The Independent's journalism is supported by our readers. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn commission.

Doctor criticises Gwyneth Paltrow's Goop for 'ignoring science'

She brought her A game

Rachel Hosie
Monday 29 May 2017 15:09 BST

Many people roll their eyes at the questionable health advice doled out by Gwyneth Paltrow and her lifestyle site, Goop.

Putting stones in your vagina, taking advice from a man who claims he can speak to ghosts, vagina steaming and more have all been recommended.

But one doctor is taking it upon herself to debunk Paltrow's claims and expose any advice by Goop that she believes could be potentially dangerous.

Five nutrition lies ruining your health

Dr Jen Gunter's latest post came about in response to Paltrow's declaration: “If you want to f*** with me, bring your A game.”

“I have taken this A game thing seriously as her pseudoscience and chicanery are lowering the medical I.Q., are harmful, and causing people to spent money on pointless ‘therapies,’” Dr Gunter writes.

She explains how she went to try one of Goop's recipes and found one of the ingredients contained arsenic and could thus be seriously harmful.

The Morning Matcha Smoothie recipe on Goop calls for an unusual ingredient called tocos. Dr Gunter, like most people, didn't know what tocos was (were?) so decided to do some research.

Tocos is “raw bran rice solubles,” Gunter found out by clicking the shopping link on the recipe.

“Not one to take Goop’s word for anything I decided to do some research,” Gunter writes. “Rice bran solubles are the husk of brown rice that has been discarded when rice is polished to make white rice. So rice offal.

“Apparently it was once animal feed until some enterprising people in Big Transformative Foods figured out they could rebrand it and charge out the yoni.

“At first blush it does sounds healthy as brown rice has a better nutritional value than white. Apparently, it is very high in vitamin E which is tocopherol hence the catchy name tocos.”

Whilst some people claim rice bran solubles have health benefits, Dr Gunter found a study that had concluded they contain high arsenic levels.

“Arsenic is a carcinogen and a poison, so that’s not transformative in a good way,” Dr Gunter says.

“This made sense as there is arsenic in rice and there is much more in brown rice. Rice bran solubles have 10-20 times the amount of arsenic as rice.”

Dr Gunter has criticised Goop for “ignoring the science when it’s convenient for their brand and their brand partners.”

She says she found the science behind tocos in just five minutes of research, so believes Goop's writers probably didn't even look into it:

“Goop editors either knew and didn’t give a s*** because ‘tocos’ are trendy (i.e. they sell) and they were counting on no one checking or they actually never researched it. I am honestly not sure which is worse for a health and wellness site.”

Dr Gunter concedes that a drinking the smoothie a few times a month is probably safe, but she says parents should be wary of making it for their children.

“I think it’s f***ing hypocritical to be all about ‘toxins’ and cleanses and cancer fear and then promote and sell a product that is illegal in China because of its arsenic,” she writes.

Goop are yet to respond to our request for a comment on the matter.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in