Do I need a 4x4 car to cope with the winter roads?

Jay Foxton is worried about this winter’s severe weather forecasts, and wonders if an off-roader would make sense. He has £10,000 to spend.

A pre-owned Chrysler Jeep Liberty from 2002 is seen on the sales lot at Prestige Auto Boutique on June 18, 2013 in Hollywood, Florida. Chrysler agreed to recall 2.7 million older model Jeeps that include the Jeep Grand Cherokees from model years 1993 through 2004 and Jeep Libertys from 2002 through 2007. (Joe Raedle/Getty Images)

A Car for the Head

Well, the sensible thing to do is invest in a set of winter tyres, which will transform the cold weather performance of any car. Jay probably doesn’t need full-time four-wheel drive either, but it can help in bad conditions if a vehicle’s system senses that extra traction is required because of icy and slippery roads. The Honda CR-V has been the nation’s favourite so-called soft-roader for some years now. It is comfortable, reliable and practical. About £8,000 would buy a well-equipped 2008 2.2i CTDi ES with a full history. This model also delivers decent 40mpg economy.

A Car for the Heart

Not everyone needs the ground clearance and bulk of a traditional 4x4. There are vehicles that have all-wheel drive, which are stylish and practical without all the unnecessary drama. Rather than go for an obvious Audi Quattro, I think Jay should consider a far better value Subaru Legacy. Here is a stylish estate car, which has permanent four-wheel drive. An SE Sports has a long list of standard equipment and, with the 2.0-litre diesel engine, it manages a decent 35mpg overall. Within budget, £8,000 buys a 2011 example with 70,000 miles.