Music

Rain (AM and PM) 7° London Hi 9°C / Lo 7°C

Bob Dylan, O2 Arena, London

(Rated 4/ 5 )

Dylan's times ain't a-changin'

By Andy Gill

Bob Dylan's show was so low-key that even photographers were denied entry to the venue

SIPA/REX

Bob Dylan's show was so low-key that even photographers were denied entry to the venue

With most big arena and stadium acts, it's abundantly evident from the off where your ticket money's gone: the likes of U2, Elton and the Stones flaunt their egos through giant stage sets replete with cantilevered walkways, cherry-picker cranes, mobile sub-stages, thunderous pyrotechnics and huge screens showing expensive home movies in between the magnified excerpts of what's actually happening on the stage. But not Bob Dylan. There are no fireworks, no choreographed stage manoeuvres, and no big screens at the O2 tonight; if you're a punter at the other end of the arena, all you can see is a small group of chaps wearing hats several hundred metres away.

To make matters worse, the chaps are clustered in a tight knot, seeking some degree of onstage intimacy in the vastness of the Dome. For a while, you might struggle to discern which of them is Bob Dylan himself, before realising he's the one on the far right behind the tiny electric organ, nattily attired in white jacket, dark trousers with the white stripe down the side, and what appears to be a white boater, as if ready for Henley, but on closer examination turns out to be a snazzy white Hickock hat. You can tell he's Bob because the rest of his band – the two guitarists, bassist, drummer, and the pedal steel guitarist just behind him – are all facing him, like spokes on an elliptical wheel.

The lack of showiness is Dylan's way of signalling that he knows what's important about himself, and what we're here to hear: it's not to be awed by stunts; it's to commune once again with that legacy which illuminates our times so well. And which we're immersed in, right from the start, courtesy of a swinging, bluesy take on "Maggie's Farm", and a heavily-accented waltz-time treatment of "The Times they are a-Changin'", on which Bob's hoarse, raw-throated vocal adds extra bite to the song's injunctions to not criticise what you can't understand, and get out of the new road if you can't lend your hand. It's followed, in typically wry manner, by its sly, polar opposite, "Things Have Changed", Dylan's offhand, disinterested delivery casually throwing away the kinds of lines lesser talents would kill for. As throughout the set, there's a smart clip to the beat, while the fiddle's descending melody emphasises the song's fatalistic tone. Something similar happens with "The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll", another waltz-time transposition with a fatalistic tone – though Dylan's characteristic throwaway delivery rather underplays the pay-off line about the killer's paltry six-month sentence.

There's nothing from the new album – Dylan still resolutely refusing to give bootleggers a head start on his new material, even though it's out on Monday – but plenty from the splendid Modern Times, including taut, whip-smart versions of "Rollin' and Tumblin'" and "The Levee's Gonna Break", an intimate, conversational "Workingman's Blues #2", and suitably relaxed cruises through "Thunder on the Mountain", "When the Deal Goes Down" and the balmy "Spirit on the Water". Of the other relatively recent songs, the most striking is a version of "'Til I Fell in Love with You" for which Bob comes out from behind the organ to throw a few languid shapes while essaying blues harmonica licks, like a supper-club cabaret singer.

The more recent material is interspersed with the usual sprinkling of old classics. The organ adds a dark undertow to a tragic "Ballad of Hollis Brown" nudged along by a persistent rhythm guitar motif, and the entire stage end of the arena is spattered with smudges of light to represent the "Chimes of Freedom" flashing. I'm not sure about Bob's organ break in "Highway 61 Revisited" – basically, he follows his patented lead guitar style, locating a counterpoint phrase and repeating it until it becomes almost the dominant melodic motif – but the standard set-closer/encore combination of "Like a Rolling Stone" and "All Along the Watchtower" works its usual magic, before the show closes with yet another re-casting of "Blowin' in the Wind", this time as a sort of slouchy soul-blues, reminiscent of "Backfield In Motion", which works rather better on stage than it sounds on paper.

Post a Comment

View all comments that have been posted about this article.

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.

Comments

Another great night
[info]karyobin1965 wrote:
Monday, 27 April 2009 at 06:22 am (UTC)
Saturday was the 38th time I've seen Dylan and there have been much better nights but that said there have been much much worse. Overall it was a good set although the sound guys took a few numbers to get the balance right. My only complaint of the night was the amount of people who talked through every number the applauded with gusto at the end of each song as if they had actually listened.

C
Not Disappointed - Just!
[info]johnlanc wrote:
Monday, 27 April 2009 at 09:52 am (UTC)
I have been a fan as long as I can remember but I have always shied away from seeing Dylan live through fear of disappointment and feeling let down. Whilst not on a par with the magnificent gig by Leonard Cohen at the RAH last November - I can happily say that I have seen my two main songwriting heroes in the space of 6 months and been entertained by both.
I concur with other reviewers that the sound in the O2 was at times appalling - lots of thundering echo that made it only possible to hear clearly if you cupped your hands round your ears.
My other main irritation was the constant stream of people traipsing like ants back and forth between their seats and the bar. Having forked out a tidy sum to be there, I'd have thought that people would have at least wish to pay some attention to the procedings - and if they were getting bored at least show some courtesy to those around them by not spoiling their evening. But maybe these far from intimate venues encourage the break down of manners.
Thanks Bob. Thanks for a good night out and now having not been disappointed once I may come and join you again sometime!
Genius
[info]clarice007 wrote:
Monday, 27 April 2009 at 11:04 am (UTC)
Did anyone else notice that it was in fact a John Brown version of the Ballad of Hollis Brown? It wasn't just any old "persistent rythm guitar motif", it was the John Brown motif. A Dylan mashup for our times.
I was there
[info]oksowhat wrote:
Monday, 27 April 2009 at 11:15 am (UTC)
I was there on Saturday evening, and so to be simple in my responce to the article, its all said in the few words, quote I would have paid the 80:00 pounds that the 2 seats had cost me and the 8 hours traveling to get there and back to have seen the same concert again, BUT I would have paid 100 times that amount and travelled to Australia & back to have seen a concert that resembled his performances from his 63 to 66 concerts close quote enough said.
The concert itself was highlighted for me by the fact that the man and his wife sitting next to me left the concert 6 songs before the end, in conversation with him before the concert I do believe he was expecting something special, the fact that he left early may have been a symptom of his expectations having not been met.
As I left my seat at the end of the concert to leave the O2 I was confronted by an obviously elated young women waving her hands in the air and shouting at the top of her voice her praises to Dylan, the young woman's expectations had obviously been met.
My expectations were met but then I'm a fan of 35 years & one of my regrets is that I never saw Dylan in the 60s and that's because I didn't start to listen until I was 30 years old and that's why Dylan can do no wrong for me because Its all about the lyrics not the performance expectations of the fans so Its alright Ma er sorry Dylan. Thanks Bob
Was I at the same performance?
[info]wobblyturkey wrote:
Monday, 27 April 2009 at 12:22 pm (UTC)
Having waited 25 years to see this great musician in the flesh, I was strangely dissapointed by the show. The acoustics were awful and I don't think his voice has improved with time. I prefered the original arrangements of his songs over those given here, wish I had skipped school and seen him in the 1960's.

Even so, I am pleased I have seen him at last, but comparing him to Leonard Cohen last year, both at Glastonbury and the O2, Leonard was so much better; he had me in tears twice, whereas Bob only had me in tears of boredom.

If I hadn't known this was Bob then I wouldn't have stayed until the end. So sad!

Sorry Bob, the times have changed but I will still appreciate your early albums!
Zimmer-man hides behind his frame!
[info]richardhackett wrote:
Monday, 27 April 2009 at 04:10 pm (UTC)
Far be it from me to be ageist but I felt that by retreating behind his keyboard for all but one song ( he may have emerged during the encores but we only stayed for All Along the Watchtower) that Dylan at 68 was using it to prop himself up and not engaging with his audience. The performance was lack lustre. The O2 arena is probably better suited to large scale shows and spectacles rather than the more intimate style of performance that Dylan chooses. I was sat on Row Z of level 1, which was a very long way from the stage and even with binoculars it was difficult to pick him out. The big hat distinguished him from the rest of the band but it also hid his face from view. He evoked an image of a bad amateur crooner in a working men?s club rather than the legend that he undoubtedly is.
Rollin? and Tumblin was more Groanin? and Mumblin? but I guess that was always the expectation of Dylan live. I have seen him on two other occasions, firstly at Earls Court in 1978 when the stage was also a long way from where I was seated but the charisma he oozed on that occasion has stayed with me for 30 years. Then I saw him at Portsmouth Guildhall about seven years ago, a very small venue, that was much more suited to his arrogant and snarling style. He was mesmerising and magnificent there.
Others have mentioned the poor sound quality, which may be a feature of the O2 arena. However I am sure that the Dylan entourage could have done more during the sound checks to ensure that those of us at the back at least had a fighting chance of distinguishing at least some of those fantastic lyrics.
I wish that I had known about the Roundhouse gig. I strikes me that it would have been a far more suitable venue for the man behind the keyboard.
The O2 show last Saturday did nothing for me and I am a life long fan.
My wife was attending a Dylan gig for the very first time. Her image of him before the gig was of the pre 1966 acoustic folkie. I had done as much as I could to dispel that. I am afraid that although she enjoyed herself she is not likely to become a fan of the present day Dylan on the strength of this gig. To have spent more than £200 to be at this event (this includes our train fares, Thames Clipper boat to the O2, a great way to arrive) was not money well spent and we left feeling truly disappointed. My wife had wanted to hear Blowin? in the Wind, which we missed in order to ensure that we caught the return boat to connect with our train. I feel sure that she would not have recognised it.

You Go Your Way and I'll Go Mine
[info]kevin_24 wrote:
Monday, 27 April 2009 at 04:12 pm (UTC)
You can never really be certain what a Dylan show will be like. Some shows can be finger lickin good and other shows can be arse wipingly bad, to paraphrase Rowan Atkinson. Last Saturday night, a call went out for more toilet paper!

I guess given the number of dates Bob does each year, performing at the O2 is for him, just another gig, just another pay day. Some days good, some days bad. But where does that leave us punters? Paying good money for old tat doesn?t sit well. We should expect more. Let me tell you, the show started badly with an almost apologetic introduction and it was all down hill from there. Okay, being in Desperation Row, and a long long way from the stage and with my eyes, guarantees that the performers will appear as mere dots down there. Fair enough but the stage was bad with all the team cluttered and bunched in the middle. So much wasted space and not enough going on to help focus the eye and generate visual impact. Bob hid behind the keyboard and it wasn?t until the second song that I discovered it was actually him! Up to that point I thought he was one of the guys on guitar. The sound was bad too. It was like listening to one of those live Bob bootlegs put down on a cheap portable cassette recorder.

Bob was bad. Awful, Shocking in fact. I strained to listen to the songs just as Bob strained to sing them. But it was no use. I couldn?t make out the songs he was singing let alone the words to them. Interest was waning. Think about it?, this was Bob Dylan, in the year 2009 at the O2 for Christs?sake. I left halfway through and got better value from the fiver I gave to a busker singing his heart out alongside the river. ?Can you play any Dylan stuff? I enquired. Of course he could and he could do it much better than Bob Dylan too.

I'll buy the new record and I'll still play the old stuff but would I go to another live performance. Tell you what Bob, You Go Your Way and I'll Go Mine.

Kevin
Dylan Concert at O2
[info]jackstone47 wrote:
Monday, 27 April 2009 at 04:32 pm (UTC)
The concert was most disappointing - the backing was just too loud and the words were inaudible. Dylan made no attempt to interact with his audience. At the prices charged we deserve more than what was dished out.

Jack
Dylan at The 02
[info]billerickie wrote:
Monday, 27 April 2009 at 10:05 pm (UTC)
Dylan was dreadful.Through his plodding re-arrangements and careless vocals,he did those great songs a massive disservice.Contemptuous of the audience - not a single word to the adoring crowd of 20,000 people,half of whom couldn't see him due to the fact that there were no big screens up - presumably that would have cost him too much money.
I've seen Dylan half-a-dozen times, am a long-time fan,but never again will I bother.
You can tell a great concert - the audience comes bouncing out afterwards.Happened last year when I saw Leonard Cohen,Neil Young,Coldplay. After Dylan they shuffled out,muted and disappointed.
Your reviewer must have been at another show, given his misguidedly generous appraisal.
Set List
[info]p_ting wrote:
Monday, 27 April 2009 at 10:36 pm (UTC)
Was "The Levee's Gonna Break" on the set list of the O2?
I don't remember it. My friends don't remember it.
It's not listed on Bob links http://www.boblinks.com/042509s.html
It's not listed at http://www.thespaghettiincident.com/search/label/bob%20dylan
Sheffield yes, O2 no.

Since it was a "...taut, whip smart version..." it should be a matter of record.
Bob Dylan O2
[info]jgp126 wrote:
Tuesday, 28 April 2009 at 11:06 am (UTC)
Having read the review and comments I am surprised at the overall favour with which the show is judged. Opening on Maggies Farm the vocals were the clearest I have heard from Dylan live in years and I was really up for the show - from then on he seemed intent on being as indecipherable as possible with an irritating inflection at the end of many lines adding to the ruination of many songs - too many songs from only average albums, a poor echoey muffled sound and no screens must have rendered the show almost unlistenable and certainly unwatchable with very dim lights and no screens for anyone in the back half of the hall. I had good seats and still felt strangely detached and not at all excited by this, my favourite artist of all time. In contrast Cohen from exactly the same seat was sublime, had the courtesy to speak to the crowd and honour his own work - Dylan sadly seemed to be taking the piss out of us and all those fantastic songs. Having seen him 15 or so times in 33 years I have sadly reached the end of the line - comparisons with the saga of the Emperors new clothes ring true - and yes Bob "you can't fool all of the people all of the time"
Very poor and sorry I went
[info]janice11 wrote:
Tuesday, 28 April 2009 at 02:47 pm (UTC)
I was at the O2 saturday performance, and people were walking out, I didnt think much of it, and I was a Dylan fan. He was dreadful, sorry but he was, I hadnt been to see him live before because I had read lots of bad reviews, now I wish I hadnt bothered,
i've got to say that although a bob fan if even his last ten years too, i find it difficult to hear
[info]mattstollar wrote:
Sunday, 3 May 2009 at 09:10 am (UTC)
i've got to say that although i am a bob fan and own all his albums and i like his stuff of the last ten years too esp time out of mind and love and theft, i fail to see any of his live performances, and i've seen four in as many years as much more than a man who can't really be bothered. i feel a musician should assume the audience has never heard the song before each time. Well really not helped by a muddy,boomy digital, bad wedding pa system only about 5% of dylan's words could be heard from my vantage point in a vip box. I really enjoyed one quarter of the show, thought one quarter was painnfull and the other half neither. Apart from a few relatively strong blues songs there was hardly anything to suggest his obssessive interest in roots music. there was nothing, nothing at all magical folky skillfull or even soulful in most of the musicianship. Dylan live could be so much better if someone with better taste was arranging the music, and if the words were as clear as they are on recent studio recordings. He no longers sings melodies but sings in the upper and lower octave of eight notes. Even the irritable pathos and desperate mood in the vocals seems 60% put on for effect. Pretty tragic

Matt Stollar

Most popular in Arts & Entertainment

Article Archive

Day In a Page

Sun | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat

Select date