Kidde drops US patent law suit
Kidde, the fire equipment group which is fighting a $116m (£81m) US court damages award against it for breaching a contract with another company, X-IT Products, yesterday revealed that it had dropped a counter-suit against X-IT.
A spokesman for Kidde, which reported that the case has cost the company £2.6m in legal expenses, said the counter-suit – called a declaratory judgement action – had been withdrawn "without prejudice".
X-IT, a tiny US company with just one full-time employee, had taken Kidde to court for allegedly copying its design for a portable fire escape ladder.
In August last year, a jury in Norfolk, Virginia awarded $116m against Kidde. The judge in the case is now due to issue an order on the amount of damages he deems appropriate. Shortly after that jury verdict, X-IT's patent application, which had been pending for some time on the ladder, was granted.
Kidde quietly filed a case in another court against that patent.
Bob Tata, X-IT's lawyer, said: "Kidde was seeking to have the patent declared invalid but that action was never served on us."
X-IT said it was news to the company that Kidde had now dropped this action but it noted that the ploy could be re-activated at any time. Aldo DiBelardino, the ladder's inventor and X-IT's chief executive, said: "They are simply trying to litigate us out of existence. We are a small company and they have very deep pockets."
Separately, Kidde yesterday issued a trading update. The company, run by the chief executive Michael Harper, saw a 25 per cent drop in demand for civil aerospace aftersales care in October, with some recovery in November and December.
Subscribe to Independent Premium to bookmark this article
Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Premium subscription today.
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies