TV & Radio

Rain (AM and PM) 5° London Hi 9°C / Lo 7°C

Red Riding: Yorkshire noir on TV

Channel 4's trilogy of films based on David Peace's 'Yorkshire noir' novels, will shock even seasoned viewers of crime drama, says Gerard Gilbert

Red Riding: Never before has it been quite so ravishingly grim up north

Channel 4

Red Riding: Never before has it been quite so ravishingly grim up north

British TV audiences are no strangers to the bad behaviour of fictional police officers, whether it's the off-duty copper slapping his wife in Z Cars (sensational in its day) or the Scotland Yard "bad apple" taking backhanders in G F Newman's drama Law and Order (equally sensational back in 1978). But nothing will have quite prepared us for Red Riding, a trilogy of fictional dramas set in Yorkshire in the Seventies and Eighties that suggests that West Yorkshire Police tortured and murdered people. As John Stalker, who was Assistant Chief Constable of Greater Manchester Police in 1980 and headed the inquiry into the RUC's "shoot-to-kill" policy in Northern Ireland, told Radio Times: "It's the most shocking portrayal of a named force I've ever seen."

Indeed it is. Based on the acclaimed quartet of "Yorkshire noir" novels by David Peace, Red Riding is a febrile, almost hallucinatory account of police corruption and brutality set against a backdrop of the hunt for the Yorkshire Ripper. Peace, whose The Damned United, a fictionalised account of the football manager Brian Clough's 44-day reign at Leeds United, has also been turned into a forthcoming film, suggests further reading to those who feel he has been exaggerating. "I recommend The History and Practice of the Political Police in Britain by Tony Bunyan, Error of Judgement: the Truth about the Birmingham Bombings by Chris Mullin or Bloody Valentine: a Killing in Cardiff by John Williams. Or anything by the late Paul Foot."

The three films that emerged out of Peace's four novels, have been adapted by Tony Grisoni, who has the screenplay of Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas among his credits. Each film is named after a different year, starting with 1974 and continuing in successive weeks with 1980 and 1983. Some of the characters (played by a lip-smacking cast that includes Sean Bean, Andrew Garfield, Maxine Peake, David Morrissey, Paddy Considine and Rebecca Hall) turn up in more than one of the films.

"I started reading 1974, and from the first unsettling parody of a fallen angel to the final Jacobean shoot-out, I did not stop to take breath,"says Grisoni. "I plunged into the other three novels... They read like an English James Ellroy cut with Stan Barstow and drenched in the occult sensibilities of an Iain Sinclair. We're talking eternal perdition and the possibility of redemption. Dickens on bad acid."

A heady brew, and Grisoni had a four-hour meeting with David Peace, who now lives in Tokyo, in a "seedy London hotel – his choice". Thereafter, their dialogue continued in cyberspace. "Looking back over our communication, I notice: 'For me, the books were about nature vs nurture: did the time, the place and the society of West Yorkshire give birth to Peter Sutcliffe or was West Yorkshire just unlucky..."

Sutcliffe, the Yorkshire Ripper, appears (played by Joseph Mawle) in the middle film, 1980. And while Sutcliffe's malevolent shadow hangs over the trilogy, other real-life cases also inspired Peace's fiction. In Red Riding, a simple man, Michael Myshkin, is fitted up by the police for the abduction and killing of a child. In November 2007, a story broke that exonerated Stefan Kiszko, who had spent 16 years in prison for the murder of a young girl in 1976 and died months after his release.

"David Peace said the Kiszko case was a tragic source of inspiration," says Tony Grisoni. "Throughout the development of these scripts, we were haunted by reality that seemed to mirror the fiction: Stephen Lawrence, Madeleine McCann, Natascha Kampusch, Shannon Matthews, Josef Fritzl, the Yorkshire Ripper hoaxer... Sometimes, it was difficult to tell the real world from the dark fictions we were weaving."

Which will no doubt be a criticism levelled at Red Riding. What should not be questioned is the artistic integrity of the work, which has been produced by Michael Winterbottom's Revolution Films. Each part of the trilogy is a startlingly original piece of work. And each is helmed by a different director: Julian Jarrold (Brideshead Revisited), James Marsh (director of the wonderful, Oscar-winning documentary Man on Wire) and Anand Tucker (Hilary and Jackie). "I think we had one meeting where we sat down and tried to make sense of the whole thing," says Jarrold. "And then we said, 'Sod that – let's do our own thing.'"

And never before has it been quite so ravishingly grim up north. Anton Corbijn came pretty close in Control, his beautifully framed 2007 biopic of Joy Division's Ian Curtis.

"I wanted lots of modern, concrete buildings... lots of geometric shapes," says James Marsh, who directed 1980. "I wanted to offset the formality and coldness of these backdrops with lots of warm greens, browns and yellows."

Each director shot with different film stock, Marsh using 35mm ("more forgiving in low light") while Anand Tucker shot 1983 in anamorphic widescreen ("I wanted to make it as cinematic as possible"). Julian Jarrold opted for Super 16 film for 1974, which gave him "a grainy quality, which could dominate and imprison the characters", he says. "We went for a colour we all associate with the Seventies, which is slightly brownish and muted. What I didn't want to do was to go down the Life on Mars route and plaster it with pop songs of the periods."

Jarrold's film, 1974, opens the trilogy, telling of an ambitious young fictional Yorkshire Post journalist, Eddie Dunford, investigating the disappearance of a local schoolgirl. Dunford is played by Andrew Garfield, the Bafta-winning star of Channel 4's Boy A, who gives another magnetic performance here as a cocky reporter getting out of his depth amid civic and police corruption. "I wasn't born until 1983," he says. "It was great exploring the period – the cars, the clothes... It was fascinating – the clothes of the time make you move differently, they give you a real swagger."

Dunford's nemesis is a big-shot property developer, John Dawson, played by Sean Bean, who tells me he went all Method, deliberately gaining weight for the role. It's an unexpected and wonderfully menacing performance, more The Sopranos than Sharpe and very different from Bean's dashing heroes or stock Hollywood villains. "As soon as I read the scripts, I knew this was something different that I could really get my teeth into," he says.

The big-name cast were thrown together in a thoroughly democratic manner while on location in Leeds and Bradford. "We decided not to offer trailers or private dressing rooms to the cast," says Red Riding's producer, Wendy Brazington. "We know that if you can get it right, it can lead to a very convivial atmosphere."

"I thoroughly enjoyed it; we all did," says Sean Bean. "There was a lot of laughter, which permeated the set, because it was a case of if we didn't laugh, we'd cry."

'Red Riding' begins on Channel 4 tomorrow night at 9pm

Murder he wrote: The cast

John Dawson (Sean Bean)

The sadistic head of a construction and property firm, Dawson has a lot of important people in his pocket and may or may not be involved in the case of the missing schoolgirls.

Eddie Dunford (Andrew Garfield)

A cocky but determined young 'Yorkshire Post' reporter returned to his home turf after an unsuccessful stint on Fleet Street. Dunford's crusade to crack the story about three abducted schoolgirls leads to his undoing.

Paula Garland (Rebecca Hall)

The mother of one of the missing schoolgirls, Garland is a fragile divorcee who is instantly attracted to Eddie Dunford, the journalist who's asking too many questions. Unfortunately she's also a plaything of violent property magnate John Dawson.

Helen Marshall (Maxine Peake)

Marshall is chosen by Peter Hunter to work beside him on the secret inquiry into the West Yorkshire police's handling of the Ripper case. The two admire each other and share some history, but will they cross the line professionally?

Peter Hunter (Paddy Considine)

Reportedly based on the real-life John Stalker, Hunter is Assistant Chief Constable of the Manchester Police, who has been asked to head a secret Home Office inquiry into the Ripper investigation. Cooperation isn't forthcoming.

Detective Inspector Maurice Jobson (David Morrissey)

Aka "the owl" – the bespectacled Jobson hero-worships his boss, Bill Molloy, aka "the badger" – a deeply corrupt superintendent played by Warren Clarke. Only too late does Jobson realise that his hero has feet of clay.

Post a Comment

View all comments that have been posted about this article.

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.

Comments

Waste of Space
[info]rdt22 wrote:
Friday, 6 March 2009 at 08:48 pm (UTC)
We watched this last night; we thought it was rubbish; just read critics reviews - can't believe what I've seen. Maybe TV drama is so poor these days that the TV 'experts' (average age 25, media studies grads) think anything with half a storyline is 'essential viewing'.
As ex-pat Tykes. we were really looking forward to this series - but can't understand why almost everyone in this 'dark Yorkshire Drama' is a Lancastrian!! What an insult! Shan't be watching any more episodes - just an x-rated Inspector Morse. Two hours of our free time wasted - wish I'd done the ironing instead.
[info]tomoleeds wrote:
Saturday, 7 March 2009 at 07:08 pm (UTC)
A NICE CHANGE TO WATCH SOMETHING DIFFRENT,ALL WE HAVE AT PRESENT ARE BORING SOAPS,OR HOUSE PROGRAMMES;AT TIMES RED RIDING IS BLEAK,BUT ONCE YOU GOT INTO IT ,YOU WANTED MORE.SEAN BEAN AND THE REST OF THE CAST ARE EXCELLENT.
red riding
[info]bonzor wrote:
Saturday, 7 March 2009 at 11:57 pm (UTC)
having lived through the seventies unlike most of the pro reviewers who liked it, it was a time of colour and shape. Not muted, not brown, that was the fifties. Pathetic trick, film through the thickest of gauze to take us back in time. Junk. It didn't rain all the time, the cops weren't any worse or any better than anywhere else and the dialogue was laughable."We've got to get out of Yorkshire' Ask yourself, have you ever heard anyone talk about getting out of a county. Yorkshire was so parochial and divided no such notion existed. Life was based around your town. As for the bloodbath and gore. Just poor mans Hollywood. The film was so bad its untrue. Sean Bean was a cardboard cutout villain better suited to panto. The mix of fiction and fact simply did not work as any credibility was eroded. Cartoon caricatures, sets better suited to hell than a real place and locations so grim as to be like the famous Monty Python sketch about being brought up in the gutter and living in a cardboard box. Pure unadulterated junk.
red riding 1974
[info]elitest101 wrote:
Monday, 9 March 2009 at 09:13 am (UTC)
I couldnt even watch this all the way through, much as I love Sean Bean and I loved John Dawsons houe, the unremitting nastiness and gratuitous violence turned my stomach one too many times
[info]neilpspain wrote:
Thursday, 12 March 2009 at 11:19 pm (UTC)
I have ried this twice now and wont be coming back. It was undewhelming in its tawdryness subtituting a good story-line, pace, good acting with a mess that was even too bad to be funny.
Red Riding
[info]pand69 wrote:
Friday, 13 March 2009 at 03:49 pm (UTC)
I don't think any of you bloggers get this!! What a shame...... It is fantastic!! I remember the seventies and eighties, I was a little girl, i'm 40 this year. I remember the ripper on the loose, it was really frightening, my mum worked at the off-licence in the evenings, I was terrified she would be his next victim. Over dramatic imagination you might think, but, rationality aside, that was how affected you became, due to news reports, etc. I also lived and still live, in a small lancashire town. I remember new housing estates going up, I get the colours and atmosphere that is being portrayed. I love this trilogy, although terrifying, it is strangely familier. I can't wait for the conclusion next week. Wish they had done the missing year, not sure which it is? Will read books at some point and get further submerged into i'm sure, far murkier waters of police corruption.
Re: Red Riding
[info]mrreasonable wrote:
Tuesday, 17 March 2009 at 04:00 pm (UTC)
I watched the first episode and expected great things -I was disappointed.

The production has a certain style and captures some of the period detail well, even if Life on Mars/Ashes to Ashes did very similar with more laughs. It reminds me of programmes my parents used to watch that involved subtlety and not necessarily a happy ending.

My disappointment stemmed from the fact that the 'plot' was all over the place, rushed in places and even the 'good' characters aren't appealing enough for the viewer to care about them. The 'love interest' story was dealt with very clumsily. Fundamentally, the whole programme tried to be too clever and failed.

I watched the second episode and, although I thought it was slightly better, I was disappointed a second time for the same reasons.

Is this a case of the "Emperor's New Clothes"?


Is it worth enduring the final episode?
[info]neilpspain wrote:
Friday, 13 March 2009 at 04:16 pm (UTC)
My comment is not about the reality. And by the way it was the Yorkshire Ripper not the lancashire Ripper. My comment is about the writing, the direction, the acting and the entire execution of this project. Frankly all are bad and hamming up the real story. Dreary result from very good real material.And the use of grainy film is so trite. This was money badly spent.Compare the film Valkyrie where we all know the outcome but they maintain the suspense to the end.This was a classic case of watching something hoping it will get better.
[info]pand69 wrote:
Saturday, 14 March 2009 at 05:35 pm (UTC)
I knew someone would spot that! (Lancashire and Yorkshire). Where I live in Lancashire, tis only a hop across the pennines. I don't agree..
Red Riding
[info]fi_mac0 wrote:
Tuesday, 17 March 2009 at 07:05 pm (UTC)
Gripping,tense,dark drama. Can't wait to see 1983. Top acting and directing. Thankyou Channel 4.
Red Riding
[info]roysrant wrote:
Friday, 20 March 2009 at 10:26 am (UTC)
I watched the first episode, missed the second but caught in on demand, then watched the third to see how all the pieces fall into place. It was unremitting in its condemnation of how the line between good and bad had been blurred. Portraying things how they really were does make for uncomfortable viewing.

I'm sure West Yorkshire Police were not alone in their approach to policing in the 70's and 80's - many examples of the corruption and violence used by other forces are now well documented. Indeed more cases about how the police thought they have their man and "made sure" the evidence fitted this pop up each week.

I remember cases like George Davis, The Black Panther, Yorkshire Ripper. Life was hard and unrelenting, but the thing I liked is that almost all the population were in the same boat - struggling to exist in the face of severe economic conditions. Power cuts, 3 day week, Miners strikes, IRA bombings etc etc. We now seem to have an elite group of society who feel they are more deserving and better than the rest of us!

Excellent show, complex and honest.


Unpalatable yes, but still food for thought
[info]mudeford wrote:
Saturday, 28 March 2009 at 03:18 pm (UTC)
Interesting to note how polarised opinions have been on Red Riding. As a northerner settled in Wales I probably was motivated by the setting and cast list alone to watch the first of the trilogy; it felt menacing, confusing, disturbing and somehow also strangely familiar. Having watched all three parts I would have preferred more clarity in understanding the time frame of some scenes and the 'back-story' to how D I Jobson and Supt Molloy became 'the owl' and 'the badger', perhaps because I'm more used to linear storytelling. Despite this I haven't watched any television in recent years that comes close to it in terms of compelling drama. I found myself recalling the late seventies of my teen years and the sense of fear that seemed inherent in every ride on the bus past Bramhall Lane, or the centre of Sheffield on a weekend when the miners were on the march, let alone when the Ripper was in every newspaper. It's a huge testament to the series that it brought back how much things seemed to be out of control at the time.
NOT IMPRESSED
[info]rachel_81 wrote:
Friday, 3 April 2009 at 07:37 pm (UTC)
I was very excited when I saw the advertising for Red Riding. I had heard the books were gripping with twisted stories and morbid yet fascinating characters. I am a massive Sean Bean fan as he is a fabulous actor with excellent ability to lose himself in the parts he plays and is highly original. Yet I was hugely disappointed with the way the characters in this series were portrayed and wasnt exactly blown away with his performance. Slightly wooden with an air of 'I'll put in half the effort I usually do through lack of interest.' With all the drivel we have on the television a the moment including soaps and the usual house sales programmes I was hoping for something different to make me want to watch television again. Sadly it didnt happen. A shame as there was some good actors starring in this and it had the potential storyline for some excellent television. I will learn not to get my hopes up next time!!!
not a depiction of what actually happened
[info]mkd83 wrote:
Monday, 18 May 2009 at 11:40 pm (UTC)
This was an adaption of a serie of books based around the events of these years. the films are brilliant and a very good adaption of the books. The films never claim to be factual but merely a story loosely based around the big police cases of the time. Take time to watch these film from this persepctive, ignore the facts not being correct and you may see them in a different light!

I think the use of different filming materials worked really well, if you watch a TV program from the 70's its a grainier with more emphasis on cetrain colours. I dont think the directors were trying to make the films look life in the 70s /80s did, i think they were making them look like they were films made during that time, making them appear more authentic and therefore believable

For me, the first 2 film were a work of art, unfortunately i missed the 3rd and have just bought the trilogy on DVD - if its half as good as the first 2 it will be an amazing film

Most popular in Arts & Entertainment

Article Archive

Day In a Page

Sun | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat

Select date