Letter: Teenage misfits
Sir: The goth movement is not "obsessed with satanism and medieval torture" ("The misfits who killed for kicks", 22 April). That is a wildly inaccurate description of a complicated (and popular) American subculture.
The goth "movement" - which is a misnomer - is a style of music (often moody, melodic, slow electronic music with an abundance of minor chords - not Marilyn Manson, but bands like Bauhaus), a style of dress (wearing a lot of black, copying Victorian styles and 19th-century arcana) and a social group. It is not an exclusively American movement.
Satanism and the goth movement are not synonymous. Many "goths" are teenagers, to whom satanism has a certain rebellious appeal, but are not in any way dangerous people.
If you're going to link these boys with a subculture, the militia movement is far more accurate, with its obsession with war games and guns, than the goth movement. Most "goths" I have known spend their time writing abysmal poetry and traipsing through graveyards, trying to look poetic and pale.
They are mostly social misfits who can find acceptance in a subculture with very different social norms from the rest of American teenage society. What better way to rebel against the sunny disposition of the jock/cheerleader stereotype than by cultivating a calculated depression?
ALICE MARWICK
Seattle, Washington, USA
Subscribe to Independent Premium to bookmark this article
Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Premium subscription today.
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies