Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

Phil Michaels: Environmental lawyer who won a succession of cases driven by his passion for justice and activists' rights

 

Gita Parihar
Tuesday 07 October 2014 18:44 BST
Comments
Michaels: his training materials usually bore the legend, 'Be you ever so high, the law is above you'
Michaels: his training materials usually bore the legend, 'Be you ever so high, the law is above you'

Phil Michaels, environmental lawyer extraordinaire, was driven by a passion for rights and justice and he always underplayed his enormous talent and skill. He made a deep impact on environmental law and on all those who worked with him.

A Londoner by birth, Michaels began his legal career at Theodore Goddard and then joined Friends of the Earth in 2001. I met him in 2003 when he brought a successful legal challenge against plans for "Ghost Ships", old and deteriorating US naval vessels due to be scrapped in Hartlepool. Each was contaminated with chemicals, including asbestos, heavy diesel and carcinogenic PCBs. This was typical of the type of case that Michaels championed, as at its core it was about respecting laws protecting wildlife and the right of people to have a say about what happens in their neighbourhood. Hartlepool was burdened with a history of environmental pollution, and the issue became a hot political potato with the local MP, Peter Mandelson. The court found that the necessary permissions did not exist to let the scrapping go ahead.

In another judicial review, Michaels prevented Gordon Brown from abandoning a requirement on companies to report their environmental and social impact. Not only did the Government back down and settle out of court by agreeing to re-consult, it also paid Friends of the Earth's legal costs. Brown's decision had provoked uproar, so this was a significant victory for Michaels.

Despite such achievements, he carried not the slightest hint of arrogance and was always great fun to work with. As a senior barrister put it, he was totally committed to the environment, but that never got in the way of his judgment or sense of humour. Even when court cases failed, Michaels was committed to highlighting the links between social inequality and environmental harm. His unsuccessful challenge to the Government on its failure to meet fuel poverty targets forced ministers to introduce policy measures to demonstrate that they were at least taking steps towards this goal.

As well as setting up the Coalition for Access to Justice for the Environment with fellow lawyer Carol Day, one of Michaels' lasting legacies was establishing Friends of the Earth's Rights & Justice Centre (RJC), the UK's first pro bono or affordable legal advice centre for environmental public law. It was a groundbreaking step, and under his careful stewardship the RJC achieved victories that had real impact. These included taking a case all the way to the House of Lords to protect London's Critical Mass cycle ride and acting for a residents group to prevent 7,000 trees from being chopped down for the development of football pitches.

Michaels' legal acumen and passion for campaign work were widely recognised. In 2007 he was named as one of The Lawyer magazine's Hot 100 lawyers, and in 2008 he was nominated as In House Lawyer of the year, with judges commenting that he "set an example for others to follow". But what really distinguished him was his dedication to helping ordinary people use their environmental rights and hold powerful interests to account. He trained members of the public and community activists on how to use their rights to environmental information and on how to obtain access to justice.

As an information law specialist, one of his most prized wins was ensuring that the price charged for photocopying documents being disclosed was restricted to an affordable amount, generally 10p per sheet. His training materials were often headlined with the edict: "Be you ever so high, the law is above you." He pioneered the use of caps on the costs of losing environmental cases to make them more affordable.

He left Friends of the Earth in 2010 to work at the "coal face", in this case a solar company set up by his brother Joe. When he agreed a few months later to provide a witness statement in Friends of the Earth's legal challenge to a cut in the solar Feed-In Tariff, I teased him about the irony of his quick return to case work. As with most things, he took this in his good-natured stride, and recently he had steered his course back to legal work.

Outside the office, Michaels was at his happiest in the natural world and was a devoted father, delighting in summer camping holidays with his family on the beaches of Cornwall.

Upon learning of Michaels' death from cancer, Friends of the Earth's policy and campaigns director, Craig Bennett, said: "Phil was quite simply one of the brightest, most driven, passionate and talented campaigning lawyers I've ever had the pleasure to meet. It was a real honour to work alongside such a giant. An extraordinary life, tragically cut far too short. The Earth has lost one of its very best friends."

Philip Michaels, environmental lawyer: born Hendon, London 19 January 1972; married 2002 Abi Allanson (three children); died Watford 27 August 2014.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in