- Friday 24 May 2013
- My Account
- Logout
- Register
- Login
- News
-
Voices
-
Find by writer
- Yasmin Alibhai-Brown
- Rebecca Armstrong
- Memphis Barker
- Terence Blacker
- Chris Blackhurst
- David Blanchflower
- Archie Bland
- Ian Burrell
- Andrew Buncombe
- Ben Chu
- Patrick Cockburn
- Laura Davis
- Mary Dejevsky
- Grace Dent
- Robert Fisk
- Andrew Grice
- Stefano Hatfield
- Philip Hensher
- Ian Herbert
- Howard Jacobson
- Ellen E Jones
- Alice Jones
- Owen Jones
- Simon Kelner
- Dominic Lawson
- Donald Macintyre
- Lisa Markwell
- Comment
- Campaigns
- Debate
- Editorials
- Letters
- IV Drip
- Archive
- Our Voices
- Commentators
- Columnists
- Democracy 2015
- IV Drip Archive
-
Find by writer
- Sport
- Tech
- Life
- Property
- Arts & Ents
- Travel
- Money
- IndyBest
- Blogs
- Student
Monday 7 November 2011
Letter from Simon Kelner: Just look to the Lords for a better class of debate
You can spend many a happy hour engrossed in Hansard, the verbatim account of what happens in the Mother of Parliaments. I particularly commend to you the debates held in the House of Lords, where men and women of an independent mind (largely), great experience of the world (in the main), and impressive eloquence and erudition (with the exception of Lord Prescott) do vital work for democracy in acting as a check and a balance to the first chamber.
Speeches are generally shorter, and much more to the point, than those in the House of Commons, and as a result can be more enlightening, and indeed entertaining. There are some of Britain's best public speakers among our noble Lords, people who can command serious fees for an after-dinner turn.
I seem to recall that it was at one such event where I heard my favourite parliamentary story. It concerns Lord Annan, who was a leading figure in the movement to liberalise homosexuality.
Shortly after achieving success in the Lords, the following week he backed a bill to protect badgers. This was roundly defeated.
"I can't understand it," he said to one of his fellow Peers. "We vote to protect homosexuals, but not badgers."
"I think you'll find," his colleague answered, "there are very few badgers in the House of Lords."
This type of insouciant humour, however, might be a thing of the past. A Peer of my acquaintance (see how easy it is to slip into the lingo) said to me the other day that there is a widespread concern that the exchanges across the benches are becoming rather too similar to those in the Commons. They are a little bit "shouty", was the description.
The blame was laid on the recent intake of Lords, people who were invited to wear the ermine in recognition of loyal service to their political masters.
The Lords is about politics, of course, but it's about a whole lot more besides: culture, history and tradition. Not to mention the odd surprise. For instance, last week you could hear the creator of Downton Abbey defend the proliferation of advert breaks during the programme.
"It is wrong to present advertising as a sort of hideous evil that wrecks the programmes it appears in," said Julian (Lord) Fellowes.
He added that with the advertising revenue came the freedom to make the programme as the creators wanted. Well, that's a view. I always thought that it was the freedom from commercial concerns that brought the best out of creative minds.
Anyway, for the time being, it's all over. That's Downton, not the Lords, although the two institutions have much in common. They hark back to a time when manners were better and public discourse was of a higher quality.
It's a shame, however, that it's only the fictional Lords that the nation seems to care about.
-
Woolwich: The EDL were camped outside my house
Emily Jupp -
Woolwich is only the latest act of barbarism: Muslims, we must take on this cancer in our midst
Ali Miraj -
The Daily Cartoon
-
Woolwich murder: They killed, then they performed - these men should be starved of our attention
Frank Furedi -
Woolwich attack: The EDL will seek to exploit this evil crime for their own evil ends
Jamie Lewis
Get your summer started with British Military Fitness
BMF is the UK’s biggest and best loved outdoor fitness classes
Visit York
Find out what The Independent's resident travel expert has to say about one of the most beautiful small cities in the world
Making reading fun for kids
Nook is donating eReaders to volunteers at high-need schools and participating in exclusive events throughout the campaign.
Introducing the 'Get Reading' campaign
Get the latest on The Evening Standard's campaign to get London's children reading.
Enter the latest Independent competitions
Win anything from gadgets to five-star holidays on our competitions and offers page.
Business videos from commercial thought leaders
Watch the best in the business world give their insights into the world of business.
Simon Kelner
-
The popularity of the Chelsea Flower Show isn't waning - but perhaps it could widen?
-
What a kiss can tell us about the Royal Family - and our own stiff upper-lip
-
We can't turn back the online shopping tide, but we can change the way we think about high streets
-
There's a warmth in the air and it can only mean one thing - wedding season is upon us
Related Articles
-
Simon Calder's Helpdesk: Have I been overcharged for this minor Emirates booking change?
-
New Manchester City manager must deliver five trophies in five years
-
Ben Chu: Why isn't a global tax on multinational profits on the agenda for G8?
-
Mark Bridger tells Mold Crown Court he can't remember where he put April Jones' body
Get the best in opinion from Independent Voices, straight to your inbox every Thursday lunchtime.
Subscribe
Amol Rajan
A weekly update from the Editor
Day In a Page
The man who's eaten everywhere
A Berliner in 1963 – but did John F Kennedy once admire Adolf Hitler?
Banned Iranian director to attend Cannes Film Festival
The 10 Best salt and pepper sets
Ferran Soriano: Predicting success if Manchester City 'vision' is followed
Edward VIII’s phone calls - and how MI5 bugged them