Glasgow and Edinburgh: the architectural rivalry

The cultural rivalry between Glasgow and Edinburgh has been reignited by two striking new museums. But who gets the bragging rights? Jay Merrick finds out

Two new museums in Scotland, a vast zinc-coated amoeba on the edge of Glasgow, and a transformed temple of High Victorian knowledge in Edinburgh, have renewed the eternal cultural rivalry of these two great cities, just 47 miles apart. Glasgow claims immediate bragging rights because the Riverside Museum of Transport and Travel was designed by Zaha Hadid and cost more: £74m. And yet Gareth Hoskins Architects' £46m modernisation of the 145-year-old home of the National Museum of Scotland makes it hard to deny the vivid power of big, classically inspired set-piece spaces awash with natural light.

Those braced for high drama on Clydeside can unbrace. There is only one look-at-me moment: the roof edges of the two main facades are like languid architectural scribbles above the gleam of the glazed ends. Here, at Pointhouse Quay, where the Kelvin river flows out of Partick to join the Clyde, this architectural soft machine is anything but a big, big toy for big, big boys.

The museum doesn't obviously express Hadid's key creative stimulants: Russian Suprematist and Constructivist art, Arabic calligraphy, and her fundamental desire to shatter preconceptions about architectural space, and how we experience it. Only her interest in denuded landforms and watercourses seems to apply to the Riverside. Despite 6,000 square metres of exhibition area, the museum is an oddly gentle presence on the quayside where A&J Inglis built ships from 1861 to 1962. From some angles, the museum's beautifully applied 24,000 zinc scales give it the look of a coiled, battleship-grey python.

The back story of the design is the heart of the matter, and two aspects in particular: the socio-economic strategy of Glasgow City Council's nine-year development of the project; and the strong curatorial and demographic leads imposed by the Transport Museum itself, which was previously housed in Glasgow's Kelvin Hall, where only half of its 3,000-object collection could be shown.

The completion of the Riverside marks a key moment in the Glasgow Harbour regeneration project, which is why the council paid two-thirds of the museum's cost, the rest coming from the Heritage Lottery Fund and local corporate and public donations. Architecturally, the museum is the least disturbing of the new developments in the Clydeside areas around Partick and Govan. The Riverside forms an almost flaccid break-point to the grim go-faster stripe of big new blocks of flats that have introduced "lifestyle living" to this stretch of the north bank of the Clyde. It is a lifestyle bereft of any engaging sense of place or history – just another dreary chunk of British boom-bust urban legacy.

Inside the museum, a cornucopia of historic artefacts of transportation is spread out or hung in huge pleated caverns the colour of Golden Delicious apples. The highlights include the Wall of Cars, rather like a two-storey high presentation box of used Dinky toys. There's a heroically mammoth, wildlife-crunching South African Railways locomotive; a charmingly skew-whiff vehicle-loaded shelf that rises up one wall in mimicry of the steep road in Argyll known as Rest and Be Thankful, where manufacturers used to test cars; and a brilliantly contrived moving conveyor belt that parades selections of the museum's 708 ship models.

Does the Riverside work as a welcoming place for the 650,000 visitors expected in its first year, with up to 800,000 coming to see the Glenlee tall ship moored next to it? There is certainly a distinct tension between the architecture, and what it contains. In flowing, column-free spaces like this – with a sharp, cathedral-like high point of about 100ft – it's obvious that it will take some time before the curators discover what segments best suit particular configurations of exhibits. Apart from the fact that the Riverside Museum's café-restaurant seems far too small, Hadid's creation seems highly suitable for Britain's only remaining heavy industry – heritage tourism.

But all thought of things blobbish and avant garde seems trifling on a stroll up The Mound and North Bank Street in Edinburgh. This densely engaging scene reminds you of the emotional and intellectual importance of historic architecture – not all of it superb – in relation to changing times. St Giles' Cathedral, the city's Presbyterian High Kirk, bristles like a dark mound of thistles in sandstone. A little further south, at the corner of Chambers Street, the 1998 postmodernist extension of the National Museum of Scotland, designed by Benson and Forsyth, seems overwrought.

In comparison to this tricked-up blancmange, Hoskins and his co-director, Chris Coleman-Smith, have positively knelt at the altar of the Grade A- listed museum's original architect, Francis Fowke, who also designed London's Albert Hall.

The crucial design move has been to return the magnificent atrium and three levels of galleries in the Grand Gallery to something very like their original condition; in addition, the long stone-vaulted basement space beneath it has been opened up for the first time: it's now the main entrance to the museum, an atmospherically compressed introduction to the building which leads visitors straight up into the Grand Gallery.

As architectural segues go, it's pretty gripping. Yet, considered detail by detail, the Grand Gallery is not in the least astonishing. The iron columns, the arched windows, the glazing – they're all quite unremarkable. But the way the bones of this space are set out, their shifts of scale and perspective, proves that you don't need brilliant architectural refinements to produce a really wonderful space; you can't help smiling when you walk into this one.

The greatly enlarged 16-gallery domain covers 6,800 square metres – slightly more than at Glasgow's Riverside Museum, incidentally – and retains something of the aura of the 18th-century Scottish Enlightenment and of the far-flung Scots of the 19th century who gifted the museum with extraordinary artefacts from the days of empire. More than 8,000 objects will be displayed in a building that now has 50 per cent more public space.

Coleman-Smith has treated the museum – previously constipated at key points by clumsy ad hoc interventions that blocked views and made circulation difficult – with kid-gloves; the new modernist details are restrained. "Previously, people regarded the building as a problem," admits the museum's director, Dr Gordon Rintoul. "Now, the building's almost the main exhibit."

It's a telling remark. How do you get the balance between a museum's exhibits and its modern (or modernised) form right? You can, as in Jean Nouvel's hallucinatory Musée du Quai Branly in Paris, create a building in which the ethnographic exhibits totally dominate. In Glasgow and Edinburgh, in two utterly different buildings, there remains a lingering sense of a complicated contemporary stand-off between historic objects and the way they're presented.

At the Riverside, there is a sense of exhibits being too tightly packed together. And even in Edinburgh, where the renowned Ralph Appelbaum designed the exhibition narrative, the National Museum of Scotland is keen to highlight the large number of interactive displays. History and historical objects are inevitably being reduced to museum entertainments that require greater footfall but shorter dwell-times. Thank heavens for Francis Fowke's Grand Gallery, which defeats that insidious vibe in a way that the Riverside Museum, despite its beautifully crafted shell, cannot.

The winner of this museum design bout is Edinburgh – it just shades its slick opponent, on historical points.

The National Museum of Scotland, Chambers St, Edinburgh (0300 123 6789) opens 29 July. The Riverside Museum of Transport and Travel, 100 Pointhouse Place, Glasgow (0141 287 4350) open now

Arts and Entertainment
Victoria Wood, Kayvan Novak, Alexa Chung, Chris Moyles
tvReview: No soggy bottoms, but plenty of other baking disasters on The Great Comic Relief Bake Off
Arts and Entertainment
80s trailblazer: comedian Tracey Ullman
tv
Arts and Entertainment
Stephen Tompkinson is back as DCI Banks
tvReview: Episode one of the new series played it safe, but at least this drama has a winning formula
Arts and Entertainment
TV
News
Graham Norton said Irish broadcaster RTE’s decision to settle was ‘moronic’
TV
Arts and Entertainment
Attenborough with the primates
tv
Arts and Entertainment
Former Communards frontman Jimmy Somerville
music
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
Arts and Entertainment

ebooksNow available in paperback
Arts and Entertainment

ebooks
Arts and Entertainment
Secrets of JK Rowling's Harry Potter workings have been revealed in a new bibliography
arts + ents
Arts and Entertainment
Fearne Cotton is leaving Radio 1 after a decade
radio The popular DJ is leaving for 'family and new adventures'
Arts and Entertainment
arts + ents
Arts and Entertainment
Public Service Broadcasting are going it alone
music
Arts and Entertainment
Eddie Redmayne as transgender artist Lili Elbe in The Danish Girl
filmFirst look at Oscar winner as transgender artist
Arts and Entertainment
Season three of 'House of Cards' will be returning later this month
TV reviewHouse of Cards returns to Netflix
Arts and Entertainment
Harrison Ford will play Rick Deckard once again for the Blade Runner sequel
film review
Arts and Entertainment
The modern Thunderbirds: L-R, Scott, Virgil, Alan, Gordon and John in front of their home, the exotic Tracy Island
TV
Arts and Entertainment
Natural beauty: Aidan Turner stars in the new series of Poldark
TV
Arts and Entertainment
Taylor Swift won Best International Solo Female (Getty)

Brits 2015
Arts and Entertainment
Shining star: Maika Monroe, with Jake Weary, in ‘It Follows’
film review
Arts and Entertainment

Brits 2015
Arts and Entertainment
Paloma Faith arrives at the Brit Awards (Getty)

Brits 2015
Arts and Entertainment
Anne Boleyn's beheading in BBC Two's Wolf Hall

TV review
Arts and Entertainment
Follow every rainbow: Julie Andrews in 'The Sound of Music'
film Elizabeth Von Trapp reveals why the musical is so timeless
Arts and Entertainment
Bytes, camera, action: Leehom Wang in ‘Blackhat’
film
Arts and Entertainment
The Libertines will headline this year's festival
music
Arts and Entertainment
Richard Dean Anderson in the original TV series, which ran for seven seasons from 1985-1992
tv
Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?

ES Rentals

    Independent Dating
    and  

    By clicking 'Search' you
    are agreeing to our
    Terms of Use.

    War with Isis: Iraq's government fights to win back Tikrit from militants - but then what?

    Baghdad fights to win back Tikrit from Isis – but then what?

    Patrick Cockburn reports from Kirkuk on a conflict which sectarianism has made intractable
    Living with Alzheimer's: What is it really like to be diagnosed with early-onset dementia?

    What is it like to live with Alzheimer's?

    Depicting early-onset Alzheimer's, the film 'Still Alice' had a profound effect on Joy Watson, who lives with the illness. She tells Kate Hilpern how she's coped with the diagnosis
    The Internet of Things: Meet the British salesman who gave real-world items a virtual life

    Setting in motion the Internet of Things

    British salesman Kevin Ashton gave real-world items a virtual life
    Election 2015: Latest polling reveals Tories and Labour on course to win the same number of seats - with the SNP holding the balance of power

    Election 2015: A dead heat between Mr Bean and Dick Dastardly!

    Lord Ashcroft reveals latest polling – and which character voters associate with each leader
    Audiences queue up for 'true stories told live' as cult competition The Moth goes global

    Cult competition The Moth goes global

    The non-profit 'slam storytelling' competition was founded in 1997 by the novelist George Dawes Green and has seen Malcolm Gladwell, Salman Rushdie and Molly Ringwald all take their turn at the mic
    Pakistani women come out fighting: A hard-hitting play focuses on female Muslim boxers

    Pakistani women come out fighting

    Hard-hitting new play 'No Guts, No Heart, No Glory' focuses on female Muslim boxers
    Leonora Carrington transcended her stolid background to become an avant garde star

    Surreal deal: Leonora Carrington

    The artist transcended her stolid background to become an avant garde star
    LGBT History Month: Pupils discuss topics from Sappho to same-sex marriage

    Education: LGBT History Month

    Pupils have been discussing topics from Sappho to same-sex marriage
    11 best gel eyeliners

    Go bold this season: 11 best gel eyeliners

    Use an ink pot eyeliner to go bold on the eyes with this season's feline flicked winged liner
    Cricket World Cup 2015: Tournament runs riot to make the event more hit than miss...

    Cricket World Cup runs riot to make the event more hit than miss...

    The tournament has reached its halfway mark and scores of 300 and amazing catches abound. One thing never changes, though – everyone loves beating England
    Katarina Johnson-Thompson: Heptathlete ready to jump at first major title

    Katarina Johnson-Thompson: Ready to jump at first major title

    After her 2014 was ruined by injury, 21-year-old Briton is leading pentathlete going into this week’s European Indoors. Now she intends to turn form into gold
    Syrian conflict is the world's first 'climate change war', say scientists, but it won't be the last one

    Climate change key in Syrian conflict

    And it will trigger more war in future
    How I outwitted the Gestapo

    How I outwitted the Gestapo

    My life as a Jew in wartime Berlin
    The nation's favourite animal revealed

    The nation's favourite animal revealed

    Women like cuddly creatures whilst men like creepy-crawlies
    Is this the way to get young people to vote?

    Getting young people to vote

    From #VOTESELFISH to Bite the Ballot