Killing a people’s heritage is the weapon of choice among dictators

Trump, in his warmongering stupor, has proposed the same destruction dictators have used for centuries: ‘culturecide’, where future generations must grieve for their very essence, writes Robert Fisk

Wednesday 08 January 2020 13:07
comments
The most culturally important building in Tehran? Iranian students storm the US embassy in 1979
The most culturally important building in Tehran? Iranian students storm the US embassy in 1979
T

here is something deeply ritualistic as well as outrageous about our coverage of the latest mummers play in the Middle East. The US president tosses off another tweet to the world and – however infantile or medically insane its contents – we treat it as some serious political statement. Then millions march on the streets of the Arab world, shouting “Death to America’’ and “Death to Israel’’, and we report this nonsense as if these slogans – which I have been listening to in the Middle East for decades – are actually the product of some serious political debate. Their cries may be understandable, but they give no indication of Iran’s future reaction to the murder of Qassem Soleimani.

Then the international channels dress up all this verbiage into the language of “crisis journalism’’ – scrupulously fair to both mendacious sides – and open an old journalistic notebook. Escalation, retaliation, backlash, revenge, hatred, the gravest crisis since the last gravest crisis, you name it. This is familiar territory and I am reminded of the early days of the Northern Ireland war when we played the same preposterous, childish word games.

In one of his exasperated poems of the early Seventies, Seamus Heaney – later a Nobel laureate and now, alas, the late Seamus – expressed almost identical fury. He wrote of journalists in Belfast “who proved upon their pulses ‘escalate’,/‘Backlash’ and ‘crack down’…/‘Polarisation’ and ‘long-standing hate’…” Heaney’s poem, titled Whatever You Say, Say Nothing is all too applicable. The more we journos utter, the more banal we become. And the more banal it becomes, the less we understand. Or, more to the point, the less we are supposed to understand.

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

View comments