Car choice; Which GTI?

Helen McLennan wants a small hatchback – but it can't be dull. Ideally, she would prefer a GTI-type model. She has about £10,000 to spend

(Mini)

A Car for the Head

Because practicality appears not to be not the priority, with the emphasis more on fun and the ability to cope well with long journeys I would be inclined to think that a Mini Cooper would be the answer, especially the quicker Cooper S version. It has a 1.6 turbocharged engine, and it manages to combine a good turn of speed with absolutely superb handling. There are loads to choose from and we came across a 2014 Mini Cooper S Clubman. This is a tiny estate version of the Mini Cooper, and our example had with 50,000 miles on the clock. It also looks really funky with roof bars and bonnet stripes at £10,000.

(Renault (Renault)

A Car for the Heart

I know that Helen has a soft spot for French performance cars and previously owned Peugeot GTis. I don’t think subsequent Peugeots have been as exciting to drive, or even look at as some comeptitors, however. So maybe it is time to change brands to Renault, and in particular a Clio Renaultsport which has great handling, a spacious interior and is certainly lots of fun. A 2011 Clio 2.0 VVT in liquid yellow with sports seats seems like the sort of uncompromising hot hatchback that Helen would really love. Advertised at £9,495 our selection has just been serviced and had covered 56,000 miles.

If you would like James Ruppert to help with your car choice, email james@freecarmag.com. For more motoring views visit freecarmag.com