- Thursday 23 May 2013
- My Account
- Logout
- Register
- Login
- News
-
Voices
-
Find by writer
- Yasmin Alibhai-Brown
- Rebecca Armstrong
- Memphis Barker
- Terence Blacker
- Chris Blackhurst
- David Blanchflower
- Archie Bland
- Ian Burrell
- Andrew Buncombe
- Ben Chu
- Patrick Cockburn
- Laura Davis
- Mary Dejevsky
- Grace Dent
- Robert Fisk
- Andrew Grice
- Stefano Hatfield
- Philip Hensher
- Ian Herbert
- Howard Jacobson
- Ellen E Jones
- Alice Jones
- Owen Jones
- Simon Kelner
- Dominic Lawson
- Donald Macintyre
- Lisa Markwell
- Comment
- Campaigns
- Debate
- Editorials
- Letters
- IV Drip
- Archive
- Our Voices
- Commentators
- Columnists
- Democracy 2015
- IV Drip Archive
-
Find by writer
- Sport
- Tech
- Life
- Property
- Arts & Ents
- Travel
- Money
- IndyBest
- Blogs
- Student
Tuesday 26 June 2012
Amol Rajan: Vocations should not replace academic learning
Freeview from the editos at i
After leaking plans to the Daily Mail last week to scrap GCSEs, Michael Gove was both denounced as an inhumane Victorian and welcomed as a one-man panacea for all Britain's social ills. Broadly, the former tendency came from the left and the latter from the right. This represents a terrible defeat for the left, and I say that as someone who is not a conservative.
Perhaps the greatest failure of the modern centre-left in Britain is its connivance in the systematic dismantling of academic education in the state sector. This has been done under the guise of vocational education, a secular tyranny which consigns the poorest students – or at least those forced down this path – to a life of diminished learning and stunted imagination. It has led to a terrible chasm in our society, which I wrote about in The Independent two years ago: skills for the poor and schools for the rich.
If you go to the great public schools around the country, or speak to its progeny, you will note that all sorts of specialist, skilled activity – woodwork, cooking, sport – is complementary to academic learning, by which I mean crunchy subjects like physics, maths, Latin, and history. It is not a substitute. This is because, in the schools that produce the most intellectually able students – and I know how contested is the measurement of intellectual ability – they know that it is tough academic subjects – organised bodies of knowledge transmitted through the generations – that learning is cultivated.
The expansion of vocational learning in the past 15 years was a way of palming off struggling poor students on to subjects that kept their attention. But there are two massive problems with this approach. First, adolescents don't know what's good for them, and in any case their interests are temporary and transient. At 14, I wanted to be a porn star, a cricketer, and a train driver (in that order). You can be the judge of how that worked out for me. Second, if a pupil from a poor background specialises in textiles at 14, and realises two years later he doesn't want to be a clothes manufacturer after all... then what? Better to have tried and failed at tough subjects than head down a blind alley with no turning back.
Vocations are fine, even laudable. But they should complement, not substitute, academic learning – and therefore be reserved for those over 18. I cannot tell you whether or not Gove's adoption of a Singaporean system is a good idea. But I do know that when people on the left instinctively denounce any plan to restore academic rigour to the state sector, they are going in for the very class warfare they used to despise.
Follow @amolrajan-
Grace Dent: I’m not sure how these people can avoid being called ‘bigots’. And the more ‘civilised’, the worse they are
Grace Dent -
After woman sells virginity for $780,000, here are the results of our prostitution survey
Laura Davis -
The Daily Cartoon
-
Woolwich murder: They killed, then they performed - these men should be starved of our attention
Frank Furedi -
Woolwich attack: The EDL will seek to exploit this evil crime for their own evil ends
Jamie Lewis
Get your summer started with British Military Fitness
BMF is the UK’s biggest and best loved outdoor fitness classes
Visit York
Find out what The Independent's resident travel expert has to say about one of the most beautiful small cities in the world
Enter the latest Independent competitions
Win anything from gadgets to five-star holidays on our competitions and offers page.
Business videos from commercial thought leaders
Watch the best in the business world give their insights into the world of business.
Amol Rajan
Get the best in opinion from Independent Voices, straight to your inbox every Thursday lunchtime.
Subscribe
Amol Rajan
A weekly update from the Editor
Day In a Page
Edward VIII’s phone calls - and how MI5 bugged them
Hollywood's random acts of red-carpet kindness
Not secure any more: G4S boss heads for exit at last
How to say ‘I’m a sellout’