Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

Skeleton Tree, Nick Cave & the Bad Seeds, first listen review: A beautiful, shatteringly visceral portrait of grief

There is no theatrical swagger here; Cave’s experience of bereavement is blisteringly undiluted 

Jess Denham
Friday 09 September 2016 14:51 BST
Nick Cave writing songs at the piano in his documentary film ‘One More Time With Feeling’
Nick Cave writing songs at the piano in his documentary film ‘One More Time With Feeling’

“How on earth do you award aesthetic points to a 75-minute suicide note?” wrote Michael Billington in his famous critique of Sarah Kane’s final play 4.48 Psychosis. Sixteen years later, reviewing Skeleton Tree, Nick Cave’s new album with the Bad Seeds, is a similarly gargantuan task. How do you judge a record written by an artist enduring the most emotionally traumatic event that can happen to a parent, a man enveloped by grief after the death of a child?

Cave’s 15-year-old son Arthur died last July after falling from a Brighton cliff while the singer was halfway through writing it. He duly released a statement with wife Susie Bick asking for privacy to grieve before enlisting director Andrew Dominik to help him make documentary film One More Time With Feeling so that he could address the album’s harrowing context without having to speak to journalists.

The result is beautiful, visceral and, predictably, emotionally devastating. From the first line of eerie opener “Jesus Alone” (“You fell from the sky/Crash landed in a field/Near the River Adur”) Cave makes it clear that he will not be hiding from the tragedy suffocating him, before warped instrumental sounds create a surreal sense of depersonalisation. Gone is the old, lush assurance in Cave’s voice, replaced by a poised fragility as he sings about lacing up the shoes of his “little blue-eyed boy” on “Girl in Amber”. Imaginative preconceptions of death, a theme he has lyrically obsessed over for decades, have been sobered by a personal apocalypse. “I used to think that when you died you kind of wandered the world/ In a slumber til you crumbled, were absorbed into the earth/I don’t think that anymore,” he spits bitterly with barely-concealed anger, flooring the listener with the crushing magnitude of everything this means for an artist changed utterly.

Skeleton Tree leaves Cave’s wounds open, raw and bleeding. Like David Bowie’s critically-acclaimed, analogy-laden swansong Blackstar, it is not overly long, with each song serving to tighten an increasingly acute clench in the chest. “Just like that bluebird, I’ll be free” sung Bowie on “Lazarus”, a track which took on searing new meaning following his death from cancer just days after its release. Cave, meanwhile, is imprisoned and isolated by his grief, left standing in places as mundane and unremarkable as supermarket aisles feeling that “nothing really matters” anymore.

“It’s interesting watching people grieving, they are always trying to do something, but there is nothing to be done,” Dominik said of watching Cave instinctively turn to songwriting for catharsis. By presenting these songs in their flawed natural state, freshly-oozed from a “sawn in half” heart, Cave invites us to share in the universal pain of losing someone you love. There is no theatrical swagger here; his experience of bereavement is blisteringly undiluted.

‘Skeleton Tree’ is available to stream and download from today

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in