What were the great ideas of the last century? A random list might include abstract art, behaviourism, corporate identity, automation, digital theory, futurism, the uncertainty principle, Gestalt psychology, industrial design, jet engines, fast food, television, the marginal productivity theory of wages, the hit parade, best-sellers, miniskirts, consumerism, modernism, cassette tapes, nudism, VAT, pop and linguistics.
These ideas grew in a world with fundamental economic convictions, namely the mass-production and mass-consumption of goods. But these assumptions are fast changing. Those goods are now coming from China and the great legacy manufacturing corporations of the West are mostly in a parlous state. In manufacturing, the rates of change are themselves changing. Once companies which owned important patents (Pilkington, Xerox or Kodak) could dominate their markets, but now anything can be reverse engineered (ie, copied) in a Guangzhou sweatshop.
Things happen quickly and, with ideas, speed is a virtuous circle. Hewlett-Packard makes the majority of its earnings from products that didn't exist last year. Once the simple ability to manufacture guaranteed competitive advantage. That's no longer so. Anything can be made anywhere; the world is flat. Instead, the ability to generate ideas has replaced manufacturing as the engine of the economy.
As a result, our flattened world is dematerialising. Production lines have been replaced by a satellite uplink; experiences are better than possessions. Once making cars and computers guaranteed the West's economic dominance, now all we have to sell is ideas.
But this is no bad thing since the value of manufactured goods is falling and the value of ideas is rising. The big question has become where do ideas come from and how can we get more of them? Absurdity seems to be dematerialisation's bedfellow. The two most successful business books of recent years - Jonas Ridderstrale's and Kjell Nordstrom's Funky Business and Robert Sutton's Weird Ideas That Work - have acknowledged this, in their idiosyncratic ways. A pair of Nordic hipsters and a button-down Stanford professor may make an incongruous coupling, but there really is no escaping the zeitgeist.
To have any value, a new idea must be disconcerting. Banker J Pierpoint Morgan said to Alexander Graham Bell: "My colleagues and I have seen and discussed your invention, but we have determined there is no commercial future for it." He was referring to the telephone. In Pierpoint Morgan's day, when you were making so much money out of steel or railroads, why take a punt on a wacky creative idea?
The British, of course, have been specially resistant to new ideas, except in areas where native eccentrics proposed extraordinary innovations in answer to questions no one had asked. Christopher Cockerell's hovercraft or James Dyson's vacuum cleaners would be examples. Cockerell in particular demonstrates, if demonstration were needed, the British knack for doing an unlikely thing rather well... and then losing money on it. Dyson is, of course, quite the opposite.
People with new ideas tend to be both illogical and contradictory. Explaining his discovery of relativity, Einstein said: "I just ignored an axiom." Nothing defines creativity better than the ability to defeat habit by originality. There seems to be a physiological source for new ideas. We have 10 billion brain cells, each one capable of making 5,000 connections, but it is making unusual connections that's a basis for new ideas. But mostly we are very conservative: as far as food is concerned, we eat only about 600 of the planet's hundreds of thousands of edible plants.
The absurd element in the quest for a new idea was brilliantly described by Miles Davies as "don't play what's there, play what's not there". This is what Akio Morita meant when he said Sony's contrarian company philosophy was "doing what others did not". Morita was a businessman capable of extraordinary creative leaps. While Western Electric said in 1947 there were no commercial applications for the semi-conductor, by 1955 Morita had realised such wisdom was wrong and Sony built the world's first transistor radio. His best idea, however, was not to be the father of the tranny, but to see that Tokyo Tsushin Kogyo was a bit of a mouthful for dumb Westerners so he changed it to Sony - a word inspired by the Latin for sound and a misunderstanding of the affectionate English word for a male child. An unusual connection.
New ideas are sometimes at odds with the stern disciplines of management. The 3M engineer responsible for the Post-it note absurdly recalled: "If I knew what I was doing, it would not be research."
The ICA (Institute of Chartered Accountants) publishes a Guide to Professional Ethics, but many of its requirements positively inhibit new ideas. For instance, the ICA insists on integrity by which it means actions uncorrupted by self interest or truth. But, as Picasso - one of the truly turbulent ideas men - said, great artists don't borrow, they steal. The ICA insists on objectivity, defined as: "The state of mind which has regard to all considerations relevant to the task in hand, but no other." That seems to exclude the possibility of uninhibited free-thinking. The ICA insists on competence: "A member should undertake professional work only where he has the necessary competence required." This inhibits daring innovation. Risk-taking, tolerance of error, are all necessary to creativity. Picasso said of competence: "I am always doing that which I cannot do, in order that I may learn how to do it." And we have Ludwig Wittgenstein versus the accountancy profession when he said, "If people never did silly things, nothing intelligent would happen."
Here's a list of here-today gone-tomorrow ideas ruefully intended to revive moribund industries: just-in-time manufacturing, total quality management, supply-chain management, management by objectives, business process re-engineering, management by walking around, benchmarking, outsourcing, what if, gateway, downsizing, flattening, evaluation, strategic alliances and the fearfully significant brainstorming.
Brainstorming never works because ideas are not generated systematically, but absurdly; ideas do not respect or follow the dynamics of a formal meeting. Brainstorming was invented by adman Alex Osborn in his 1950s business bestseller Applied Imagination. But creative people tend to be more solitary: support of others not needed. Indeed, one test (although not an infallible one) for authentic creativity is that support is rejected and criticism not even considered. Beethoven once told a grumbling violinist to shut up and get on with it because he didn't care what the musician thought and, in any case, God had helped him write that particular unplayable line.
Is it ever going to be possible to quantify the value of ideas? There is an interesting precedent here. In 1948, Claude Shannon published his " Mathematical Theory of Communications" in the Bell Systems Technical Journal. Here Shannon laid the practical basis for our digital revolution. He popularised the word "entropy" (adapted from thermodynamics). He defined the difference between signal and noise. And he made the important distinction between mere data (measurements) and information (data with value which affects behaviour). Then, not taking a breath, Shannon established the binary maths that moved us from analogue to digital systems. The separation of the medium and the message was another of his proprietary insights. This distinction between form and content allowed engineers to concentrate on technology, freeing the rest of us. In one academic paper, Shannon established the general rules of information theory and predicted the convergence of computers and phones. Shannon had more new ideas than most and to demonstrate his resistance to convention he said: "I had to invent any maths that was needed."
When it comes to generating ideas, the distinction between visionary genius and aberrant behaviour is not always clear. Cultures which encourage ideas must learn to tolerate error. Mistakes, James Joyce said, are the " portals of discovery". According to IBM's Thomas Watson, "If you want to succeed, double your failure rate." Soichiro Honda believed, "Success represents the one per cent of your work which results from the 99 per cent that is called failure." Henry Ford said, "Failure is the opportunity to begin again more intelligently."
Where then do ideas come from? Porsche's chief designer once explained what inspired him. He said modern sculpture and animal forms, getting a high while running, basketball shoes, running shoes, ski boots, sports gear in general, the Peak Tram in Hong Kong, the plastic smell from car seat covers, elevators, escalators and Pat Metheny's album As Falls Wichita So Falls Wichita Falls. The creative personality who is likely to get a new idea also approves of intellectual theft, enjoys separation, benefits from isolation and encourages dissent. All these apparently anti-social factors help the imagination to grow (although history suggests that drink and drugs have also played a part). Misunderstanding is a definition of a genuinely new idea. Only one thing is certain about new ideas: their patterns cannot be accurately predicted.
As soon as Thackeray had written something that pleased him, he asked himself (bemused), "How did I think of that?" Johannes Brahms explained that when he had a new musical idea he would leave it alone for a while and then when he returned to it, the idea would have developed all by itself. Creativity is the last legitimate means of securing an unfair advantage. And creative intelligence prefers unknown territory: Bob Dylan once said "I follow no one". Music supplies many other affecting examples of the creative personality. From Beethoven to John Lennon, great innovators have been cussed, uncooperative and frankly unconcerned with their immediate audience.
The generation of ideas is now the most important economic objective. But unfortunately for conventional businesses, the people best able to generate them are unpredictable, quixotic and generally unsuited to a formal business environment. Someone asked Miles Davies what he was going to do. He said: "I'll play it first and tell you what it's about later." And then he had a new idea. It is all about unconventional wisdom.
Every Christmas we're told there will be a return to the simpler toys of yesteryear - as if pre-teens will rise up as one and switch off their PlayStations - but this year, it might just happen. The Bilibo comes with no instructions, batteries, rules or bits to plug in.
"It's a shell-shaped, hard-wearing piece of plastic, and that's it," admits a spokesperson for Treasure Trove, the award-winning toy's UK distributors. "But when you give it [to kids], the possibilities are endless." Using the power of imagination, it can be turned it into almost anything - and at least it's one toy that won't be broken by Boxing Day. Johnny Davis
D'uh? Isn't this idea as old as death and taxes? Well, yes and no. What's new is positive psychology, a school of thought suggesting there are formulae that can quantitively increase our happiness and outlined in books such as 'The Happiness Hypothesis'. Professor Martin Seligman of the University of Pennsylvania, "the father of positive psychology", suggests that the formulae can be boiled down to: pleasure + engagement + meaning = happiness. Pleasure's inbuilt flaw is that it's fleeting, so to it is added a sense of engrossment and of meaning. Of course, the formula is not definitive - for instance, too much "engagement" leads to workaholism, but Seligman suggests you can be happier if you're willing to engage in exercises such as disputation, which involves challenging negative thoughts, playing to your strengths, and counting your blessings. Happier now? Stuart Husband
3. Screw-top wine
In recent years, winemakers have made huge leaps forward by figuring out how to make wines that unfailingly preserve the intrinsic qualities of their constituent grapes. The techniques used are as far removed from the old-fashioned romantic image of winemaking (grizzled French guy with beret and Gitanes) as Donald Rumsfeld is from Johnny Depp, but they are wonderful advances. Temperature control, pneumatic presses, stainless-steel fermenting tanks - it scores zero out of 100 for romance, but attains perfect marks for quality.
The screwcap, almost always referred to in the wine world as the Stelvin (after the leading manufacturer), is the equivalent of those technologies for keeping the finished product in tiptop condition. If a wine possesses rapturous depths of fruit flavour and wonderful acidity to keep it fresh, the screwcap will make sure it stays like that for as long as the wine is likely to be stored.
It was not always thus: early screwcaps had technical faults that could allow too much air in (disaster) or let the wine come into contact with the paper between the cap's plastic seal and the metal cap (disaster). But now that the technology has been perfected, the 21st-century wine industry has met its perfect closure. In years to come, we will see it more and more, and on ever-more-expensive wines. Richard Ehrlich
4. Blockbuster television
The film and television industries have long enjoyed a close relationship but, until recently, there was no doubt which one was the dominant partner. Sure, movie stars may have made guest appearances on television but, generally, it was the ambition of every small-screen actor, writer and director to, one day, graduate to cinema. But no more.
When '24' exploded on to our screens in 2001, a subtle, but fundamental shift took place in the balance of power. Starring Hollywood veteran Kiefer Sutherland, it looked like a slick blockbuster film, but was stretched over 18 hours of frantic suspense.
Meanwhile, the Second World War miniseries 'Band of Brothers', which came out in the same year and was produced by Steven Spielberg and Tom Hanks, cost a huge $125m to make, dwarfing even the then-impressive $35m first-season budget of '24' and compounding the feeling that television was now being taken as seriously as film.
Ever since, numerous sophisticated, entertaining programmes - such as 'The Sopranos', 'West Wing' and 'Lost' - have proved television can do things the ideas-bankrupt, CGI-reliant, sequel-riven dream factory could only, er, dream about. Keith Laidlaw
Want to be introduced to some new music? Just tell this internet radio station what you like, and it will play you similar tracks you may not have heard of, like having a personal DJ perfectly tuned to your personal tastes.
6. Pigeon spikes
Anti-roosting pigeon spikes were designed as a humane deterrent not, as some of us might prefer, as a lethal skewer. The concept is to prevent pigeons landing, nesting and defecating on property, but also allowing them to fly away. Sounds simple. But it's taken a few thousand years of the building-pigeon conundrum for someone to come up with a solution. David Jones, Managing Director of Jones & Son, the original pigeon-spike company, had the idea when working on pest control in London. Complex systems didn't seem to work and netting often trapped birds. Such measures were also costly and difficult to affix. Pigeon spikes can be attached, almost anywhere, with silicon adhesive, screws, nails, cable ties or clips. Their precise dimensions mean they are inoffensive to small birds but repellent to pigeons. David Baskerville, of Jones & Son, says sales are booming: "We now export them to Australia, Thailand and China," he says. "Fortunately for us, there are pigeons everywhere." Jennifer Stuart-Smith
For more information, go to www.pigeonoff.co.uk
7. Book swapping
As a nation, we bought nearly 8 million new books last year, and it's a fair bet most of those were read just once (if at all) before being dumped on a shelf. Many homes own hundreds of books that will never be read again. You could donate unwanted books to a charity shop, of course, or try shifting them on eBay, but the resale value is likely to be low. So why not try www.readitswapit.com? The idea behind the website is that you exchange the books you are unlikely to read again for ones you just might. Users provide a list of their unwanted books. They can then browse around to see what other swappers are offering. If you find a book you want, you email its owner, asking them to check out your list and, if they see a title they like, all each of you pays is the cost of posting your book second-class. At the moment, the site is a bit dominated by the likes of The Da Vinci Code but, with 49,000 books available at the time of writing, you're bound to find something to interest you. Helen Davies
8. Decentralised energy
The UK's current energy system is based on the centralised model, using large-scale coal, oil, gas and nuclear power stations, located far from the point of use. This way, more than 60 per cent of the original energy input is lost in the form of waste heat at the power station. More losses occur transporting electricity over distances to its point of use, and through our inefficient homes and appliances, meaning we typically utilise only 22 per cent of the energy that originally went into power stations. Wasted energy means less energy security and more carbon dioxide emissions.
With a decentralised model, energy is produced close to the point of use. Using CHP (combined heat and power) units, which can vary in scale from supplying a single home to a city district, heat produced by electricity generation is channelled through underground networks to heat buildings and provide hot water; minimal energy is lost as waste heat, or in electricity transmission. This system can integrate renewable technologies such as solar panels and wind turbines. Individual buildings and districts stop being just consumers of energy and start generating it. It's a system that is more secure, more efficient and it opens the way for a greater range of technologies and innovation that would help cleaner fuels and renewables take off.
Sound unrealistic? Actually, 50 per cent of Denmark's electricity is generated in a decentralised system, and Copenhagen has heat networks travelling over 40km. In Finland, 98 per cent of Helsinki is heated by community heat networks. So when Tony Blair says we need new centralised nuclear power to fight climate change, he is clearly stuck in the 20th century. What we need is an energy revolution for the 21st century that delivers a new efficient system for the future in the form of decentralised energy; a system that is cheaper, cleaner and more secure. Simon Reddy Policy and solutions director, Greenpeace UK
For more information, go to www.greenpeace.org.uk
As well as letting you buy or sell almost anything (handy), eBay has shifted power away from chain stores and back towards individuals (revolutionary). Now anyone can be a retailer.
10. Venture philanthropy
When renowned investor Warren Buffett decided to donate most of his multi-billion fortune to charity earlier this year, there was a good reason why he picked the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation rather than, say, a local cat rescue centre. Buffett and Gates represent a new breed of philanthropist - one who is not content to simply write out cheques but who wants to use their business skills to help solve the world's problems.
These so-called "venture philanthropists" increasingly want to monitor the organisations they have invested in as well as to provide key management support. They take business practices and apply them to social sector companies, making sure their structures are right, encouraging them to take managed risks, develop tools to track effectiveness, and generate measurable returns.
Permira, one of the world's largest private equity firms, recently announced a €1million partnership with us at Community Action Network to help social enterprises (organisations with the aim of creating social good) to scale up. The scheme, Breakthrough, will help "social entrepreneurs" overcome barriers to growth by offering hands-on mentoring, financial and operational support.
Venture philanthropy is about more than providing finance; it reflects a growing understanding that the most valuable way the commercial sector can offer its support is thought the transfer of skills. The expertise of companies such as Permira in growing and transforming commercial firms is of huge value to a social entrepreneur struggling to break out regionally or nationally. Adele Blakebrough MBE co-founder of Community Action Network, which helps social entrepreneurs
As well as providing local information such as house prices or crime statistics for any area in the UK, this site's 'find my nearest' feature allows you to find the businesses, shops and services closest to your home at the touch of a button.
12. Light-up lipstick
How many former Spice Girls does it take to have a good idea? Just one - Miss Emma Bunton. On a night out, she and make-up designer (and creator of Eyeko cosmetics) Nina Leykind decided that they were fed up with trying to do their make-up in the back of a darkened limo.
And lo, the Liparazzi was born. It's a lipstick with a light. Click the button on the base of the shaft, and your mouth is cast in a bright spotlight. (This feature also comes in handy if you ever find yourself scrabbling in a dim corner for your keys, or if you are stuck in the dark and have important business documents to read, or, for that matter, 40 pages of 'The Female Eunuch'.) The Liparazzi case is mirrored, too, so it basically works like a small portable dressing table.
These are features, surely, that lipsticks should have as a matter of course. Bravo, Baby Spice. Perhaps Ginger will now invent the self-cleaning flannel. Hermione Eyre
For more information, go to www.liparazzi.com
13. De Young Museum
The copper-clad sheath and tower of the De Young Museum in San Francisco, perforated and embossed with collages mapped from photographs of light dappling through trees in Golden Gate Park, is less interested in portraying physical and intellectual chaos than in doing what its co-architect Jacques Herzog calls "the maximum thing". This is a building as an agent of heightened perception, right on the edge of sensual overload.
The Swiss practice Herzog & de Meuron has entered the third millennium determined to prove that architecture's material and formal beauty can be resonant, rather than ephemeral - and the De Young is a superb demonstration of sensuality, mystery and a physical narrative that owes as much to cinematic panning shots and jump-cuts as it does to architectural precedent.
The De Young is kryptonite architecture: it disables cheaply ironic or slackerish responses; it is beyond cool; its overall form, and its tiniest details, are about rigour. The building is an essay in emotional and physical extremity - and even, as Herzog suggests, a kind of fear. And though it may look weirdly unreal, its electrifying physicality is the dominant vibe.
The De Young is also beautifully crafted, a trademark of the obsessive perfectionism of the Basel-based practice - and a polemical declaration that architecture can have a meaningful, rather than merely entertaining, future. Jay Merrick
For more information, visit www.thinker.org/deyoung/
14. Sky Plus
I recently went to the Maldives for 10 days to do a spot of scuba-diving. On my return, I was able to watch the endless hours of Big Brother my Sky Plus hard-drive had recorded for me. I could also save time by fast-forwarding through the adverts and the bits when Aisleyne was crying in the diary room. I love Sky Plus. If I was still single, I would marry it. It never lets me down, recording my favourite programmes even when I'm too drunk to remember them. I love coming home late and discovering what treats it can find for me. It's especially good for me as I tend to like odd documentaries on BBC Four at 3am and I'm too old to stay up that late now. I once met the man who claimed to have invented Sky Plus. I bought him an evening of free drinks. Recently it has also solved my tricky problem as to whether to give up Big Brother for Love Island - now I can just watch them both and never go out socially again. And just when I think things couldn't get better, a leaflet arrives telling me I can use the internet or my mobile phone to order my machine to record stuff when I'm away from home. Happy days. Sky Plus - God bless her and all that sail in her. Dom Joly TV presenter, writer and comedian
15. Tooth whitening
The concept of tooth whitening is nothing new - the ancient Romans tried using urine to remove stains, and, until the 18th century, barbers would offer to lighten the teeth of their clients by filing them down, then painting what remained with nitric acid. Safer and more effective techniques which use hydrogen peroxide to bleach dentine - the layer underneath the enamel - have been around for about 50 years, but require you to wear a mouthguard filled with whitening gel for at least two hours each day for a fortnight. Which is why BriteSmile is such a brilliant idea. This technique, invented by Dr John Warner, a former NASA scientist, involves a dentist applying whitening gel to the teeth, then using a special lamp to shine high-intensity light on to the teeth to accelerate the bleaching process. The treatment costs around £500 and the result, after one hour, is teeth that are permanently lightened by up to nine shades - the difference between a manky British mouth and a gleaming Hollywood smile. It's thanks to BriteSmile that, now, for any D-list celebrity, revealing teeth any less than blinding white is a sin. But there is a catch: if you want to keep the whitened appearance, you'll need to avoid red wine, tea, coffee and cigarettes. So, unless you're willing to live a life as pure as your smile, you may have to stick with non-Hollywood teeth after all. HD
16. Time together
Time Together is a scheme running in 24 locations across the UK that aims to break down some of the barriers that can prevent refugees establishing themselves here, by bringing them together with existing members of their new communities. These volunteers become a "mentor" to the refugee, helping them to integrate into life in this country, learn more about British culture and find work .
I became a mentor last year, and was chosen by Asha, a remarkable woman who escaped the horrors of Somalia and now lives in London, struggling to bring up three children on her own. All her life she has struggled, first against her father to stay at school and train to be a doctor, then to escape war in Somalian, and now to learn good enough English to find medical-related work. None of her children spoke English when they arrived; now her eldest daughter has made it to medical school, studying with utter determination, perched on a bed in their two-room flat.
We meet and talk, sometimes with her children. We go to public places such as the British Museum and the South Bank, and I asked their MP to arrange a tour of the House of Commons - all places they hadn't seen before but now known they are free to visit. Soon they will get British nationality, and we will be all the better for new citizens so determined to make the most of every opportunity.
The scheme is run by a charity called TimeBank, and so far more than 1,000 refugees have been found mentors. I couldn't recommend it more highly: I probably get more out of it than I have been able to offer Asha. Polly Toynbee writer and 'volunteer mentor'
The current online phenomenon combines the best functions of more specialised sites (blogging, MP3 swapping, networking) to great effect, and now accounts for an incredible 80 per cent of all traffic to social networking sites.
18. Hypoallergenic pets
Recent research by scientists at biotechnology company, Allerca, in the US, discovered that babies may be at a 50 per cent greater risk of developing eczema if their family has a cat.
Apparently many cat allergies are caused by a protein contained in the cat's skin flakes and saliva deposited on the fur when the animal grooms itself. It can trigger an allergic reaction in minutes if breathed in by an asthma sufferer.
This is bad news for moggies you might think. But before you ditch the idea of buying one of the most affectionate and entertaining of pets completely, Allerca has managed to breed the world's first scientifically-proven hypoallergenic cats.
With the pets now on sale in the UK (albeit for the rather princely sum of £7,500 each), people who have lived without the companionship of a cat because of their allergies can now have one of their own without the costs of allergy treatments and their associated health risks. Sweet relief indeed for the 2.6m UK asthma sufferers whose attacks are triggered by their animals, and far better than buying one of the ugly and hairless Sphynx breeds any day of the week. Tom Greatrex
For more information, go to www.allerca.com
19. CCTV Building
The first great architectural icon of the third millennium - and a powerful blow against established notions of skyscraper verticality - will be the CCTV Building in Beijing, designed by the Dutch architect Rem Koolhaas's OMA practice and currently under construction. The word "icon" suggests certainty and virtuosity; the CCTV Building's power lies in its twisting of one Modernist icon, the skyscraper, into a vast glass and steel fortune cookie - corporate complexity, rather than vertical bling.
Its graphic punch demonstrates the doubt created by what Koolhaas refers to as "the violent surf of information". The architect has Utopian instincts, but admits that architects are now reduced to playing catch-up with the slews of imagery, information and corporate forces that increasingly dominate thought and behaviour.
"That belief in manifestos, and that confidence that we knew what to do, have now completely collapsed," he says. "Nowadays, we no longer write manifestos; at most, we write portraits of particular cities, in the hope, not of developing a theory of what to do with them, but of understanding how cities exist currently. We're just trying to understand what's happening."
The CCTV Building invokes the Tatlin Tower, a Constructivist model structure that helped to jolt the architectural world into Modernism in 1919. Koolhaas's fortune cookie, both icon and anti-icon, is beyond "-isms"; it's a brilliant pan-cultural special effect. JM
20. Satellite navigation
One of the greatest ideas of recent times is the satellite navigation system, of which GPS (Global Positioning System) is perhaps the best known. Since I installed one given to me by one of my sponsors, RS Components, in my E-type Jaguar, the instructions - spoken to me by a lady I call Talula - prevent me from getting lost en route to exhibitions.
The original motivation for satellite navigation was for military applications, both in the delivery of weapons and the strategic tracking of troops. However, numerous civilian uses have emerged over the past few years, with applications ranging from vast improvements in life-saving services, such as search and rescue operations, to the tracking of both people and wildlife.
Satellite-based global surveying systems and geophysical sciences are benefiting all. It is rare these days to meet an explorer, pilot, sailor or even a taxi driver who, in their line of work, is not equipped with satellite navigation. But principally, I like the progress being made in finding and negating the activities of terrorists wherever they may be. Trevor Bayliss inventor of the wind-up radio
21. Green roofs
A hi-tech 21st-century version of the traditional turf roofs still found in parts of Scandinavia, a green roof is one covered with a thin layer of growing material which, in turn, supports a range of low-maintenance plants such as stonecrop and moss - all ready-grown on a kind of net matting which can be cut to fit. The results may be pretty, but it's not so much the aesthetics as the ecological and, to a lesser extent, economic benefits that really count. They're good for insects and birds, they soak up between 50 and 80 per cent of the rainwater that falls on them, and they provide natural insulation. Provided your roof is strong enough and not too steep (you can plant on slopes of up to 30 degrees), a green roof is now the perfect eco-friendly architectural accessory. Christopher Stocks
For more information, see www.livingroofs.org or pick up a copy of 'Planting Green Roofs and Living Walls' by Nigel Dunnett and Noel Kingsbury (Timber Press, £25)
Ever tried to buy something from a US-based website, only to discover that it can't be delivered to the UK? International Checkout can order it for you, have it delivered to its warehouse, then send it anywhere in the world
23. LED bulbs
The light bulb hasn't changed very much since it was patented by Briton Joseph Swan in 1878, one year before the somewhat better-known Thomas Edison laid claim to it. Flip a switch, it will give you light. It is fragile and - fzzzt - it doesn't last very long.
But electronic LEDs - light-emitting diodes - are set to change that, with a low-power, long-life alternative just a few years away. Previously only available in red, yellow or green, the first white LED was developed in the early 1990s, and, since then, its use has spread in flashlights and miners-style headbands. White LEDs light up almost instantly and, given their solid construction, can take much more of a knock than traditional bulbs.
As with other electronic devices, the cost of LEDs is falling. Their use in homes is sparse so far, but a US Department of Energy report found that converting to LED lighting would reduce the country's energy consumption by 29 per cent by 2025, cutting energy bills by $125bn and reduce carbon emissions.
The real problem so far has been their unnerving blue-white colour, a side-effect of the chemical used in their manufacture. That has now been solved to give a warm, yellow light from a device that will last for decades, never break and slash your power bill. Mark White
Have you ever gone into a record shop and confessed: "I'm trying to get hold of this CD but I don't really know who the artist is, or the name of the song, but it goes a bit like this..."? Well now you and record shop staff can breathe a sigh of relief, thanks to Shazam.
This amazingly handy service allows users to identify a song using only a mobile phone. Just dial 2580, hold your handset up to the speaker for 10-15 seconds, and you will magically receive the elusive track's full details via a text message. It works like this: a computer scans the "mathematical" makeup of the song and then matches it to one of the entries in Shazam's database of around 3 million tracks.
This revolutionary technology has led to more than 20 million calls being made to the company worldwide, and it is widely recognised as the fastest and most accurate music-recognition service. There is one drawback: the song must be played quite loud, so be prepared to make some noise. Rhiannon Mee
25. Hourly car hire
Streetcar is a brilliant new company that turns the concept of hiring a car on its head. The best bit is that, instead of paying for a whole day, you pay by the hour. After signing up, you get a swipe card which will be your key. When you want to hire a car you go online and it tells you the nearest location where one is parked - so you don't even have to go to an office. The cynical will see plenty of flaws in the idea - the main one being that it runs on trust and sharing (my God, a company treating its customers like responsible adults). So far, the service is only available in London and costs £4.95 with 30 miles of free petrol. Johnny Dee
26. The $100 laptop
If, as the old proverb says, teaching a man to catch fish will feed him for a lifetime, then what could you achieve by giving his children a laptop? Quite a lot, according to the One Laptop per Child group, which is on course to deliver millions of stripped-down PCs by the middle of 2007. It is the brainchild of Nicholas Negroponte, the co-founder of MIT's Media Lab, who announced the project in January, 2005, at the World Economic Forum meeting in Davos, Switzerland. "It's an education project, not a laptop project, " he says.
The plan is for governments to buy and distribute the laptops. The machines in question will come with low-power see-in-the-sun displays, open-source web browsers and easily customisable word processors, and power supplies rechargeable by hand cranks, foot pumps, or pulleys that can be harnessed to the family cattle. They will also be equipped with wireless broadband. Costs have been kept low by limiting memory to 500MB of flash storage, about the same as the smallest iPod Shuffle.
Initial target countries are Brazil, Nigeria, Thailand and Argentina, followed by China, India, Egypt and Mexico, though two US states also want to buy them for poor students. Governments have to order in units of one million, and it's hoped the cost will fall to $50 (£27) in a virtuous race to the bottom.
There are critics, however. Bill Gates derides the hand-crank notion, and others have pointed to the problems of imposing a top-down solution; that computers could be sold for food; that computers need to be maintained; that developing countries need food and clean water before iTunes. This all may be true. But what if it works? MW
For more information, go to www.laptop.org
27. I ' My Dog Poop Scoops
While picking up their dog's poop, many people think only of the short-term benefits of keeping parks clean or dodging a fine. Few consider the problem of millions of tons of dog waste and plastic sitting in landfill. Thankfully, Terry Barton did, when he developed I ' My Dog Poop Scoops.
They're made from recycled card, paper and water-based inks and come with two cardboard spatulas which flip the offending object into a brown paper holder. You can kiss goodbye to that squishy sensation and, once done, you're left holding just a brown paper bag. Plus, it biodegrades fully and without a negative environmental effect.
According to Barton, the bags, which were initially seen as a joke, are taking off: "We've solved a nasty problem, very sweetly," he says. In short, he's made a successful business of dog's business. JSS
For more information, go to www.poopscoop.biz
Move over Fairtrade, Equitrade's the latest economic model for helping to end poverty through sustainable commercial international trade. Fairtrade aims to help the globe's marginalised food growers, working through cooperatives guaranteeing environmental and social standards. But Equitrade tries to ensure that, not only does a product's raw materials originate from a poor community, it also tries to ensure it is manufactured, packaged and even marketed from there too.
Malagasy, the first Equitrade firm in the world, says it "will not sell cash crops from Madagascar at pence per kilogram, so that other companies can sell them at pounds per kilogram in international markets". Malagasy's (meaning from Madagascar) chocolate is classed as "equitably traded" and this means it shares the income it receives from selling its finished product abroad equally with its various suppliers at home in Madagascar.
Neil Kelsall, a director at Malagasy says: "Probably only about 5p of the £1.70 cost of an average fairly traded chocolate bar goes back to the country. The difference with Malagasy equitrade is that 40 per cent of the income from a bar of Malagasy chocolate stays in Madagascar, and the country further benefits because 11 per cent tax is paid to the government."
This commendable approach to fair trade also enables the people of Madagascar to preserve the unique eco-systems, habitat and wildlife of the island. Other companies should sign up and get involved immediately and help take on the buying power of the big supermarket chains. TG
For more information, go to www.equitrade.org
29. Sheep's-wool insulation
Sheep can adapt to many different environments as their wool protects them through hot, cold, damp and dry seasons. Man has also used wool for its protective properties and for the many other benefits offered by the material. Wool's unique advantage, though, is its ability to absorb moisture from the surrounding air, without itself becoming wet to touch, and then releasing it again when the atmosphere dries out.
Organisations such as Sheep Wool Insulation and Thermafleece are capitalising on this natural and sustainable source of insulation by turning it into an energy-efficient insulating material. Not only is it flame-retardant and self-extinguishing, wool's "green" appeal is obvious - vital for the latest generation of ethical consumers avidly buying into anything with an environmentally conscious stamp. Reducing the flow of heat into a home by up to 7C during the summer, increasing the temperature by 4C in the winter, sheep's wool also uses only 14 per cent of the energy it takes to make glass-fibre insulation, thus paying the consumer back its energy-saving costs almost seven times faster. Oh yes, it's even halting the rapid decline of hill farming in the UK and Ireland. TG
Amazon was the first company to fully realise the potential for selling goods over the internet. Without the overheads and storage issues faced by high-street stores, it offers customers a huge diversity of goods at low prices.
31. Internet campaigning
In the 2004 US presidential contest, Howard Dean was the Democratic challenger with a difference. He bypassed the traditional fundraising routes by mobilising small donations via the internet, until his campaign kinnocked (from the verb "to kinnock", to destroy a promising career with a display of slightly alarming exuberance), with his famous "scream" at a rally in Iowa.
But you can see the attraction here. Party membership numbers have declined, and all three main parties are increasingly dependent on a small number of rich men for most of their funds. The web, meanwhile, is where a lot of the fiercest political action is, and anyone can join in. The Labour Party is trying to set up an internet community of "registered supporters". As for the Conservatives, their plans to organise US-style primary election to choose the Tory candidate for London mayor next year will give an advantage to a well-organised internet campaign.
The problem with the idea of mass parties is that they depended on thousands of unpaid people collecting tiny sums of money at front doors, club doors or the workplace. Now the internet makes that possible in cyberspace. Who will exploit it first? John Rentoul
32. The long tail
If the old entertainment economy was about blockbusters, argues Chris Anderson in his book, The Long Tail: Why The Future of Business is Selling Less of More, the new era is all about niches. The smash'n'grab model, where everyone rushes to the latest Pirates of the Caribbean sequel or snaps up the new Dan Brown novel is the "short head". Behind this is the "long tail" curve, where ostensibly less-popular products have a healthy afterlife of their own, thanks to new-tech delivery methods - cheap computer hardware, broadband - and filters such as blogs and online reviews which help to match supply and demand.
At Amazon.com, around a quarter of all book sales come from outside the site's top-100,000 bestsellers. Online music retailer Rhapsody, which has a library of 1.5 million songs, reported that, while its top 1,000 tracks are downloaded more than 10,000 times a month each, these represent less than 0.01 per cent of its catalogue, and everything up to its top 1,000,000th track is streamed at least once a month.
"What's truly amazing about the long tail is its sheer size," Anderson writes. "If you combine enough of the non-hits, you've actually established a market that rivals the hits." And in the best-case scenario, this means a heterogeneous marketplace. "The filters help people move from the world they know (hits) to the world they don't (niches)," says Anderson. "They drive demand down the tail by revealing goods and services that appeal more than the lowest common denominator fare that crowd the channels of traditional mass-market distribution." Wagging the dog, indeed. SH
33. Change the World 9 to 5
'Change the World 9 to 5' is a sequel to another book, called 'Change the World for a Fiver'. Both contain 50 simple, practical tips that you can integrate into your life to help improve things. It ranges from small-scale stuff such as a reminder to say "thank you" to people or bigger ideas such as encouraging people in your office to turn the lights off at night. No one thing is very big in its own right, but all those individual actions add up to a big effect if everyone's doing them.
The first book is an amazing success stories: the organisation behind it, We Are What We Do, initially printed just 5,000 copies and ended up selling 600,000. With this one, because it's based on things you can do at work, they've realised they can get companies to buy it to give out to team members. I'm going to give everyone at Innocent a copy for Christmas, while Sainsbury's has ordered 20,000 copies, which is about what most books sell in total. Richard Reed co-founder of Innocent drinks
For more information, go to www.wearewhatwedo.org
34. Hub working
Many of us have fantasies of working from home, imagining afternoons off down the park, recreational shopping or a round of golf when we should be filing a report or chasing customers. The reality is you will be spending most of you time on your laptop, listening to Radio Five Live, struggling to meet deadlines and not talking to anyone for weeks.
Now there appears to be an alternative, somewhere self-employed freelance types can toil but fool themselves that they are simultaneously working and relaxing. Hundreds of work hubs are springing up throughout the world to service this need, offering the self-employed all the joys of having both a pretend office for meetings and work areas that are really pretend cafés. Not only that but, while you are in these hubs, you will be among other human beings with whom you can enjoy crap conversations about last night's telly just like those regular office drones who are jealous of you working from home. JDee
For more information, go to www.hubworking.net
35. Oyster cards
These pre-pay plastic travelcards provide light-blue relief for 5 million Londoners facing the daily bedevilment of a decrepit transport system. Introduced in 2003, the Oyster is a contactless smartcard used to pay bus and tube fares without the need to fumble for cash. Commuters in Hong Kong have used a similar "Octopus" card for a decade. Unlike Hong Kong, however, Londoners are thus far unable to also use their cards as " emoney" to buy newspapers, sweets etc en route. That proposed scheme collapsed in 2005 after failing to find a backer, although it may be revived at some point. Regardless, aided by some vigorous advertising by Mayor Ken Livingstone, the Oyster has "Got London Moving" and become part of its visual language along the way. And the name? It was chosen because " the oyster protects a pearl in much the same way the card protects the cardholder's money". Nice. JD
36. Magic plasters
It's the first hot day of the year and you decide to wear sandals to work. You are enjoying the sense of freedom and endless possibility presented by exposing your toes in public. You take a dozen or so steps and gradually become aware of a rubbing sensation. Within two more steps, you have a blister. You will spend the next few days debating whether to burst it or not but, whatever you decide, the outcome will be the same: you'll be left with a patch of hard skin, followed by an ugly purple mark, which may or may not have faded a year later when you will begin the whole charade again. Not any more. New blister plasters employ hydrocolloid technology, which is a fancy way of saying that they absorb moisture to form a gel which stops the skin over the blister from drying out and going hard. Leave the plaster on for a couple of days and the blister disappears as if by magic. HD
37. Flavoured straws
While the idea of the Sipahh milk-flavouring straw is simple - welded filters at the ends of the straw hold flavoured beads in place to suck milk past - it took more than seven years to develop. With the current fuss about children's diets, the fact the straw uses no artificial colours or preservatives, has no fat, contains just half a teaspoon of sugar, and encourages the drinking of milk has seen it licenced to 65 countries including most of Europe, the Caribbean, parts of Africa, and even Iran and Iraq. But milk is just the start, as anything could be put into the beads. They could be used with vitamins and minerals, or to improve water quality. They could deliver drugs to children, the elderly and people who have trouble swallowing pills. The straws are also light, portable and can be recycled. Oh, and they taste delicious with milk. As the name suggests, say "aah". MW
Though apparently an overnight sensation when the entire world went Sudoko potty in the summer of 2005, its roots actually go back far further (a version called Latin Squares kept Arabic numerologists entertained on long journeys back in AD 990). Modern Sudoko was finalised in 1979 by Howard Garns, a 74-year-old freelance puzzle constructor from Indianapolis, who invented the current 9x9 grid. A hit in Japan in the 1980s after being published in a magazine as the game Number Place, the tipping point came when the magazine was reprinted last year and newspapers the world over caught on. Sudoku is a short version of a longer Japanese phrase, which roughly translates as "the digits must remain single" and its democratic popularity is down to the fact that, while the basic rules are simple, the level of difficulty can be varied. In the age of the PlayStation, it's gratifying to see so much pleasure being derived from pen, paper and, yes indeed, your brain. JD
39. Deal or No Deal
"A quarter of a million pounds. Twenty-two identical, sealed boxes. And no questions. Except one: deal or no deal?" This is a format so simple it can be explained in 20 words. A game show so riveting it could turn even the "cursed" Noel Edmonds into one of the highest-paid personalities on UK television in less than a year. A cultural phenomenon so versatile there are already 26 versions around the world - from Bulgaria to Brazil, from Thailand to Tunisia. It started life in 2001 as one strand in a Dutch lottery programme. Created by John de Mol - co-founder of Endemol, the company behind 'Big Brother' - by the time it hit UK screens in October 2005, the format had been whittled down to its core concept: 22 boxes, containing amounts from 1p to £250,000, which a contestant opens at random. At intervals, The Banker will offer the contestant an amount of money for the box in front of them. The contestant has to decide whether to sell their box based on which amounts have been revealed. For economists, the programme is a repeated exercise in decision theory, risk aversion and the law of diminishing returns; for viewers, it is an opportunity to put yourself in the shoes of the contestant: what would you decide? Edmonds believes the show's popularity is entirely down to its simplicity. "Anyone can play and anyone can win. In that regard I think it is the perfect television format." Simmy Richman
' Deal or No Deal' returns to Channel 4 on 28 August
It's a simple idea: a free, online encyclopedia that anyone can contribute to. With almost five million entries in 200 different languages, complaints about the odd inaccuracy miss the point: the amazing thing is how often it is correct.
41. Meat growing
As the smell from thousands of barbecues stretches across the land, think - if only for a moment - about where that sausage, steak or chicken wing came from. Industrial food production is widely acknowledged as inhumane and creates health problems and pollution.
Well, more than a dozen labs in Holland and America are currently working out how to grow meat. The benefits of a safer and healthier meat are considerable: lower coronary heart disease, for example, and zero risk of a species-jumping flu. Meat can already be grown; take cells from an animal, soak them in nutrients, attach to a scaffold (a kind of artificial skeleton), stretch the scaffold to exercise the cells and, once ready, harvest the cells and process to form sausages, hamburgers or chicken nuggets (all only marginally less unappetising than the way chicken nuggets are currently put together). No one has tasted the results yet, and unprocessed meat such as steaks and pork chops could be a decade or more away as researchers are having trouble giving the meat texture. But one cell could produce the world's entire meat supply. Pumping animals full of antibiotics to counter the appalling conditions under which they're raised would end. It's not much less natural than coralling animals in vast, dark barns, and feeding them a diet of growth hormones and animal waste and remains. And it raises interesting ethical questions for vegetarians. According to scientists, the economics will make it unviable for between five and 10 years. They're studying cheaper growth mediums - something like soyabeans would see the prices approach mass-market levels, according to one researcher. And, just think: it's not that long since DVD players cost £500. MW
42. Parasitic architecture
With housing in demand as never before and green belt-style planning laws making the business of constructing new buildings an increasingly tricky business, we are seeing "parasitic architecture" - a self-contained new building that is attached to an existing structure - becoming an increasingly viable option for homebuyers in the 21st century.
Architectural practices such as Spacebox in Holland, Werner Aisslinger in Germany and Mae in the UK have all designed cube, pod and even cantilevered units that can be lifted by crane up on to existing rooftops or even bolted on to the side of a building.
Mae's recent Lift-up House - which is a two-bedroom apartment on the roof of an industrial building in the heart of London's Hoxton - exemplifies this growing trend in architecture. The building is a contemporary interpretation of the traditional weavers' lofts found in the area, and the design plays with ideas of light and transparency by using translucent walls and sliding screens that can close for privacy while still allowing light to filter through.
Spacebox's modular apartment buildings, pictured above, come pre-assembled, so all you need is a crane (and some help from your neighbours, perhaps) to lift it on to your building of choice within minutes.
Werner Aisslinger, meanwhile, has developed the Loft Cube, a temporary, minimalist domicile to suit people who stay in cities for short periods of time, but want the kind of sanctuary never really found in big, international hotel chains. The 40 square metres of space can be divided into rooms to your own specification in order to create the ultimate modernist rooftop dream. Tom Greatrex
43. The Freecycle Network
Like a sort of hippy eBay, www.freecycle.org takes that auction house's notion that one man's trash is another man's treasure, and simply removes the auction bit from the equation. TFN (The Freecycle Network) is a global set of city and town-specific online noticeboards, each one offering unwanted items for free. No money ever changes hands, and it's up to the giver to decide who receives the gift and set a time for the "winner" to collect their booty. There's only one rule: that everything posted must be free, legal and appropriate for all ages. A further feelgood factor comes from an option to give unwanted stuff to a non-profit organisation - hence the "free cycle of giving". TFN was started in May 2003 in Arizona to promote waste reduction and reduce landfills. Today, it comprises over 2.5million members in 3,700 groups all over the world - there are 326 groups in the UK alone. Long may it run. JD
44. Friendly security
The trouble with most home security systems is they are downright ugly, but Matthias Megyeri is trying to change that. When he came to Britain from his native Germany, he was struck by the seeming contradiction between tower blocks fortified with alarms, surveillance cameras and security railings, but also decorated with kitsch plastic garden ornaments and lace curtains. Megyeri decided to embody this contradiction within a collection of security products, which would be functional while also embracing their owners' taste for the cute. His Sweet Dreams Security range features surveillance cameras topped with cartoon character hoods; the barbs in razor wire are shaped like butterfly wings; iron railings are topped by beaming cartoon faces. His take on traditional net curtains will especially appeal to members of Neighbourhood Watch schemes everywhere. Soft and welcoming on the inside, they are woven to look like a metal security shutter and thus appear cold and harsh-looking from the outside - the ideal design to keep the burglars at bay, without making you feel imprisoned in your own home. TG
For more info, go to www.sweetdreamssecurity.com
45. Flatpack coffins
EveryBody coffins are made from flat, modular pieces, that are easy to transport and fit together without the need for glue or nails. They were invented to offer a humane and uniform method of dealing with bodies in disaster situations, but the Dutch company that makes them has been surprised by the amount of orders it receives from people looking for cheaper, more environmentally friendly alternatives to traditional mahogany coffins. The EveryBody also lends itself to creativity as the boxes can be easily decorated and painted. JDee
46. Hi-tech interiors
With the arrival of ever-more-sophisticated projection systems and display screens, our homes are set to become places that respond to our mood and sense of creativity. According to boffins at Anterior:Insight, the clash between art and technology is fast moving from desktops and on to the walls of living rooms, bathrooms and bedrooms. For example, it will allow people to have themed rooms that can be changed to reflect a chosen mood (a romantic meal for two, perhaps) or time of day. It will also move beyond the home and into public spaces for socialising such as Starbucks coffee shops, style bars or arts venues.
One company, loop.pH has developed DigitalDawn, a reactive window blind with a surface that is in constant flux, growing in luminosity in response to its surroundings. It digitally emulates the process of photosynthesis using printed electroluminescent technology. The darker a space becomes, the brighter the blind will glow - thus maintaining a balance in luminosity. A natural, botanical environment appears to grow and evolve on the window lamp.
Meanwhile, digital artist Daniel Brown's "Software As Furniture" uses projectors and plasma screens to investigate the use of PC technology as wallpaper. His Flowers series "On Growth and Form" - regenerative floral imagery merging maths and design, pictured right - will set the benchmark for how the walls of our homes could be forever changing as technology allows all surfaces to have a visual function. TG
47. Guilty Pleasures
It started, as these things often do, by accident. Fed up with playing cutting-edge records on his BBC Radio London show, DJ Sean Rowley gave " Oh Lori" - a 1977 hit by the Alessi Brothers - a spin. The response was overwhelming and, soon, listeners were requesting their own "guilty pleasures" - records that had been unfairly dubbed "uncool". Within two years, there were compilation CDs, club nights in New York, Singapore and Sydney and London.
Rowley explains the thinking behind the Guilty Pleasures phenomenon thus: "You've gone to someone's house and you're flicking through their record collection. There are all the usual suspects: The Clash, Marvin Gaye, Revolver... And then you see a Barbra Streisand album, you put it on and you're dumb-founded as to how great that record is."
The effect on current pop tastes has been profound: Scissor Sisters, the Darkness and The Feeling are all clearly familiar with the records in Rowley's collection. As Huey Lewis & the News predicted in their 1986 hit, suddenly, it really is hip to be square. Time to go and fetch all those old 10cc and ELO records from the attic... SR
48. Tipping points
The term "tipping point" was coined by New York writer Malcolm Gladwell to define the moment when "social epidemics" - trends such as the crime rate dropping in New York in the 1990s or the vogue for wearing trainers without laces - reach critical mass. "It's the moment on the graph when the line shoots straight upwards," explains Gladwell. The term is borrowed from epidemiology, because, says Gladwell, "I'm convinced behaviours, ideas and products move through a population like a disease does, and even the smallest change - the original Patient Zero - can get them started." In other words, it only takes one person (a " connector") to show off his new laceless trainer look to an influential contact (a "maven") whose adoption of the look is co-opted by opinion-formers such as model or pop stars ("salesmen"), only to replace it with another when the original is too commonplace. According to Gladwell, you can detect the tipping point in everything from business to advertising to social policy, and, given the tools, even start "positive " epidemics of your own. SH
The launch of Hotmail in 1995 transformed the world of email by providing free access for all. Sold to computing giants Microsoft in 1997, it is now the largest web-based email service in the world, with 200 million active users.
50. Millau Viaduct
Lord Foster's Millennium Bridge may have wobbled, but his Millau Viaduct across the Tarn gorge in France has quantum-jumped civil architecture and engineering into a new paradigm of scale and infrastructural ambition. The bridge connects two plateaux and spans 2.46km. Each motorway section is 342m, and its central "masts" reach up 245m. The way the columns are tapered above road level, and split below it, has minimised its sense of mass.
In design terms, the Millau Bridge is minimal in an age where total licence is given in terms of form and drama. While Santiago Calatrava's bridges took Modernism into neo-baroque forms and the forthcoming bridge by Cecil Balmond at Coimbra, Portugal, is so refined its mid-section seems to vanish, Foster's can-do grandiosity is almost Victorian in its belief in sheer gigantism. JM
Join our new commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies