet dream – and a nightmare for the rest of us. They propose a flat tax of 31 per cent for all but the very poorest, leaving millionaires paying the same as call centre workers, nurses and bin collectors. They want to abolish employers’ national insurance contributions, which the IFS, a think-tank, estimate would be a tax cut for bosses of up to £60bn, leading to even more traumatic cuts. It denies climate change and wants to scrap subsidies for renewable energy, favouring increased support for nuclear power stations instead.

But it is the fact that it threatens to tap into a huge potential well of bigotry that makes the party such a threat. Other Western European countries have long been afflicted with thriving right-wing populist parties; Ukip looks like it has a shot at establishing itself as Britain’s equivalent of the French National Front. With its campaign against gay marriage, Ukip hopes to win over obsessively homophobic Tories. Ukip MEP Roger Helmer once compared gay marriage to incest and polygamy, and Dr Julia Gasper – who stood for the party in Oxford East in 2010 – once mused: “We ought to reflect that there is a strong connection between male homosexuality and paedophilia.” To top off all the offensive comparisons, Ukip’s cultural spokesman Winston McKenzie suggested that putting children with lesbian or gay couples was “ child abuse”. In the European Parliament, Ukip sit with hardline homophobes such as the far-right United Poland party. Little wonder, then, as former Ukip MEP Nikki Sinclaire has put it, that Ukip is “without a doubt homophobic”.

Above all, Ukip offer a respectable outlet for those with racial prejudices.

Above all, Ukip offer a respectable outlet for those with racial prejudices. As professors Peter John and Helen Margetts have put it, Ukip “draws upon the same source of social and political attitudes among the public as the BNP and has the potential to convert such attitudes into votes.” After protracted campaigns by anti-fascists, the BNP are in meltdown: but Ukip offers a home for those turned off by the fascist associations of Nick Griffin’s thugs. With dog-whistle policies such as banning the burka, Ukip is tapping into the poison of Islamophobia. Muslims are “breeding 10 times faster than us”, claims former Ukip leader Lord Pearson; and a study by Matthew Goodwin and Jocelyn Evans found nearly two-thirds of Ukip supporters would feel “bothered a lot” by a mosque in their community, well over double the average in Britain as a whole.

“Multiculturalism has split our society,” Ukip claims, promising to end the “active promotion of the doctrine of multiculturalism by local national government and all publicly funded bodies”. Last week’s census exposed the myth that we are becoming a more racially segregated society, with the number of mixed-race children doubling in just a decade. People from different backgrounds increasingly live together, work together and – yes – sleep together. But it is those fearful of Britain’s growing diversity that Ukip is desperate to appeal to.

Ukip’s rise represents a failure of the left. Even as capitalism remains in an intractable crisis, left-of-Labour parties in Britain are incapable of channelling people’s growing frustrations, winning derisory votes in each election. Ukip has become a vehicle for those repulsed by our technocratic political elite. Be in no doubt, charming Farage is a dangerous man, politically speaking, and Ukip is a potential menace. It’s time to take it seriously.