Edinburgh Fringe 2019 review round-up: Beatboxing and baby boomers at the Traverse Theatre

Frankenstein: How to Make a Monster and Trying It On are two brilliant shows aimed at different generations, finds Dave Pollock

Dave Pollock
Tuesday 20 August 2019 12:25
Frankenstein: How to Make a Monster is one of the most crowd-pleasing shows of the year at Edinburgh’s new writing hub
Frankenstein: How to Make a Monster is one of the most crowd-pleasing shows of the year at Edinburgh’s new writing hub

Frankenstein: How to Make a Monster ★★★★☆ / Trying It On ★★★★☆

Beatboxing theatre seems to be having a mini-comeback at this year’s Fringe. Between the return of Shlomo with two shows, one for adults and one for children, the prevalence of the form alongside tapdancers in Noise Boys, and the enjoyment of Boar at Pleasance Courtyard, it has hardly been better represented. To the above roll call we can also add Frankenstein: How to Make a Monster at the Traverse, one of the most crowd-pleasing shows of the year at Edinburgh’s new writing hub.

Performed by Battersea Arts Centre’s BAC Beatbox Academy, the show is described as “a mashup, a live concept album… like Frankenstein’s monster”. There are six young beatboxers in the crew, who each have a small podium to stand on when they aren’t prowling the stage; the show isn’t a straight adaptation of Mary Shelley’s classic, but there are heavy intonations of a sense of horror as the group perform what’s essentially a live gig split into “chapters”.

With their voices not just creating dense, dark rhythms, but also rich, atmospheric sound effects – and some gorgeous singing, in the case of Aminita Francis – a sense of contemporary foreboding of what lurks along darkened city streets, and the unconscious fear of the monster within, pervade the work.

There’s one great scene inspired directly by Shelley and subsequent film adaptations, as one figure playing Doctor Frankenstein engages in a beatbox battle with the monster itself; four writhing beatboxers, their bodies contorted together as though one stitched-together carapace. Elsewhere, the music touches lightly upon more universal feelings of perceived ugliness and regret for a terrible mistake. There’s an hour of the show, followed by a mind-bending half-hour beatbox battle, and finally a new understanding of how whole worlds can be created from voices alone.

David Edgar asks why baby boomers went from revolutionaries to reactionaries

Staying with the Traverse, but moving up at least a couple of generations, Trying It On is the new solo(ish) play from playwright David Edgar, in which he celebrates his 70th year by reflecting upon what his baby boomer generation actually achieved, and wondering why the revolutionaries of 1968 became the reactionaries who voted for the current world order. The short answer – at least as far as he ever actually divines one, for his gaze soon turns upon himself – is that Thatcherism proved to be just as attractive a revolution for those who had become comfortably well-off by the time it arrived.

Amid a set stacked high with brown boxes doubling as screens operated by an onstage tech – whose role in the play is deeper than expected, ultimately confronting Edgar with his own sense of smug generational security – he engages in “discussions” with the likes of Paul Mason, David Aaronovich and Tariq Ali to try and divine a sense of the old left’s fate.

Masterful in its rug-pulling structure, with only Edgar’s limitations as a performer to challenge it, what has begun as a eulogy to the good old days and the achievements of Edgar’s life becomes an elegant statement that all of this means nothing unless you can and are willing to pass on responsibility with a sense of generational harmony.

Frankenstein: How to Make a Monster is at the Traverse Theatre, Edinburgh, until Sunday 25 August

Trying It On is at the Traverse Theatre, Edinburgh, until Saturday 24 August

Register for free to continue reading

Registration is a free and easy way to support our truly independent journalism

By registering, you will also enjoy limited access to Premium articles, exclusive newsletters, commenting, and virtual events with our leading journalists

Already have an account? sign in

By clicking ‘Register’ you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to our Terms of use, Cookie policy and Privacy notice.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy policy and Terms of service apply.

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in