Robert Verkaik: Two cases, two contrasting results

These two different outcomes show how little scope there is for measuring compassion

Share
Related Topics

Both are loving mothers, who after years of devoted care to their disabled children felt they had no choice but to take the law into their own hands. But while Bridget Gilderdale was allowed to walk free from court yesterday after helping her daughter die, Frances Inglis will spend many years in prison for killing her son.

These two startlingly different outcomes, to two seemingly similar cases of mercy killing, show how little scope there is for measuring compassion in our criminal justice system.

Critics of the law of homicide say that both Mrs Gilderdale, 55, and Mrs Inglis, 57, acted in what they thought were the best interests of their seriously ill children and should never have been charged with the offence of murder.

Yesterday, a jury from Lewes, East Sussex, cleared Mrs Gilderdale of attempted murder while last week an Old Bailey jury sitting 60 miles away in central London convicted Mrs Inglis of murder.

Both sets of jurors heard that the mothers had been devoted parents, putting the needs of their children before everything else. They had both endured years of emotional turmoil, pushing them to the brink of human tolerance. There was no hope that their children would ever lead normal lives.

But these two case are different and they are different in one very important respect.

Lynn Gilderdale, 31, who had suffered from ME since the age of 14, was mentally competent and had made it very clear that she did not want to live. Thomas Inglis, 22, had suffered terrible brain damage in 2007 and could not speak.

This distinction meant that it was not possible to charge Mrs Inglis with assisted suicide, as there was no evidence that her son intended to end his own life. The Old Bailey jury was also told that Mr Inglis was not in a persistent vegetative state and that he was making progress.

In the Inglis case, the judge outlined why Mrs Inglis's actions amounted to murder: "What you did was to take upon yourself what you thought your son's wishes would have been, to relieve him from what you described as a living hell. But you cannot take the law into your own hands and you cannot take away life, however compelling you think the reason."

This was not true in the case of Mrs Gilderdale, whose daughter had not only asked for her mother's help to die but forensic tests could not say with certainty which drugs had killed her.

While these cases can be reconciled in how they were prosecuted, there remain serious questions about the sentencing of mercy killers. As the law stands, a murder conviction attracts a mandatory life jail term.

Even if a judge is persuaded that the defendant was motivated by mercy, the most lenient sentence he can impose will still result in many years behind bars.

React Now

Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
iJobs Job Widget
iJobs General

SEN Teaching Assistant

£2880 - £3120 per annum: Randstad Education Leeds: Special Needs Teaching Assi...

SEN Teaching Assistant

£60 - £65 per annum: Randstad Education Leeds: We are currently recruiting for...

English Teacher Thetford Secondary

£110 - £150 per day: Randstad Education Cambridge: An Academy based in Thetfor...

SEN Teaching Assistant

£60 - £65 per day: Randstad Education Leeds: We are currently recruiting for ...

Day In a Page

 

In Sickness and in Health: Waking up to my 4am witching hour of worry

Rebecca Armstrong
Oscar Pistorius sentencing: The athlete's wealth and notoriety have provoked a long overdue debate on South African prisons

'They poured water on, then electrified me...'

If Oscar Pistorius is sent to jail, his experience will not be that of other inmates
James Wharton: The former Guard now fighting discrimination against gay soldiers

The former Guard now fighting discrimination against gay soldiers

Life after the Army has brought new battles for the LGBT activist James Wharton
Ebola in the US: Panic over the virus threatens to infect President Obama's midterms

Panic over Ebola threatens to infect the midterms

Just one person has died, yet November's elections may be affected by what Republicans call 'Obama's Katrina', says Rupert Cornwell
Premier League coaches join the RSC to swap the tricks of their trades

Darling, you were fabulous! But offside...

Premier League coaches are joining the RSC to learn acting skills, and in turn they will teach its actors to play football. Nick Clark finds out why
How to dress with authority: Kirsty Wark and Camila Batmanghelidjh discuss the changing role of fashion in women's workwear

How to dress with authority

Kirsty Wark and Camila Batmanghelidjh discuss the changing role of fashion in women's workwear
New book on Joy Division's Ian Curtis sheds new light on the life of the late singer

New book on Ian Curtis sheds fresh light on the life of the late singer

'Joy Division were making art... Ian was for real' says author Jon Savage
Sean Harris: A rare interview with British acting's secret weapon

Sean Harris: A rare interview with British acting's secret weapon

The Bafta-winner talks Hollywood, being branded a psycho, and how Barbra Streisand is his true inspiration
Tim Minchin, interview: The musician, comedian and world's favourite ginger is on scorching form

Tim Minchin interview

For a no-holds-barred comedian who is scathing about woolly thinking and oppressive religiosity, he is surprisingly gentle in person
Boris Johnson's boozing won't win the puritan vote

Boris's boozing won't win the puritan vote

Many of us Brits still disapprove of conspicuous consumption – it's the way we were raised, says DJ Taylor
Ash frontman Tim Wheeler reveals how he came to terms with his father's dementia

Tim Wheeler: Alzheimer's, memories and my dad

Wheeler's dad suffered from Alzheimer's for three years. When he died, there was only one way the Ash frontman knew how to respond: with a heartfelt solo album
Hugh Bonneville & Peter James: 'Peter loves his classic cars; I've always pootled along fine with a Mini Metro. I think I lack his panache'

How We Met: Hugh Bonneville & Peter James

'Peter loves his classic cars; I've always pootled along fine with a Mini Metro. I think I lack his panache'
Bill Granger recipes: Our chef's heavenly crab dishes don't need hours of preparation

Bill Granger's heavenly crab recipes

Scared off by the strain of shelling a crab? Let a fishmonger do the hard work so you can focus on getting the flavours right
Radamel Falcao: How faith and love drive the Colombian to glory

Radamel Falcao: How faith and love drive the Colombian to glory

After a remarkable conversion from reckless defender to prolific striker, Monaco's ace says he wants to make his loan deal at Old Trafford permanent
Terry Venables: Premier League managers must not be allowed to dictate who plays and who does not play for England

Terry Venables column

Premier League managers must not be allowed to dictate who plays and who does not play for England
The Inside Word: Brendan Rodgers looks to the future while Roy Hodgson is ghost of seasons past

Michael Calvin's Inside Word

Brendan Rodgers looks to the future while Roy Hodgson is ghost of seasons past