Election row over Labour and Tory commitments not to raise VAT
Both parties have pledged not to raise income tax, national insurance or VAT over recent days, should either of them win after polling day on July 4.
Your support helps us to tell the story
From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.
At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.
The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.
Your support makes all the difference.A General Election row has broken out over near-identical Conservative and Labour commitments not to raise VAT.
Both parties have pledged not to raise income tax, national insurance or VAT over recent days, should either of them form a government after polling day on July 4.
Setting out how his party would afford to lower the tax burden, Tory Chancellor Jeremy Hunt told BBC Breakfast that he would “want to avoid austerity-style cuts that we had after the financial crisis”.
Labour shadow Treasury minister Darren Jones denied his party has made a commitment not to raise VAT in response to similar pledges by his Conservative rivals, telling BBC Radio 4’s Today programme: “We’ve not been bounced into anything.”
The row began overnight as The Telegraph published an article by Mr Hunt which read: “A VAT increase will hammer families’ finances and push inflation back up, just when we have got it down to normal.”
He wrote: “Today we rule out increases in the rates of income tax and VAT. If Labour don’t do the same, we will be a bit closer to knowing how they will raise £2,094 in taxes from you.”
UK inflation slowed to 2.3% in April, the lowest level since July 2021 and near the Government’s 2% target, according to the latest figures.
Shadow chancellor Rachel Reeves responded: “I want taxes on working people to be lower, not higher. That is why we opposed the increases to national insurance when Rishi Sunak put those forward as chancellor.”
Her party held a press conference in London on Wednesday, where Labour campaigners claimed the Conservatives have a financial black hole in their plans of £71 billion, made up of allegedly unfunded pledges.
Earlier in May, Mr Hunt claimed Labour’s pre-election campaign pledges would have left a £38.5 billion black hole in their budgets.
When asked about Ms Reeves’ firm commitment that Labour will not raise income tax, national insurance or VAT, Mr Hunt told BBC Breakfast: “When you have, since 2010, an economy where we have created more jobs, attracted more investment, grown faster than nearly any other major European economy, it is a big risk, frankly, to hand that over to a party that can’t make up its mind on the basics.”
The Chancellor added: “I set out in the Budget very clear plans to improve the efficiency of public services, and I took a very difficult decision – I put £3.4 billion into improving the IT systems in the NHS.”
He said the move was “not something that’s a big vote-winner but it will make the NHS more efficient, meaning it can do more operations and means that we can run our public services more efficiently”.
Labour’s Mr Jones told the Today programme: “We’ve been very, very clear – even before the election was called – that we want the burden of taxes to come down on working people.
“That’s why we’ve supported the last two cuts to national insurance and why we’ve been consistent in saying we have no plans, no expectations to increase taxes on working people.”
When asked about the word “change”, used on Labour’s campaign material throughout the election campaign so far, he pointed to his party’s six-point “first steps” policy, planning reforms, and ambition to boost skills.
He said: “Of course, I would love to do lots of other things that cost lots of money, but I can’t because the Conservatives have crashed the economy, debt has gone through the roof, the cost of the national debt is a huge burden on the Treasury.”
Mr Jones claimed the UK’s economic woes began before 2022 when war broke out in Ukraine, during the austerity period which “failed to get growth back into the economy”.
Labour has not announced a plan to raise VAT at a general level, but the party has a much-publicised plan to extend VAT onto private school fees at the standard rate of 20%.
It has also proposed closing “loopholes” in the windfall tax on oil and gas companies and the Government’s plans to tax non-doms.
Party leaders have weighed in to the row, with Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer telling broadcasters in Monmouthshire that his plan is “in stark contrast to a Government that’s taken the tax burden on working people to the highest level since the war”.
He refused to commit to unfreezing tax thresholds in the future, adding: “On the thresholds, I do think that the burden on working people is too high, but I’m not going to do what the Government is doing and make commitments that we cannot afford.”
Rishi Sunak told broadcasters the Tories “want to keep cutting taxes on working people” when “we can responsibly do so”.
But he declined to name a target when asked to make a concrete pledge on reducing the overall tax burden during a campaign visit to Buckinghamshire.
The Prime Minister accused Labour of planning “£2,000 worth of tax rises because they’ve made all these spending commitments they haven’t got the money to pay for” and warned of a “retirement tax” under a Labour government as Sir Keir has not matched the Tories’ promised tax cut for pensioners.
Both parties are making their General Election pledges against a challenging backdrop. The Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) said the next UK government will face the toughest fiscal inheritance for 70 years.
Helen Miller, IFS deputy director, told the PA news agency that ruling out income tax, national insurance and VAT rises “is a major constraint”.
Ms Miller said: “Whoever wins the election will face difficult choices. In order to stick to their own fiscal rules, they will have to either raise taxes or cut spending. If parties are ruling out raising taxes, we should expect to see spending cuts.”