Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

Coronavirus: Young men more likely than young women to break lockdown rules, study finds

Older teenage boys also more likely to incorrectly believe they cannot catch or pass on coronavirus

Tim Wyatt
Saturday 09 May 2020 16:56 BST
Comments
Young men were almost twice as likely to have met up with friends in public than women
Young men were almost twice as likely to have met up with friends in public than women (Getty Images)

Research by a team of psychologists suggests young men are twice as likely to break the coronavirus lockdown as young women.

Two thousand 13-24 year-olds were interviewed by researchers about the pandemic, revealing the strikingly different approaches to social distancing rules.

The group which flouted the lockdown the most were older adolescent males, aged 19-24. Just over half of this cohort admitted to the scientists, from the University of Sheffield and Ulster University, they had met up with friends or family members they did not live with.

In contrast, only about 25 per cent of young women of the same age said they had broken the lockdown regulations in this way.

It was a similar story when the researchers asked if they had gathered in a park or public place in groups of three or more.

About 45 per cent of men aged 19-24 admitted they had done this, compared with about 25 per cent of women of the same age.

The research even found a fifth of older adolescent men had been reprimanded by police because of breaking the lockdown rules, including being dispersed, fined or arrested.

Males aged 19-24 were also noticeably more likely to agree with statements downplayed the risks of coronavirus, such as “There is no risk that I can easily spread the virus to others even if I have no or very mild symptoms” and “There is no risk for me to catch the virus as young people are immune”.

Dr Liat Levita from the University of Sheffield said psychologists had known for some time men on the whole are happier taking greater risks than women.

“We know that males in general take more risks and evolutionary psychologists have always explained that in terms of males trying to show off,” she told the BBC.

"They will take more risks and their decision-making processes are shaped by that so their behaviour actually makes sense to them.”

Last month, statistics from the National Police Chiefs’ Council found 80 per cent of those fined by police forces across the country for breaching the Covid-19 lockdown were men.

Two-thirds of those fined were also aged between 18 and 34, including four young men stopped by Greater Manchester Police who had driven all the way from their home in Yorkshire to buy burgers.

Raab: 'Any lockdown changes will be modest and incremental'

The psychology study also found coronavirus was taking a toll of young people’s mental health.

Between 40 and 50 per cent of respondents (with higher numbers in the older age cohorts) said they felt significantly more anxious than before the pandemic, and 50-60 per cent reported feeling worried about their parents and family.

Those who reported having depression were more likely to leave home and break social distancing by meeting up with friends, while those with anxiety were more likely to be washing their hands frequently.

Dr Levita said these findings showed how it can sometimes be harder to comply with the lockdown for those with mental health problems.

“The more someone is depressed, the less compliant and de-motivated they are. So if you need to hand-wash more often and need to make an effort in following the guidelines, it's not something that you're actually going to be able to do very well."

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in