Badger cull: Jane Goodall, top scientists and ex-government advisers issue personal plea to Boris Johnson to halt expansion

Exclusive: Virginia McKenna and Caroline Lucas join top vets in warning PM over how he will be remembered if he fails to step in

Jane Dalton
Tuesday 01 September 2020 22:04 BST
Brian May protests against badger cull

Leading scientists and wildlife experts including Jane Goodall and Virginia McKenna have issued a direct plea to Boris Johnson to cancel this month’s planned badger cull expansion.

A former government deputy chief vet and former government adviser on culling are also among those urging the prime minister to intervene.

In a letter sent today, seen by The Independent, the 23 lobbyists remind Mr Johnson of a government promise earlier this year to phase out intensive culling and instead move to badger vaccination.

The experts, including Green MP Caroline Lucas and broadcaster Chris Packham, ask Mr Johnson to honour those words and step in to stop the expansion.

They warn him: “If, however, your government chooses to continue the discredited and ineffective badger culling policy, you will be remembered as the prime minister who presided over the greatest slaughter of a protected animal in living memory.”

Last month, leaked documents suggested the badger cull, which was begun in an attempt to stop dairy cattle from catching tuberculosis (bTB) from badgers, would be expanded to 11 new areas, bringing the total this year to 54.

The widened operation, due to begin this month, would kill 65,000 badgers, conservationists estimate.

They include for the first time Derbyshire, Oxfordshire, Warwickshire, Shropshire, Leicestershire and Lincolnshire, which is considered a low-risk TB area.

Derbyshire has the biggest badger vaccination project in the country, and an expansion would mean even inoculated animals could be killed.

The letter is also signed by Ranald Munro, the government-appointed former chairman of an independent panel examining culling, former government deputy chief vet Alick Simmons and Will Travers, executive director of Born Free.

It argues that culling is ineffective in curbing bTB. The prevalence of the disease in cattle herds in Gloucestershire and Dorset was higher following pilot culling than before, it claims.

In Cumbria, only three badgers out of 317 killed last year tested positive, the letter adds, also citing evidence that the cattle skin test is ineffective.

“We applaud your government’s stated aim of phasing out badger culling, but this appears to be in stark contrast to your apparent intention,” the experts write.

And they add that public opinion will be with Mr Johnson if he halts the expanded cull.

Since 2013, more than 100,000 badgers have been killed in England in efforts to prevent the disease spreading. More than 30,000 infected cattle are slaughtered each year.

The NFU last year cited research, published in Scientific Reports, that “showed a 66 per cent reduction in new TB breakdowns in cattle in Gloucestershire and a 37 per cent reduction in Somerset”.

The Independent asked Downing Street to respond, but it referred questions to the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra), which said recently: “Bovine TB remains the greatest animal health threat to the UK, costing taxpayers over £100m every year as well as causing devastation and distress for farmers and rural communities.

“There is no single measure that will provide an easy answer to beating the disease and we are pursuing a range of interventions to eradicate it by 2038, including tighter cattle movement controls, regular testing and vaccinations.”

Defra added that it does not comment on leaked documents, and that no cull licences had been granted this year. An update on the government’s bTB strategy is expected to be published in the autumn.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in