Diesel cars will never be fully replaced by electric vehicles, says man who exposed VW emissions scandal

The man behind the emissions-finding equipment that uncovered the 2015 VW scandal believes an electric-car future is fantasy 

Masatsugu Horie,Kevin Buckland
Tuesday 05 September 2017 09:37
Comments
Atsushi Horiba (fourth right) dismisses the potential for electric cars to dominate
Atsushi Horiba (fourth right) dismisses the potential for electric cars to dominate

What is the market leader in equipment for measuring car emissions to do if the vehicles of the future don’t spew exhaust?

Japan’s Horiba, whose gear was central in exposing Volkswagen’s diesel-cheating scandal, believes that day will never come.

Electric vehicles won’t ever make up more than a third of cars worldwide, says chief executive Atsushi Horiba, because it’s just not feasible to build the scale of infrastructure to enable battery-powered cars.

Who, for example, would set up a charging station in the middle of the Arizona desert, he said in a recent interview in Tokyo.

Car with internal combustion engines, including those using diesel, will continue to have a place, particularly in emerging markets, he said.

“Any academic who says 100 per cent of cars will be electric in the future has been reading too many comic books,” said Mr Horiba, the 69-year-old son of the company’s founder, speaking in Japanese. “It’s not an issue of technology, it’s just reality.”

Despite his confidence, signs are pointing to a major acceleration in the electrification of cars in the two years since VW admitted to installing defeat devices in diesel cars to circumvent clean-air regulations in the US and China. China, home to the world’s biggest car market, is ushering in stringent cap-and-trade fleet-based emission and fuel-economy regulations.

Governments in the UK, France, Norway and India have set aggressive targets to ban the sale of fossil fuel-burning cars, while the popularity of Tesla’s electric cars have raised the segment’s profile among the public.

Cars are racing to develop EVs, with Sweden’s Volvo aiming to introduce all electrified models in its line-up by 2019. Toyota, among the most ardent advocates for hydrogen fuel-cell vehicles, is also taking steps to expand its offerings of battery-powered models.

Electric cars will outsell fossil-fuel powered vehicles within two decades as technological advances push down battery prices faster than previously thought, according to a Bloomberg New Energy Finance report in July.

In just eight years, electric cars will be as cheap as gasoline vehicles, the report predicts.

Horiba, whose company makes about 80 per cent of the car emission measurement systems sold worldwide, sees no need to rush and change tack.

Car makers that don’t continue to invest in internal combustion engines won’t be able to survive the 15 or more years to see the day when EV technology starts to really take hold, he said.

The Kyoto-based equipment-maker may be caught out if there’s a big shift toward EVs in the near term, says SMBC Nikko Securities analyst Hiroharu Watanabe, though it’s likely more time is needed to work out the issues hindering the adoption of battery-powered cars.

At the same time, electrification, autonomous driving and other advanced technologies should create additional opportunities for measuring equipment, he said.

SMBC Nikko has a buy recommendation on the company’s stock.

Horiba’s shares have gained about 59 per cent since Volkswagen’s diesel-cheating scandal erupted on September 2015, outpacing the about 9 per cent gain in Japan’s benchmark Topix index.

Started in 1945 with the goal of continuing nuclear physics research that had been disrupted by the Second World War, Horiba later diversified and completed its first emissions analyser during Japan’s 1960s postwar economic boom.

Autonomous Driving

The company also has a buffer in its other businesses. Beyond car test systems, it also makes equipment to analyse water quality, blood-sugar levels and chemicals for semiconductors.

While more than a third of revenue came from the car business in the fiscal year ended in March, over half of its operating profit came from the chip-related business.

Horiba also began a foray into autonomous driving technology in 2015 when it acquired UK-based MIRA, which in addition to offering engineering consulting and testing services, had been developing autonomous vehicles for the British military.

And, it has taken some early steps to position itself to exploit opportunities in testing batteries, motors and control systems for electric vehicles, Horiba said.

But he added that those new businesses will be on top of, not replacements for, the services the company now provides.

“We live off our real businesses, so we need to keep an eye on what’s going on in the real world,” he said. “We’re not suddenly going to go all in on electrification and say we’re quitting emissions testing equipment. That’s not going to happen.”

Bloomberg

Register for free to continue reading

Registration is a free and easy way to support our truly independent journalism

By registering, you will also enjoy limited access to Premium articles, exclusive newsletters, commenting, and virtual events with our leading journalists

Already have an account? sign in

By clicking ‘Register’ you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to our Terms of use, Cookie policy and Privacy notice.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy policy and Terms of service apply.

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in