It's not just British pop that's succumbing to a tide of stage-school moppets who wannabe the next Kids From Fame; as those terrifying clips of the pre-teen Britney confirm, the same principles dominate American pop too. Though still only 21, Aaliyah is a veteran of the system, her R Kelly-produced début album Age Ain't Nothing But A Number having been recorded in 1994 while she was a student at the Detroit High School For The Performing Arts. This third offering breaks a five-year silence, during which many presumed that the ravages of adolescence must have wreaked terminal damage on her voice/looks/career, though in actual fact she was starting her acting career (of course). Produced partly by Timbaland, and partly by newcomers like Rapture & E Seats, expert replicators of the Timbaland twitchy-swingbeat style, Aaliyah has little to add to the course of modern R&B, featuring as it does the efficient but ineffectual presentation of the usual small selection of commands, complaints and romantic entreaties. Unfortunately, she lacks the character to animate them in a distinctive manner, sounding indistinguishable from her competitors – though this will undoubtedly be more than enough to satisfy most punters. As for Missy Elliott's absurdly over-praised songwriting skills, someone should tell her that the query "Can I talk to you?" is the most depressing phrase a man can hear, and that starting a chorus with it is guaranteed to kill the mood. Any mood.
Subscribe to Independent Premium to bookmark this article
Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Premium subscription today.
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies