The modern novel: is there a plot or just a conspiracy?
I SYMPATHISE wholehearteldly with David Nicholson-Lord and his frustration at the pretentious unreadability of much contemporary fiction.
I wonder, however, if he has perhaps succumbed without realising it to the other major con of the literary establishment; namely that if a book concerns itself even remotely with the unravelling of a puzzling crime, it cannot be "literature".
Dickens was certainly not above using such plots to sustain reader interest - alongside fine writing. Though there is clearly much dross in the genre (as in all others), there is still to be found, in the work of such as Ruth Rendell/Barbara Vine, Nicholas Freeling, Julian Symons and Elmore Leonard, all the joys of excellent, intelligent writing and the "good read" that your correspondent craves.
Geoffrey Brace
Exeter
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies