i Editor's Letter: Let us focus not on remembrance, but on repentance


Click to follow
The Independent Online

Amiens, Ypres, Morbecque,  Thélus, Thiepval, Arras, Hamburg,  Terlincthun, Paddington – the final resting places of the 11 men from my street who died fighting the Great War. The youngest lost his life at 19, the oldest was 40.

The blanket censorship of  1914-15 stopped the British  public from being told what was  happening while their men were marched off to the Front. Kitchener’s conspiracy to hide the casualties and the existence of the trenches led to propaganda so inept that the US President  Roosevelt felt obliged to intervene.

When reporters were  eventually allowed to the Front – working under the censor’s veto – the Telegraph’s Phillip Gibbs incensed Kitchener and was threatened with being shot, while the Mail’s Henry Hamilton Fyfe, facing arrest, joined the French Red Cross as a stretcher-bearer to continue his reporting. It took the return of wounded troops for the reality of trench warfare to reach the public.

At Westminster Abbey  yesterday, the Very Reverend Dr John Hall told the congregation:   “Our focus is not tonight on remembrance. In solemnly commemorating the centenary of the outbreak of the First World War, as we reflect on the failure of the human spirit that led to an inexorable slide into war, let us spend a moment in silent repentance.”

i reader Chris Wood of Haddenham, Bucks, writes with a similar point, and recalls Carl Sandburg’s timeless, unforgiving “Grass”.

That poem begins with an entreaty to “pile the bodies  high... I am the grass; I cover all..  Pile them high at Ypres and Verdun...”


Twitter: @olyduff