My father knew Jimmy Savile. See the good in him, he told me. That was the mistake we all made

Our writer notes that behaving like a child has its uses even for adults.

Share

So, is philanthropy the last refuge of the scoundrel?

When you have things to conceal – a criminal past, a ruthlessly accumulated fortune, a predilection for underage girls, or just a hankering to be better thought of than you deserve – what works better than giving to charity? Give munificently and ostentatiously – for there’s no advantage in hiding your light under the same bushel you hide your dirty secret – and a knighthood will surely come your way, to say nothing of the devotion of your beneficiaries, and therefrom, if you’re smart, ample opportunity to pursue your secret predilections even further. Crime, charity, crime: call it the perpetual motion of the immoralist.

It’s not my intention to be cynical. The charitable impulse is honourable and more than ever necessary in these cruel times; we cannot afford it to be discredited by dubious motives – whether of the criminal or simply the inadequate sort. (I’m thinking of Kitty’s friend Varenka in Anna Karenina who devotes herself to good works because she can’t otherwise find a centre to her life.)

My father knew Jimmy Savile a little and spoke with admiration of the charity work he saw him do at close quarters. “But the man’s a creepy nincompoop,” I used to say. “He has the dead face of a thug, makes ridiculous noises, and aspires to the condition of a slow-to-develop infant. You’d have had me adopted had I behaved like that when I was three.” “As usual you’re quick to make judgements about people you don’t know,” my father replied with justice, for I was at university and dropped judgements the way an autumn tree drops leaves. “You should see him with disabled kids. You should see the pleasure he brings them.”

Predatious

My father was a taxi driver in Manchester when he met Jimmy Savile. For some reason Savile liked the company of taxi drivers and often joined them in their hut at Piccadilly Station. I attach no sexual significance to this, not least because I can’t, for the life of me, see any. It’s hard to imagine how you’d prey on the innocence of a Manchester taxi driver. But you never know. Perhaps he needed their discretion. Or occasionally craved the conversation of grown-ups.

He gave his time freely, anyway, to the annual Manchester taxi drivers’ convoy of disabled children to Blackpool, an event which my father helped to organise, chivvying other drivers and spending weeks decorating his own cab with toys and balloons. It doesn’t fall to everybody to be good with disabled children on an outing such as this. At the behest of my father, I tried once and failed. But he was excellent at it, naturally kind and jolly, not distressed into uselessness as I had been, and Jimmy Savile, he assured me, was even better. That being the case, one has to take one’s hat off to him. Behaving as though you’re a child yourself has its uses.

That I know of, my father never had to square Jimmy Savile’s charitable work with his predatiousness. Certainly he never said anything to suggest he was aware of it, as it’s becoming more evident by the day that many at the BBC were. Mark Thompson has unwisely said he had never heard a word, which confirms one’s suspicions that he didn’t have a clue about much, including what was going on in the institution he ran. But how other people at the BBC who did have a clue managed to arrange their suspicions into complaisance is a question we are bound to ask.

Blackmail

Ditto tabloid journalists who have been half inclined to use the Savile revelations as a reminder to Leveson of the importance of exposing public figures, but who should be reminded in turn of their failure to expose this public figure when no one was stopping them from doing so. No one except Savile himself, that is. It’s said he blackmailed any paper about to unmask him with the threat of putting an end to his giving, but it’s difficult to imagine a threat like that shutting any decent journalist up. Indeed, the threat itself would only have made the story juicier. That it might have silenced some of the staff of the homes, hospitals and special schools he supported, and from which he is said to have drawn a plentiful supply of victims, is easier to understand if not to forgive. You need a hard nose to survive as a charity.

So what sense are we to make of the resounding silence? Cowardice, was it? A complicit contempt for the victims? An inane regard for celebrity? Or could it have been that those who knew, or half-knew, were actually making a philosophical decision – that the good he did outweighed the bad? They wouldn’t have been the first to go down that route. Many honourable and intelligent people – intellectuals in particular – will squint at evil if it serves an end to which their ideologies commit them.

Take the late Eric Hobsbawm who held on to his belief in the Communist system long after most other rational men had dumped it in disillusionment and shame. He saw the amelioration of humanity as the ultimate goal, no matter how many millions perished to achieve it. By this reasoning the greater good must always excuse the lesser evil, from which it follows that it’s better to keep a special school going for the many than to allow it to close to protect a few. A preference which lets not only Stalin and Savile off the hook, but also those who turned a blind eye to them.

Savile was a cunning, brutal nincompoop scraping the barrel of a bankrupt popular culture, Hobsbawm a brilliant, subtle and courteous historian, an ornament to scholarship; but they complement each other grotesquely. In Savile we see the good that wicked men can do; in Hobsbawm the wickedness that good men can think.

React Now

Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
iJobs Job Widget
iJobs General

h2 Recruit Ltd: Business Development Manager - HR Consultancy - £65,000 OTE

£35000 - £40000 per annum + £65,000 OTE: h2 Recruit Ltd: London, Birmingham, M...

Recruitment Genius: Sales Courier - OTE £30,000

£15000 - £30000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: A great opportunity to work in ...

h2 Recruit Ltd: Sales Manager - Political Market Research - £55,000 OTE

£35000 - £55000 per annum + benefits: h2 Recruit Ltd: A global, market leading...

h2 Recruit Ltd: Business Development Manager-Accounting Software-£80,000 OTE

£50000 per annum + OTE £80,000 + pesnion + health-care: h2 Recruit Ltd: A well...

Day In a Page

Read Next
The Elgin statue of river god Ilissos has been at the British Museum since 1918  

The British Museum has just lost the Elgin Marbles argument

Geoffrey Robertson
 

George Osborne's Bond issue brings out the secret agent in us all

Boyd Tonkin
The Last Word: Candidate Sebastian Coe must demand that doping is a criminal offence

Michael Calvin's Last Word

Candidate Coe must demand that doping is a criminal offence
Al-Jazeera journalists imprisoned by Egypt to ‘teach Qatar a lesson’ for supporting the Muslim Brotherhood

Al-Jazeera journalists imprisoned by Egypt to ‘teach Qatar a lesson’

Mohamed Fahmy, one of three reporters held in a Cairo prison, has written to Robert Fisk to outline his grievances against his employers
A voyage through hell: One asylum seeker's epic journey from Eritrea to a new life in Europe

An asylum seeker's voyage through hell

Zekarias Kebraeb has written an extraordinary book describing his epic journey from Eritrea to Europe
Homeless Veterans appeal: Help the ex-service personnel to whom we all owe so much

Help the ex-service personnel to whom we all owe so much

Our Christmas appeal supports the home that houses veterans. Evgeny Lebedev met two of them
Orion 'Mars ship': The most ambitious venture in Nasa's history offers the best chance of rekindling national excitement over space exploration

Orion 'Mars ship'

The most ambitious venture in Nasa's history offers the best chance of rekindling national excitement over space exploration, says Rupert Cornwell
Penguin has embarked on a four-year project to chronicle the lives of all 45 of our monarchs

Penguin chronicles lives of 45 monarchs

From Athelstan to Elizabeth IIs, Gillian Orr discovers some great pub facts
How did 'hipster sans serif' become the defining font of 2014?

The defining font of 2014

The spindly upper-case scrawl has been embraced to death by marketing folk to appeal to Young People and adorns everything from paperbacks to salad bags
The Grandmaster, film review: Wong Kar-Wai's martial arts epic is a lovingly staged dust-up

The Grandmaster review

Wong Kar-Wai's martial arts epic is a lovingly staged dust-up
Christmas 2014: 10 best gifts for teenage boys

10 best gifts for teenage boys

Get them talking, rather than grunting, on Christmas morning with our pick of the presents for teen boys
Paul Scholes column: Barcelona seem bored to me, they are a ghost of their former selves

Paul Scholes column

Barcelona seem bored to me, they are a ghost of their former selves
Frank Warren column: Chris Eubank Jnr still has a bright future – if he gets rid of dad

Frank Warren

Chris Eubank Jnr still has a bright future – if he gets rid of his dad
Autumn Statement: So what difference will it make to your finances?

So what difference will the Autumn Statement make to your finances?

The cost of moving home will fall in 98 per cent of sales, while married couples with money to squirrel away will be cheered
War with Isis: Iran joins ‘Great Satan’s’ fight against militants with bombing raids over Iraq

Iran joins ‘Great Satan’s’ fight against Isis

Tehran may have formed an unlikely alliance with its sworn enemy, but a policy of open confrontation and covert co-operation with US likely to continue, says Patrick Cockburn
From London to Birmingham, what do local people really think of the proposed HS2 project?

What do people really think of HS2?

One writer walked the straight line from London to Birmingham that is the proposed HS2 route
Vladimir Putin's biggest fan club: Media-savvy youth group Set is churning out propaganda and clothing to promote Russia's leader

Vladimir Putin's biggest fan club

Media-savvy youth group Set is churning out propaganda and clothing to promote Russia's leader