Donald Trump in talks about keeping the US in Paris climate change deal

US President's advisers are split over the issue with some arguing it is important to keep a seat at the table

Jill Colvin,Seth Borenstein
Tuesday 18 April 2017 15:46

President Donald Trump's top aides are meeting to discuss whether or not the US should remain part of the Paris climate agreement — a global effort to cut down on climate-warming carbon emissions.

Officials will be discussing their options, with the goal of providing a recommendation to the president about the path forward, according to an administration official who spoke on condition of anonymity, despite the president's criticism of the use of anonymous sources.

The non-binding international agreement was forged in Paris in December 2015 and allowed rich and poor countries to set their own goals to reduce carbon dioxide. It went into effect last November after it was ratified by countries, including the US and China.

Mr Trump's top advisers are currently divided on the issue, with some, including Environmental Protection Agency head Scott Pruitt, eager for the US to leave the deal.

"Paris is something that we need to really look at closely, because it's something we need to exit, in my opinion," Mr Pruitt said in an interview with Fox News Channel's "Fox & Friends" last week. "It's a bad deal for America. It was an America second, third or fourth kind of approach."

Mr Trump pledged during his campaign to pull out of the Paris accord, but has wavered on the issue since he won the presidency.

He told the editorial board of The New York Times in an interview last year that he was, "looking at it very closely.... I have an open mind to it. We're going to look very carefully."

Under the agreement, the US pledged to reduce its annual greenhouse gas emissions in 2025 by 26 to 28 per cent below 2005 levels, which would be a reduction of about 1.6 billion tons of annual emissions. Besides continuing Mr Obama's efforts to reduce US heat-trapping gases, Mr Trump has two general options.

One option is to pull the United States out of the non-binding agreement, which Mr Obama enacted without US Senate ratification. It typically takes countries four years to pull out of new international treaties, but because Mr Obama enacted the accord as part of the 1992 Rio de Janeiro treaty, Mr Trump could pull out of the older, broader treaty in one year.

Another option is to just do nothing. Mr Trump could publicly bad-mouth the treaty, but not formally withdraw from it. If the US stays part of the agreement, which 125 nations or groups of nations have already ratified, and fails to reach its goal, technically nothing happens. There is no climate court, no enforcement action.

And because the agreement already went into force, nothing the United States can do — even pulling out — can nullify the accord. It is in effect.

Nonetheless, a withdrawal or public announcement that the US is abandoning its efforts to fight man-made climate change could spark repercussions individually from other nations, said Nigel Purvis, who was the top US State Department environmental diplomat when George W Bush pulled out of the 1997 Kyoto climate treaty.

"Any sign that the administration would not be serious will provoke an international reaction that would undermine the administration's foreign policy," said Mr Purvis, an international attorney who served in Democratic and Republican administrations.

Other countries, he said, take climate change seriously and could retaliate in trade deals or tariffs or balk on negotiations over international security costs.

Mr Trump has already reversed some of former President Obama's efforts to scale back carbon emissions to try to halt climate change, including restrictions on coal plants and drilling.

White House spokesman Sean Spicer has said the president will make up his mind on the Paris agreement before a summit of the Group of Seven leading industrial nations in Taormina, Italy in late May.

The Associated Press

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

View comments