Shashank Joshi: This revolution is far more complex than we imagine

Share
Related Topics

There are two misconceptions around the narrative of Libya's would-be revolution. The first is that the country is cleaved between a static east-west frontline along which rebel and government forces are clashing on equal terms. The second is that Muammar Gaddafi and his inner sanctum are besieged within Tripoli.

This is a deeply fluid revolution in which regime and rebels alike have penetrated hundreds of miles into each others' territories. The opposition-held city of Zawiya is just 30 miles west of Tripoli. But the regime still holds Surt, Colonel Gaddafi's hometown, over 230 miles along the coast and a bulwark against any rebel advance from Benghazi.

Though every pillar of his rule is crumbling at the edges – tribes, army, diplomats and ministers – Colonel Gaddafi retains not just a firm grip over his capital. He is also demonstrating the ability to direct ground forces – special forces and ad hoc militias – several hundred miles from his base, such as at an oil refinery in the middle of the country and cities on each side. Colonel Gaddafi's most loyal units are also his best equipped and trained, and bombing raids on Monday suggest he still wields potent airpower.

Though Colonel Gaddafi's delusional speech at the beginning of the week hinted at a leader without a grasp of reality, he is not without a strategy. He aims not to regain his lost territory, but to enforce a grinding stalemate that might persuade his adversaries to reach a settlement. His rant was designed to emphasise his enduring presence at the capital, countering the opposition's attempt to project an image of momentum.

Indeed, rebel groups have no viable means of pushing along the coast. They are cut off from rebel counterparts in the west and have limited offensive capabilities despite their numerical superiority. The logistical challenges of moving an 8,000-strong patchwork army across nearly 500 miles may be overwhelming. International intervention could break this impasse. The barriers to this are not military, but political. Nato could obliterate Libya's air-defence network and secure its airspace. The proximity of European military assets and the poor quality of Libyan forces render this a far-easier task than enforcing the no-fly zone over Iraq between 1992 and 2003.

But the Nato Secretary General and prominent Arab voices have demanded that it be authorised by a UN Security Council resolution. That will not be forthcoming. Veto-wielding Russia and China will be opposed to any resolution that violates the principle of non-intervention. Beijing also has had flickers of unrest at home.

The Western appetite for military operations has been dimmed after the stand-off with Serbia over Kosovo in 1999 and the morass of Iraq after 2003. It is also questionable whether a no-fly zone could preclude regime brutality inflicted by troops on the ground. The 1995 massacre at Srebrenica occurred under a UN-enforced no-fly zone over Bosnia and Herzegovina.

Colonel Gaddafi would have to cross one of what are likely three lines before pushing a coalition to sidestep the UN: a single and compelling massacre; intensification of airstrikes; the use of chemical weapons. In the coming week, it is probable that he will calibrate his violence to pressure rebel cities around Tripoli without decisively crossing that threshold. That suggests that against the backdrop of Nato's flexing, the stalemate could drag into the spring.

The writer is an Associate Fellow of the Royal United Services Institute

React Now

Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
SPONSORED FEATURES
iJobs Job Widget
iJobs General

Recruitment Genius: Experienced Lettings Administrator

£13520 - £25600 per annum: Recruitment Genius: This dynamic lettings agency ba...

Recruitment Genius: Massage Therapist / Sports Therapist

£15000 - £24000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: A opportunity has arisen for on...

Recruitment Genius: Marketing Assistant

£14000 - £16000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: This leading provider of waste ...

UCL: Mechanical Design Engineer

£33,353 - £40,313 per annum, inclusive of London Allowance: UCL: We are lookin...

Day In a Page

Read Next
 

Jeremy Corbyn becomes Labour leader: Today is our darkest hour – we have become unelectable

Rob Marchant
A plot is already underway from within the Labour party to oust Jeremy Corbyn as leader before the next election  

I voted for Corbyn, but I feel conflicted about his victory. Where are all the women in politics?

Holly Baxter
Timely new graphic novel recalls how democracy first took root in Greece

Graphic novel charts Greek democracy

As the country heads to the polls, Boyd Tonkin hails the graphic novel that traces the birthpangs of democracy
The 'greatest political diary of the 20th century'? Soviet envoy's book reveals the missed chances to pre-empt Hitler's attack on the Soviet Union

The 'greatest political diary of the 20th century'?

Soviet envoy's book reveals the missed chances to pre-empt Hitler's attack on the Soviet Union
From bombed and broken Syria to Coventry, Malmo and Munich: Refugees' tales of running, swimming and pleading their way to safety

Refugee stories

Three stories from Syrians who have made a new life in the West
Patricia Field interview: The costume designer has dressed Carrie Bradshaw and Caitlyn Jenner

Frock 'n' roll: Designer Patricia Field

The costume designer inspired a generation of women when she dressed Carrie Bradshaw and Co for Sex and the City
Kevin McCloud interview: The Grand Designs presenter on the Shard, Prince Charles, and dry-stone-walling

Kevin McCloud interview

The Grand Designs presenter on the Shard, Prince Charles, and dry-stone-walling
Refugee crisis: Cutting Britain's overseas aid to help pay for taking in refugees will exacerbate the problem

Cutting overseas aid to help pay for taking in refugees will exacerbate the problem

Libyan coastguards and people smugglers tell Kim Sengupta why Britain's current policy is doomed to failure
Assisted dying: Hearing arguments for and against a Bill that's divided Britain

Assisted dying: The arguments for and against a Bill that's divided Britain

While the outcome of the debate remains uncertain, some of those taking part have explained where they stand, and why
How the Blitz shaped Britain's future: A new country arose from destruction caused by the aerial assault launched 75 years ago

How the Blitz shaped Britain's future

A new country arose from destruction caused by the aerial assault launched 75 years ago
Citizen Smith is back: Classic 1970s BBC comedy starring Robert Lindsay set to return

The revolution will be televised again

Robert Lindsay back as Citizen Smith
Apple launch: How does the tech giant's latest fruit bowl taste? The verdict of the analysts and pundits

How does Apple’s latest fruit bowl taste?

The verdict of the analysts and pundits
To the Queen's credit, she's worked her way up – there was a time when she was just a lowly princess

To the Queen's credit, she's worked her way up

There was a time when she was just a lowly princess, says Mark Steel
Gloucester Services: Are people really forgoing seaside breaks in favour of the M5 destination?

Gloucester Services: Top of the stops?

If a service station claims drivers visit for a nice day out, you want the doyen of travel experts to investigate. The Independent's Simon Calder obliged
Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone to be republished with illustrations

Harry Potter and the illustrations

Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone is to be republished with illustrations. John Walsh wonders why such productions ever fell out of favour – and if this is part of a revival
Oscar de la Renta's new designer Peter Copping honours the founder - but adds his own panache

Peter Copping's panache

Oscar de la Renta is the quintessential American label, but after the death of its founder it's now a Brit at the helm
8 best patterned gym leggings

8 best patterned gym leggings

Workout in style this autumn