Music

Rain (AM and PM) 6° London Hi 9°C / Lo 7°C

Michael Jackson: This Is It, Kenny Ortega, 112 mins, (PG)
Fleetwood Mac, MEN Arena, Manchester

Reviewed by Simon Price

Magic: Mick Fleetwood and Stevie Nicks

AFP / GETTY

Magic: John McVie and Stevie Nicks

The biggest musical event this week isn't a concert at all, but it's coming to a popcorn pit near you. By the time I'm writing this and you're reading it, Michael Jackson was meant to have performed 27 dates of his This Is It farewell show at the O2 in London, with a further 23 to follow in the spring.

Whether you believe he would even have made it this far without cancellations is a matter for personal conjecture. And it's a question that the feature film, cobbled together from his rehearsals at Los Angeles' Staples Center, only hints at answering.

The Star Wars scroll-up at the start tells us that This Is It was going to be "an entirely new concert experience". Entirely new? Not exactly. A very high-concept version of the existing concert experience, perhaps. But it's typical of the uncritical hyperbole that defines and dogs this documentary.

The main problem with This Is It lies in its choice of director: Kenny Ortega, the director of the stage show itself, who has cherry-picked the clips which make his production appear in the best possible light.

It would, unquestionably, have been a cracking concert: the dancers who pop up from below-stage at toaster speed, the black widow spider from which Jacko emerges in "Thriller", the appearance of an actual bulldozer for "Earth Song", the Zelig/Dead Men Don't Wear Plaid-style film preceding "Smooth Criminal" in which MJ is placed inside a montage of film-noir scenes (admiring Rita Hayworth in Gilda, dodging Bogey's bullets in Dead Reckoning, and so on).

But had the footage fallen somehow into the hands of an impartial documentarian, we might have seen a completely different film from the hagiography Ortega has given us.

The most fascinating scenes, nevertheless, are the candid moments in which Michael, bespectacled and studious, chomping on snacks or sucking on a lollipop, supervises auditions, oversees choreography on his laptop, bosses the band (who all call him "Sir") into making it "more funky" and admonishes them for "not letting it simmer!", while emphasising that his criticisms are always delivered "with the love, L.O.V.E".

His face, it's sad to say, looks like someone who's been in a fire, but his physical condition isn't as poor as one might expect. The 50-year-old was still super-mobile, as the awe-inspiring spin he throws into "The Way You Make Me Feel" proves, and his voice on "Human Nature" is out of this world. What he lacks, it seems, is stamina: he complains that he needs to save his voice rather than rehearse the outro of "Just Can't Stop Loving You", and can't hack a retake of the routine for "Beat It". Interestingly, the one character we never meet is Dr Conrad Murray, dosing Jacko up and pushing his body to the limit to meet AEG's concert schedule.

Despite the stress he's under, at no point does the King of Pop kick off, throw his toys out of pram or reach the end of his tether. Instead, he spends his down-time delivering a softly-spoken soliloquy on climate change. Maybe he really is that saintly. We'll never know, because Ortega's sometimes inspiring, but mostly somewhat sad film is ultimately – no apologies for the pun – a whitewash.

If she didn't mean it, it wouldn't work. Stephanie Lynn Nicks may have been working as a waitress in a cocktail bar when Fleetwood Mac found her, and cleaning the producer's toilets to pay for her first record, but the buck-toothed blonde from Phoenix never stopped imagining herself as a Welsh witch goddess.

Thirty-five years on, she hasn't ceased: swishing about in a bat-winged cape and a diamante half-moon pendant, and bleating about a "woman taken by the sky". Mystery-and-magic isn't merely an act for Stevie. She believes it, and bless her to bits for that.

If Stevie on a British stage is what really sends the hackles tingling for the faithful, then it's only in the context of a truly stunning Fleetwood Mac concert. Her foil and sometime lover Lindsey Buckingham, spindly-legged and still offensively handsome, is a fast-fingertipped phenomenon on guitar. His solo spots for "Big Love" and "Oh Well" are breathtaking; the title track of his 1979 folly Tusk is so berserk you can almost taste the Hollywood A-grade in your septum.

Together, they conjure such an electricity that the rhythm section John McVie and Mick Fleetwood, whose British blues band was transformed by the Buckingham-Nicks takeover in 1974, can only stand and watch. "I think I had met my match," she sings in the sublime "Sara", and she looks at him with lazy eyes. He catches the glance, and bites his lip. As the song ends, they waltz and he kisses her hair. It must drive their current partners insane. Because it sure as hell sends a shiver through everyone else.

Post a Comment

View all comments that have been posted about this article.

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.

Comments

MJ This is it: Breath of Fresh Air.
[info]yarifrif wrote:
Sunday, 1 November 2009 at 03:48 am (UTC)
Thank heavens for Ortega's 'Cherry picking', better than the usual cherry picking by the media. If you still want all that, you have over 30 years of negative 'hyperbole' to go back and choose from, from global media archive material. Seeing snippits of Jackson creatively interact with my own eyes and ears and without all the judgemental editing of the media, was a breath of fresh air.
People are still narrow minded...
[info]cyberjackson wrote:
Sunday, 1 November 2009 at 08:53 am (UTC)
Michael Jackson was an inspirational person, and very talented. He cared so much about everything and gave so much to this world..and people still knocked him down. In my opinion I think he was beautiful and attractive, and I think people were jealous of Michael, because he had it all.. the charisma, beauty, talent, charm, he was humble, funny, and last but NOT least.. he had LOVE. He gave love more than he recieved. My about him could go on forever. I'm just saying, in this movie you get to see all of that. The DVD isn't out yet, and there is a ton of extra footage to see. So it won't be just the "cherry picked" scenes. I know that id Michael was here, he wouldn't want the public to see this because he was such a perfectionist, but I'm sure that if his fans need that last glimpse of him, he would be ok with it. I wish everyone would stop being so negative..and for once let this man shine this one last time. The movie was bittersweet, and brilliant. People should go check it out!
Michael was amazing.
[info]cyberjackson wrote:
Sunday, 1 November 2009 at 09:15 am (UTC)
I wish the media would stop being so negative about Michael. I saw "This Is It" and thought it was a brilliant film and bittersweet at the same time. Michael was in his element and he still had it.
In my opinion (and many others) Michael was attractive and had a beauty about him. I think he was a threat - he was the opposite of the typical American idea of "masculinity" and totally threatened the American macho mentality.
I honestly think men felt threatened by him, and their recourse was to tear him down in this way and try to emasculate him.
When really, Michael was more of a man than any of them could ever hope to be.
So please stop it about his looks for once.
Also an another note, the DVD hasn't been released yet, and there is supposed to be tons of extra footage..so it won't be just the "cherry picked" scenes. It was raw footage and real. If Michael was alive, he would cringe at the thought of his unfinished work being seen by the public..but if his fans need that last glimpse of him he would be ok with it. He was understanding, caring, sexy, talented, very funny, and most of all he had LOVE..and he had plenty of that to give. I think people should go see this movie and take a closer look. Remember: it was only rehearsals! He was a perfectionist! Long live the King of Pop and forever may he reign...
Re: Michael was amazing.
[info]cyberjackson wrote:
Sunday, 1 November 2009 at 09:23 am (UTC)
I din't mean to post twice..I thought one didn't go through!LOL oops!
A gentleman-Mj
[info]malcyannie wrote:
Sunday, 1 November 2009 at 09:53 am (UTC)
One thing which comes through in the movie is the lack of pride and egoism on MJ's part. His gentle nature, kindheartedness and love for his co-workers is visible. He does not use any harsh words while dealing with mistakes made.Such is Superstar Michael!
With all the negative things written about him and faced by him, a lesser man would have crumbled. A gift from above, we have trampled him to the ground. Media is largely to blame and still tries to do so.We have to remember that this movie is only a rehearsal hence there will be hitches.MJ is a man who was not afraid to say "I love you!" to us his fans.Nowadays where using the F word is the rage, his songs are devoid of profanity and only in the scream video do we have a blanked out F word.Thank you ,Michael for your love for the people of the world. I am a fan from India, a third world country.
At least get the facts straight
[info]miaula wrote:
Sunday, 1 November 2009 at 02:20 pm (UTC)
I couldn't agree with what cyberjackson writes more re: Michael's appearance and the threat he posed to conventional masculinity. I thought he looked beautiful in the movie. And your criticisms of his appearance are particularly horrible: looks like he'd been in a fire? Good Lord. The "white" "pun" also in extremely bad taste: Michael suffered from vitiligo (now confirmed by many sources). And Mr Price, you need to get the facts right: he did, in fact, repeat the last dance sequence in the rehearsal of Beat It; the band does _not_ call him "sir" all the time; and he is not "complaining" that he needs to save his voice: this is the reality for singers, especially professional singers who are not going to be stupid enough to give it all in rehearsals! If you watch the rehearsals for the Dangerous Tour, you will see almost exactly the same kind of process--in fact, it looks to me like Michael was giving more in rehearsals for this concert than he did 25 years ago. And this show did appear to break the mould for popular music concerts: 3D movies, "ghosts" fluttering throughout the audience; costumes that light up. This is not exactly standard fare.
Did We View the Same Film?
[info]whilome wrote:
Sunday, 1 November 2009 at 10:13 pm (UTC)
"What he lacks is stamina." Michael was shown repeatedly asking to do something "one more time" and in one sequence, vigorously slamming his body up and down with more strength than the dancers around him half his age.
--and his colleagues called him "MJ". No matter. The derision dripping from this "review" simply underscores how the media lives to feed on others. Michael Jackson's legacy will outlast the musings of Simon Price.
Schoolboy error
[info]np40 wrote:
Sunday, 1 November 2009 at 10:25 pm (UTC)
That's John McVie in the photo.. you really should know that Mick Fleetwood is a drummer if you're publishing an article on Fleetwood Mac. Pretty poor show.
[info]joriginaloak wrote:
Saturday, 7 November 2009 at 10:20 pm (UTC)
Tipical independent drivel from another wet passionless hac. If you didn't see that the real Michael was totally spellbinding and for want of a better word truly Awesome! Then you need to get down from your sequined art-house bubble in which you spend your life frothing at the mouth over eastern european men swanning around in skin tight lycra and get involved with the real world. Art and performance does not begin and end in a ballet house, opera theatre or circus in your case. Michael is and was the greatest performing artist and musician of our generation and probably of all time because dude if your approach to life, writing drivel about people so far out of your league, is anything to gauge the future generation by then there is no hope for anyone. You really need a little more than a degree in journalism or a media studies diploma to talk or walk with the Gods because MJ was a Musical God next to you. To be a respected or even noticable critique on a subject you should at the very least need to have a reputation within such circles to gain any true knowledge on the subject, i bet the nearest you have come to any talent is the performance of Joseph or was it the donkey in the christmas nativity where you ran off crying cos you forgot your script. The Movie is and always was meant to be positive footage for MJ to keep and study for himself and his family however that wasnt to be. What it does show and prove that even at 50 he could and would have put on the best show the earth had ever seen. Something you with your pathetic £60,000 anual salary, if at all that, will never have anything to look back on except dark seedy nightmares to see you into your retirement of how you never acheived your potential but how you tried to ruin others attempts to offer something back to humanity. You disgust me how you believe that your sad little life somehow gives you the right to spread garbage and how you believe your oppinion is valid to the rest of us just because you have the independent? You are nothing but a faceless pathetic unsavoury cretin that society needs to be very thankful that thats all you are. Why dont you do something constructive with your life instead of spewing that inane din upon us all? Become a doctor or an architect or something even an accountant has a use but hacs are about as useful as a gay man in a brothel...your oppinion's worth diddly!

Most popular in Arts & Entertainment

Article Archive

Day In a Page

Sun | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat

Select date