Is the Natural History Museum right to get rid of 'Dippy'? We asked two writers with very different opinions to give us their views. Here, Charlie Cooper says no. To read why Tom Mendelsohn says yes, click here.
I remember very well the day I first set eyes on Dippy. It was would have been the early 90s, I about seven-years-old, and on one of my first trips to London.
On the way my friend Steve’s mum raised our expectations of the city with impossible stories of trains that went underground and – most unlikely of all – a dinosaur the size of your house that was kept in the hall of the Natural History Museum.
In my head, the hall was a place between the front door and the stairs where you hung your coat, so I was pretty sure she was having us on.
But of course, she wasn’t.
I wish I could remember the exact moment we walked into the museum, but it’s gone. Perhaps the grown-up mind can’t conceive of awe on that scale. I can only assume my reaction was similar to Sam Neill’s in Jurassic Park – “It’s…a dinosaur!”
So it was with a genuine, pit of the stomach sadness that I learned Dippy, after 36 years of service, is to be retired.
His place guarding the entrance of the museum will be taken up by a blue whale skeleton, suspended from the ceiling as though it were plunging into the great hall.
I must admit, it sounds terrific, and the message it sends about how we should think about nature – as a dynamic living force of which we’re part, rather than a static thing to be observed and studied – is admirable.
But alas, poor Dippy! To my seven-year-old self and to countless other children he was more than just a bunch of giant bones (or more accurately, model casts of giant bones).
Recent archaeological discoveries
Recent archaeological discoveries
1/11 Recent archaeologist's discoveries
Divers Alberto Nava and Susan Bird discover the world's oldest skull found in an underwater cave in Mexico, believed to be the earliest trace of first Americans
2/11 Recent archaeologist's discoveries
Paleontologist Gary Morgan stands over the fossil of a stegomastodon skull discovered in a remote area of Elephant Butte State Park, N.M. in June 2012
AP Photo/Albuquerque Journal, Roberto Rosales
3/11 Recent archaeologist's discoveries
Scientists discovered the world’s oldest face, which belongs to this 419 million-year-old fish - an ancient sea predator that might also re-write the history of our evolution from the seas
4/11 Recent archaeologist's discoveries
An archaeologist discovered a tomb of an intact mummy of the Wari prehispanic culture in Lima's Huaca Pucllana ceremonial complex, at Miraflores district
5/11 Recent archaeologist's discoveries
One of the 46 fossils found at the site in southern Chile
6/11 Recent archaeologist's discoveries
Archaeologist James Best holding a Roman skull found during the building of a utility tunnel at Crossrail's Liverpool Street station site, London
7/11 Recent archaeologist's discoveries
In 2012 archaeologists unearthed two skeletons from the Middle Ages pierced through the chest with iron rods to keep them from turning into vampires. They were discovered in the Black Sea town of Sozopol, Bulgaria
8/11 Recent archaeologist's discoveries
Several horse shoes dating from the 2nd century AD have been found stuck in cart ruts in this area. Archaeologists believe the metal shoes, which were strapped rather than nailed to horses, came off as the animals were led up to a timber bridge over the Walbrook River
9/11 Recent archaeologist's discoveries
An archaeologist digs out a skull from the site of the graveyard of the Bethlehem, or Bedlam, hospital
10/11 Recent archaeologist's discoveries
Archaeologists discovered a dinosaur tail in Mexico's desert with the 50 vertebrae of the tail completely intact
11/11 Recent archaeologist's discoveries
Archaeologist found a terracotta warrior at the excavation site inside the No. 1 pit of the Museum of Qin Terracotta Warriors and Horses, on the outskirts of Xi'an, Shaanxi province, in June 2010
© Jason Lee / Reuters
The sight of this great exotic beast from another age, standing incongruously in a place that looked like a cathedral, is the stuff of a childhood fantasy story. I remember reaching out to touch the bones (when I still thought they were bones) and the thrill of thinking that I had come into direct contact with another world – one where Dippy and countless other creatures equally big, equally astounding lumbered about the place.
That was a world much more interesting than a suburban childhood, and I think it must have fired an appetite for broader horizons, and a sense of respect and awe for a natural world that stretched back so much further than I, my parents, my grandparents or the entire human race could remember – feelings that have endured to this day.
Dippy, I am relieved to say, is not going far. There are plans for a “weather-proof resin copy” of him to stand outside the museum, and he himself will be packed up for a national tour once his baleen usurper is in place.
I can’t object to either plan and I am sure the Natural History Museum – a truly magnificent institution – will go from strength to strength without Dippy.
But for my seven-year-old self, and for every seven-year-old who won’t have the opportunity to take in that perfect sight of a diplodocus standing guard over a cathedral to nature, I’m still very sad.Reuse content