Home Office failed to act on repeated warning signs of Windrush failings, major report finds

Full scale of the scandal is yet to be established, National Audit Office says

Tom Embury-Dennis
Wednesday 05 December 2018 01:40 GMT
Home Office contributed to risk of wrongful detentions and removals, report says
Home Office contributed to risk of wrongful detentions and removals, report says (Getty)

The government failed to act on repeated warning signs of Windrush failings and the full scale of the scandal is yet to be established, a major report has found.

Whitehall’s spending watchdog said the Home Office had been aware of “credible information” about potential issues as long as four years ago.

The National Audit Office (NAO) concluded some departmental processes contributed to a risk of wrongful detentions and removals.

Official impact assessments by the Home Office about “hostile environment“ measures did not give sufficient consideration to the risk of unfair consequences, it added.

“The treatment of people who had a legitimate right to remain in the UK raises grave questions about how the Home Office discharged its duty of care towards people who were made vulnerable because of lack of documentation,” Sir Amyas Morse, head of the NAO, said.

“It failed to protect their rights to live, work and access services in the UK, and many have suffered distress and material loss as a result. This was both predictable and forewarned.

“The department is taking steps to put things right for the Caribbean community but it has shown a surprising lack of urgency to identify other groups that may have been affected.”

Ministers faced a furious backlash over the treatment of the Windrush generation – named after a ship that brought migrants to Britain from the Caribbean in 1948.

Amber Rudd 'hopes there will be changes' following report into Windrush row

Commonwealth citizens who arrived before 1973 were automatically granted indefinite leave to remain but many were not issued with any documents confirming their status.

A public outcry erupted earlier this year after it emerged long-term UK residents were denied access to services, held in detention or removed despite living legally in the country for decades.

The scandal prompted criticism of “hostile environment” measures introduced to tackle illegal immigration, now referred to by the government under the heading “compliant environment”.

The NAO said the Home Office “did not act on credible information about issues that may have contributed to the Windrush situation”.

It cited a 2014 report by the Legal Action Group, which flagged up the potential adverse impact of immigration policy on certain groups, including Jamaicans who arrived pre-1973.

In addition, Caribbean ministers raised Windrush cases with the government at a forum in April 2016, while inspection reports highlighted issues including the possibility people were being sanctioned because of incorrect data.

The NAO said: “It is our view that there were warning signs from enough different sources, over a long enough period, to collectively indicate a potential problem that merited further investigation.”

A 2016 recommendation to “cleanse” a database of individuals wrongly flagged as being in the UK illegally was ignored, the watchdog added.

It found the Home Office has not yet established the full extent of the problems affecting people of the Windrush generation.

An official review of 11,800 cases of Caribbean Commonwealth individuals identified 164 people who were removed or detained and might have been resident in the UK before 1973.

Support free-thinking journalism and attend Independent events

The department has apologised to 18 people in whose cases it considers it is most likely to have acted wrongfully.

The NAO said there are no plans to review around 160,000 files relating to non-Caribbean Commonwealth nationals on the basis this would be “disproportionate”.

“In the circumstances, we find this surprising,” the report said.

It also revealed at least 25 people may have been incorrectly sanctioned under hostile environment policies, such has having a driving licence revoked.

The Home Office has had targets for removing illegal immigrants since 2004, the report noted, but it said there is insufficient information to conclude on whether this contributed to Windrush.

Meg Hillier, chairwoman of the commons public accounts committee, said the impact on those unfairly treated has been “immense”, adding: “It is shocking that the Home Office is not proactively reviewing other Commonwealth nationals’ cases.”

Home secretary Sajid Javid has issued a profound apology to the Windrush generation and is “absolutely determined to right the wrongs of the past”, the Home Office said.

A spokesman for the department said: “As the NAO’s report acknowledges, our taskforce has taken thousands of phone calls and helped over 2,400 people of any nationality prove their status in the UK.

“The majority of those helped by the taskforce are of Caribbean origin, but we have always been clear that it accepts applications under the Windrush scheme from people of any nationality who arrived in the UK before 31 December 1988 and are settled here.

“We have worked hard to raise awareness of the support on offer across a wide range of communities.”

An independent “lessons learned” review has been set up and details of a compensation scheme for those affected will be outlined in the new year, the spokesman added.

Additional reporting by PA

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in