‘I’m gobsmacked’: Government criticised for ‘calorie-shaming’ weight loss poster

‘[It] is unhelpful and could be harmful for those already unwell or vulnerable,’ says eating disorder charity

Sophie Gallagher
Wednesday 12 February 2020 13:24

The government has been criticised over new “eat a little less” posters which state: “Just 100 extra calories a day could mean 10lbs of weight gain a year.”

The poster, commissioned by the Public Health Agency (PHA) in Northern Ireland, shows what 100 calories looks like in four different snacks.

It includes pictures of three and a half cocktail sausages, three sweets, one digestive biscuit or one medium latte drink.

Vanessa from Belfast posted a photograph of the poster on her social media, with the caption: “I just saw this poster at a bus stop talking about how 3 wee sausages or 1 f**king digestive biscuit will make you gain 10lbs I’m actually gobsmacked?

“What does this achieve other than make those with eating disorders and compulsive calorie counters feel worse?”

The 30-year-old told The Independent: "My first reaction was to laugh, but it quickly turned to concern for young people and all those suffering or recovering from eating disorders.

"To frame a biscuit and a half as having the potential to gain 10lbs of weight in a year could be incredibly damaging to compulsive calorie counters and those with body image issues.

"I think this has the potential to be incredibly dangerous to young people in general. I'm sure my younger self would have taken it very hard, it's easy to imagine young girls and women going to bed hungry afraid three sweets or a hot chocolate will be the 100 calories that will 'push them' over an intake limit," she adds.

Others replied to Vanessa's tweet, agreeing. One said: “Seeing this could f**k a lot of people in recovery up as well! Like if I was caught off guard by this in public I doubt I’d handle it well tbh.”

Others commented saying they had also seen the posters: “Literally saw this today, it’s the same with the whole ‘you can lose 10 million stone if you stop taking sugar in your tea’ like it’s hardly going to kill you?”

“Near-universal criticism from ED [eating disorder] specialists to include calorie content on publicly-distributed health materials, but good job Department of Health,” said another.

Another said: “The ‘eat a little less’ turns me too like why not make it about healthy choices if u r that concerned with people’s weight instead of telling them to restrict their intake I’m fuming [sic].”

Tom Quinn, director of external affairs at Beat, the UK’s leading eating disorder charity, told The Independent: “It is important that messages aimed at reducing obesity consider the impact they may have on individuals at risk of developing an eating disorder.

“Focusing solely on calorie counting, rather than healthy and balanced eating, is unhelpful and could be harmful for those already unwell or vulnerable.

“Public health professionals must move away from obesity-shaming to emphasising healthy behavioural changes and instilling confidence into people.”

A spokesperson for the PHA told The Independent: “Obesity is a major public health challenge facing Northern Ireland. Currently more than three in five people are classed as being overweight or obese, and it is now the norm rather than the exception to carry excess weight.

“’Extras’ is part of the Choose to Live Better campaign which is targeted at members of the general population who are overweight or obese. Previous phases of the public information campaign focused on waist measurement, physical activity as well as nutrition.

“’Extras’ aims to encourage people to think about the unnecessary ‘extras’ eg snacks, nibbles, second helpings, etc. they eat and show how easy it is to gain weight if they consume more food than they require to maintain a healthy weight .

“A number of concepts were tested with the public and ‘extras’ tested positively because it focused on small changes. The message ‘eating an extra 100 calories each day means gaining an unwanted 4.5kg (10lbs) each year’ and showing visually what 100 calories looks like was seen as a positive,” they added.

The PHA confirmed that this is a re-run of a previous campaign, and will be shown on TV, radio and outdoor advertising.

The PHA was established in 2009 under the health and social care body in Northern Ireland, to oversee a major reform of health infrastructure in the region.

On their website they say their purpose is to: “Protect and improve the health and social wellbeing of our population and reduce health inequalities through strong partnerships with individuals, communities and other key public, private and voluntary organisations.”

Similar campaigns run by Public Health England have previously been criticised: in January 2018 a campaign was criticised after encouraging parents to only give children snacks with fewer than than 100 calories.

If you have been affected by any of the issues mentioned in this article, you can contact the following organisations for support: the BEAT helpline on 0808 801 0677​ or Mind on 0300 123 3393​.

Register for free to continue reading

Registration is a free and easy way to support our truly independent journalism

By registering, you will also enjoy limited access to Premium articles, exclusive newsletters, commenting, and virtual events with our leading journalists

Already have an account? sign in

By clicking ‘Register’ you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to our Terms of use, Cookie policy and Privacy notice.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy policy and Terms of service apply.

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in