Why many autistic children in Africa are hidden away and go undiagnosed

Many African children with autism are hidden away at home – sometimes chained up, almost always undiagnosed. Efforts to bring the condition into the open are only just beginning

Nicholette Zeliadt
Thursday 14 December 2017 12:16
comments
Autism is not very well known on the continent, and acceptance is even lower
Autism is not very well known on the continent, and acceptance is even lower

The eight-year-old girl’s head droops like a wilted flower as she sits slumped in a wooden chair in her mother’s kitchen. Her wrists are swollen from the dingy white shoelace that binds them behind her back. The girl’s mother, Aberu Demas, weeps as she unties her child.

Earlier that day, Demas had arrived unannounced at the Joy Centre for Autism in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. A single mother living on the outskirts of town, Demas didn’t know what autism was or if her daughter, Fikirte, had it, but she was desperate for help. Fikirte could not speak or feed herself, and Demas had no family or friends to look after the girl when she needed to work or run errands.

It had taken Demas several hours to get to the centre by bus. Because she didn’t have an appointment, she had to wait about three hours until Zemi Yenus, the centre’s founder, could see her. The centre was at maximum capacity, so when they finally met, Yenus told Demas she could only put Fikirte on the waiting list. Demas began to cry, and confessed that she had left her daughter tied up and alone at home.

​Yenus did a quick calculation: By the time Demas would get home, Fikirte would have been restrained for about eight hours, with no food, water or bathroom breaks. That was the end of the meeting: Yenus immediately drove Demas home to free Fikirte, and reassured the woman that she would make room for the girl at her school. Fikirte wasn’t the first child Yenus had seen in that state – and she wouldn’t be the last.

Yenus is a beautician by trade, but set up the centre after her son was diagnosed with autism in the UK

In the 10 years since then, Yenus says she has encountered hundreds of children locked away or tied up. Like Demas, many parents resort to these extreme measures because they have no other choice. Others hide their children, fearing stigma, which is pervasive in many parts of Africa and casts any disability as the sign of a curse.

Many children with autism across Africa stay out of sight for another reason: Few clinicians have the skills or experience to identify the condition, if they are even aware that it exists. In all of Ethiopia, with its nearly 100 million inhabitants, there are about 60 psychiatrists, and only one who specialises in child psychiatry. Only two public clinics provide mental health services, and both are located in Addis Ababa, where a scant 15 per cent of the population lives. In 2015, there were about 50 child and adolescent psychiatrists for the more than one billion inhabitants in all of Africa.

Yenus, whose adult son was diagnosed with autism in England, is a beautician by training, but she has made informal diagnoses for many children in her care, including Fikirte. She founded the Joy Centre, the first of its kind, in 2002. She and other parents of children with autism have spent the past 15 years trying to raise awareness of autism in Africa. With little guidance available to them, they have also resorted to creating their own treatments to help children on the spectrum learn to communicate and master basic skills. None of these homegrown therapies have been validated, but these families simply cannot afford to wait. “I’m not saying we don’t need that, but that’s not what we need right now,” Yenus says. “What I need is to free those children.”

The help these families need has been slow to come, but researchers are beginning to pick up the pace. Some are tailoring diagnostic methods and treatments to African populations and devising ways to reach rural communities faster. In September, the International Society for Autism Research held a meeting in South Africa – the first of its kind on the continent – to highlight research there. Hundreds of researchers, therapists and family members met for the first time at the three-day event. “My hope is that this will not be a one-off event, but the start of an ongoing process of building networks and connections within Africa,” says conference co-organiser Petrus de Vries, professor of child and adolescent psychiatry at the University of Cape Town. Even the wealthiest parts of Africa have a long road ahead, however. “What we have here [in Cape Town] may probably be as good as it gets in Africa,” De Vries says. “And yet our services for people with autism are almost non-existent.”

Missing children

British psychiatrist Victor Lotter published some of the first descriptions of people with autism in Africa in a 1978 paper. He screened more than 1,300 children at institutions for people with intellectual disability in six African countries; he found 9 children who qualified for a diagnosis and 30 others with features of autism. Lotter reported that, as with children he had studied in the United Kingdom, autism in Africa appeared more often in boys than in girls. But compared with their British peers, African children with the condition were less likely to show repetitive and stereotyped behaviours.

It was a promising start. But “since then, not much has happened”, De Vries says. Last year, he and his colleagues laid out all of the peer-reviewed studies ever published about autism in the 46 countries of sub-Saharan Africa. They found only 53 analyses, from just nine countries. About 80 per cent of the studies focused on South Africa and Nigeria, two of the wealthiest countries on the continent.

Their analysis did not support Lotter’s claim: The studies found that autism is fundamentally no different in Africa than it is anywhere else in the world. Researchers in Kenya had reached the same conclusion after a similar review the year before. “Personally, I have not come across any indication that there’s anything different about the presentation [of autism in Africa],” says Amina Abubakar, a research fellow at the Kenya Medical Research Institute in Kilifi, who led the Kenyan analysis.

The biggest differences are who gets diagnosed and when. Children with autism in Africa tend to be diagnosed around age eight, about four years later, on average, than their American counterparts. More than half of African children with autism are also diagnosed with intellectual disability, compared with about one-third of American children on the spectrum. This suggests that only the most severely affected children are being picked up: Those who are diagnosed often speak few or no words and require substantial help with everyday tasks such as eating or going to the bathroom. By contrast, in the US, the largest diagnostic increases over the past few decades have been on the milder end of the spectrum.

Jojo and other students at the Joy Centre prepare lunch each day with supervision from a cook

These findings seem to be in line with the belief that autism is more severe in African children than in children elsewhere. However, the studies that offered up this idea were small – the largest included only 75 participants. And they focused predominantly on children brought to neurology or psychiatry clinics. “The children who end up there are almost by definition the more severely affected kids,” De Vries says.

De Vries moved home to South Africa from Cambridge, U.K., five years ago to try for a more realistic estimate of the condition in Africa. “My simple thought was, ‘Okay, we’re going to start with a prevalence study, then we’ll know what we’re dealing with.’” But he quickly realised that reliable prevalence estimates would need reliable diagnoses – and those were not easy to come by in Africa, where diagnosis is often based on judgment calls by people with little to no experience or expertise in autism.

So De Vries took a step back to focus on diagnosis. One strategy is to adapt the “gold standard” diagnostic tools developed in the US – the Autism Diagnostic Observation Schedule (ADOS) and the Autism Diagnostic Interview-Revised (ADI-R) – for use in Africa. It’s unlikely that either test will be routinely used in Africa any time soon. Both tests are too expensive for that, and De Vries is also the only person in all of Africa certified to train others to use either one. He has translated the ADOS into Afrikaans, one of the 11 official languages spoken in South Africa, and is validating it for use. Abubakar and others have translated the ADOS into Kiswahili, one of Kenya’s two official languages. But there are 2,000 or more languages spoken across the continent.

​Abubakar and De Vries are also part of a large international collaboration developing a free open-source diagnostic tool to be used instead of the ADOS or ADI-R. Once it’s ready, which they hope will be within the next five years, they plan to test it in several African countries. In the meantime, Abubakar’s collaborator, Charles Newton, is using the Kiswahili translation of the ADOS to lead Kenya’s first rigorous estimate of autism prevalence. Newton’s group has screened 11,000 children in Kilifi, aged six to nine. They selected the children randomly from a cohort of more than 250,000 people the researchers contact three times a year to track births, deaths and migrations in the general population. The hope is that these children represent the range of autism severity in Africa better than those in the earlier, clinic-based studies.

Their unpublished results suggest that about 1 per cent of children in Kenya have the condition, in keeping with rates elsewhere. The results are preliminary, Newton says, but they make it clear that “autism is not rare in Africa”.

Raising awareness

Most Africans are largely unaware of autism, despite its prevalence. In surveys conducted in Kenya, Nigeria, Tanzania and Ethiopia, healthcare workers and families frequently attribute its features to a curse (brought on by a taboo act such as cheating on a spouse) or to being possessed by an evil spirit.

Yenus experienced this lack of awareness first-hand. In 1996, she returned to her hometown of Addis Ababa from Los Angeles, where she had run a beauty salon for 14 years. She was preparing to open Ethiopia’s first cosmetology school, the Niana School of Beauty, when she realised her four-year-old son, Jojo, seemed to be regressing. He stopped using the few words he had acquired as a toddler, then he started frequently spinning around in circles. Yenus wondered if he might have autism, something she had heard about on American television. She read up on the condition and grew increasingly convinced that it explained Jojo’s behaviour. She took the boy to numerous doctors in Addis Ababa, but no one knew what she was talking about. “There was no knowledge about autism in Ethiopia,” she says. “The word autism didn’t exist.” So she diagnosed him herself based on what she had read in books that her husband sent her from the United States.

In 1999, she held a star-studded week-long exhibition about traditional and modern beauty products and services. She decided to use the media attention that the event attracted as an opportunity to talk about her son and his condition. “I made sure everybody understood it’s not a curse,” she says.

Jojo received an official diagnosis about a year later, when he was 8. Yenus had taken him to see a psychiatrist in Oxford, England, where they were visiting family. The diagnosis did little to improve Jojo’s situation back home. School after school expelled him because his teachers could not control him. And as Yenus continued to educate the public about autism through frequent appearances on TV and radio programmes, she grew distressed by the experiences of families less fortunate than hers. She heard horrifying accounts of children rejected by their families and cut off from even the most basic care.

In April 2002, Yenus used her savings from her work in the beauty industry to rent a small house in Addis Ababa, where she opened the Joy Centre for Autism. She started with just four students, including her son. As demand grew, she admitted more children and hired staff. Within a year and a half, the school had outgrown its original location and moved to its current site: A house tucked away behind a tall green fence in a quiet residential neighbourhood in the southwestern part of the city. As of September, the school has 80 students and 53 staff.

Yenus is a well-known figure in Ethiopia and recognised elsewhere in Africa. She appears regularly on TV and radio. “I think you can credit her with being the main person responsible for raising autism awareness,” says Rosa Hoekstra, lecturer in psychology at Kings College London. “She’s really a very powerful, inspiring figure.” But Yenus remains dissatisfied. In Ethiopia, as in other African countries, there are no laws to guarantee children with autism or other special needs the right to public education. To date, there are only two schools in Addis Ababa that specialise in autism – the Joy Centre and the Nehemiah Centre, opened by a group of families with children on the spectrum in 2011. Together, the two schools have more than 500 children on waiting lists.

The schools provide some therapies that are loosely derived from evidence-based approaches, such as applied behavioural analysis, but other offerings are not. At the Joy Centre, for example, children receive occupational therapy, music therapy and art lessons, as well as a speech therapy called “Abugida phonetics”, which Yenus developed for her son. It involves teaching children how to speak by breaking words down into simple syllables and showing them pictures of mouths making each sound. The idea is that the children learn to mimic those movements.

De Vries (middle) is the only child and adolescent psychiatrist in the whole of Ehtiopia

Yenus credits this technique for her son’s ability to say simple phrases. But experts say it’s unclear whether these homemade treatments help. “I think I understand why people are driven to generating their own [treatments] when the system doesn’t provide it,” De Vries says. But at the same time, he says, few people try to use proven therapies or collect the types of data needed to validate their homegrown treatments.

Some African researchers, including Waganesh Zeleke, are hoping to collect this data. Zeleke worked as a staff psychologist at the Joy Centre before earning her doctorate in the US, and she returns each year to try to evaluate the treatments offered there and at the Nehemiah Centre. She has found that most of the staff at these schools lack any knowledge of autism or experience providing autism treatments prior to being hired. “Most of their knowledge comes out of self-learning,” says Zeleke, now assistant professor of clinical mental health counselling at Duquesne University in Pittsburgh. “It’s all informal, intuition-based.”

Both centres also lack documentation about what the treatments entail or formal assessments of children’s behaviours before and after receiving the therapies. Without this information, Zeleke says, it’s impossible to tell whether any of the treatments are effective. She’s working with staff at both schools to teach them how to assess and measure their methods rigorously.

Cultural lessons

As the meeting in September made clear, researchers in Africa are primarily focused on long-term scientific goals – but recognise families’ acute need for help. “It’s pointless to do neuroscience if people don’t get access to diagnosis and treatment,” De Vries says. “It’s pointless to do a prevalence study if all it does is to say how big our problem is, and we have no solutions for the problem.”

He and others have started to collaborate with local communities to make more immediate gains. Hoekstra, for example, has partnered with Ethiopia’s Federal Ministry of Health to educate its nearly 40,000 health extension workers about autism. These workers travel to rural areas to provide primary health services, but they have historically received no training in mental health or developmental conditions. “What we are trying to do is to go from a close-to-non-existent services situation to a situation where we can actually start offering families some handles or supports,” Hoekstra says. Her results so far show that the training reduces stigma and misconceptions about autism among the workers. The team is evaluating whether it also results in more children being diagnosed with autism.

Other projects sidestep the lack of trained autism experts and focus on helping parents directly – teaching them to provide evidence-based therapies to their children rather than relying on trips to doctors or other experts. For instance, Lauren Franz at Duke University in Durham, North Carolina, is adapting a therapy called the Early Start Denver Model for use in South Africa. The therapy uses play routines to help children with autism learn skills such as speaking and socialising. Another team, led by Nola Chambers at the University of Cape Town, is adapting an online tool called the Autism Navigator, which uses videos to teach parents strategies for helping their children.

These researchers are incorporating what they are learning about African views and experiences. Because literacy in Ethiopia is low, Hoekstra’s team has developed oral training sessions. They also no longer tell Ethiopians that autism is highly genetic. “You could cause a very strong genetic taint on the family,” Hoekstra says, essentially “replacing one stigma with another”. One major lesson is the importance of working with local beliefs – and that’s true anywhere in the world. “The fact that many African people believe that autism is caused by a curse or spirits, I don’t think that’s culturally any more unusual than some people saying that autism is caused by vaccinations or by particular diets, or by particular heavy metals,” De Vries says. “They’re all cultural beliefs, in a way.”

Yenus diagnosed her son herself when she could not find an Ethiopian clinician familiar with the condition

Yenus says the programmes seem to work best when experts solicit the opinions of parents like her – and wishes they would do so more often. “There should be no research about us without us,” she says. “Even though we are not psychiatrists, we are not doctors, we are doing the work. We have the knowledge as well.”

Yenus is using that knowledge to expand her centre’s reach. She has begun training teachers in 15 mainstream schools in and around Addis Ababa to help them provide inclusive education for children with autism. And last year, the Ethiopian government gave her permission to build another school for children with autism, on the outskirts of Addis Ababa. The new school, which Yenus calls her “Autism Centre of Excellence”, is set to accommodate roughly 400 children. She is still raising money but helped to lay the building’s cornerstone in March. She says the facility will be equipped with dedicated treatment rooms, as well as long-term living quarters for children in the direst need of help.

​Fikirte, now 18, still attends the Joy Centre most days of the week. She still does not speak but has figured out other ways to communicate. One afternoon in September, as her mother talked with a visitor, she retrieved a glass from a cupboard and gave it to her mother to signal her thirst. Demas works part-time at the centre, along with six other single mothers of children with autism, preparing dried spice blends sold to area hospitals and businesses. The job provides the women with a small salary and the flexibility to check in on their children during the day. Before she met Yenus, Demas says, she contemplated killing her daughter and herself. “This is a second chance at life,” she says, speaking through an interpreter. “Now I’m a different person.”

For Yenus, there is no greater motivation.

“It’s a big responsibility I have, that is on my shoulders,” Yenus says. “That’s why I keep doing this, because when all those people look at you, hoping that something will be done because of your activities, because of your shouting and talking to whoever, you don’t want to just leave them alone. Even give them a little hope – it means a lot to me.”

This article was first published here. For more articles, visit Spectrum’s website at spectrumnews.org

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

View comments