Trans people could 'face rape charges' if they don’t declare sexual history, warns trans activist
'By forcing transgender people to disclose their history to prospective partners the law is not only infringing their human rights it’s also reinforcing the bigoted idea that trans people are in some way abhorrent'
Non-disclosure of gender history can be seen as a breach of the Sexual Offences act, says Sophie Cook
(
Facebook
)
A transgender activist has highlighted the issue of gender identity in legal sexual consent, warning that trans people in the UK may face rape charges and potentially jail if they fail to disclose their gender history to their sexual partners.
Sophie Cook, a LGBT speaker, trans activist and the first transgender newscaster to appear on European terrestrial TV, says that under UK law, deceiving someone about the nature of a sex act makes them incapable of informed consent.
This means penetrative sex may amount to rape if the partner claimed they were unaware of a transgender person’s history.
Under Section 2 of the Sexual Offences Act 2003 it is an offence if a defendant intentionally penetrates the vagina or anus of a person, where the other person does not consent and where the defendant does not reasonably believe the other person consents.
Section 74 of the act gives the definition of consent: “A person consents for the purposes of this Act if he agrees by choice and has the freedom and capacity to make that choice.”
People who made 2015 a landmark year for LGBT rights
Show all 10
People who made 2015 a landmark year for LGBT rights
1/10
Caitlyn Jenner
2/10
Miley Cyrus
Getty
3/10
Kristen Stewart
4/10
Cara Delevingne
5/10
Keegan Hirst
6/10
Ruby Rose
7/10
St Vincent (who's in a relationship with Cara Delevingne)
8/10
Annie Lennox
9/10
Ellen Page
10/10
Justice Anthony Kennedy
1/10
Caitlyn Jenner
2/10
Miley Cyrus
Getty
3/10
Kristen Stewart
4/10
Cara Delevingne
5/10
Keegan Hirst
6/10
Ruby Rose
7/10
St Vincent (who's in a relationship with Cara Delevingne)
8/10
Annie Lennox
9/10
Ellen Page
10/10
Justice Anthony Kennedy
Non-disclosure of gender history can thus be seen as deception and a breach of the Sexual Offences act, challenging the “freedom and capacity” of a partner to consent to sexual activity.
Ms Cook says: “Transgender people are entitled to a private life and the personal choice as to how much of their history they disclose, to the extent that our personal details are locked by HM Revenue & Customs.
“By forcing transgender people to disclose their history to prospective partners the law is not only infringing their human rights it’s also reinforcing the bigoted idea that trans people are in some way abhorrent and something that people need to be warned about.”
The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) says it will not automatically prosecute trans people for having sex by deception and each case is treated separately. CPS also has guidelines surrounding transgender equality.
This has been disputed by LGBT activists who argue ambiguity in the system leaves it open to abuse and personal prejudice.
Pervious cases in the public eye have highlighted these ambiguities.
In November 2015, lawyers for Gayle Newland, the young woman jailed for eight years for duping a female lover into thinking she was a man to embark on a sexual relationship, lodged an appeal against her sentence.
LGBT rights across the globe
Show all 8
LGBT rights across the globe
1/8 Russia
Russia’s antipathy towards homosexuality has been well established following the efforts of human rights campaigners. However, while it is legal to be homosexual, LGBT couples are offered no protections from discrimination. They are also actively discriminated against by a 2013 law criminalising LGBT “propaganda” allowing the arrest of numerous Russian LGBT activists.
(Picture: Riot police hold an LGBT activist during a Moscow rall.)
AFP/Getty
2/8 Mauritania
Men who are found having sex with other men face stoning, while lesbians can be imprisoned, under Sharia law. However, the state has not reportedly executed anyone for this ‘crime’ since 1987.
(Picture: Chinguetti Mosque, Mauritania.)
ALAMY
3/8 Sudan
Both male and female same-sex sexual activity is illegal under Sudanese law. Men can be executed on their third offence, women on their fourth.
(Picture: The courthouse in the Haj Yousef district in the Sudanese capital Khartoum.)
Getty Images
4/8 Saudi Arabia
Homosexuality and transgender is illegal and punishable by the death penalty, imprisonment, corporal punishment, whipping and chemical castration.
(Picture: The emblem of Saudi Arabia above the embassy in London.)
Bruno Vincent/Getty Images
5/8 Yemen
The official position within the country is that there are no gays. LGBT inviduals, if discovered by the government, are likely to face intense pressure. Punishments range from flogging to the death penalty.
(Picture: Yemen's southern port of Aden.)
Getty
6/8 Nigeria
Both male and female same-sex sexual activity is illegal and in some northern states punishable with death by stoning. This is not a policy enacted across the entire country, although there is a prevalent anti-LGBT agenda pushed by the government. In 2007 a Pew survey established that 97 per cent of the population felt that homosexuality should not be accepted. It is publishable by 14 years in prison.
(Picture: The northern Nigerian town of Damasak.)
Reuters
7/8 Somalia
Homosexuality was established as a crime in 1888 and under new Somali Penal Code established in 1973 homosexual sex can be punishable by three years in prison.
(Picture: Families use a boat to cross a flooded Shebelle River, in Jowhar.)
Reuters
8/8 Iraq
Although same-sex relationships have been decriminalised, much of the population still suffer from intense discrimination. Additionally, in some of the country over-run by the extremist organisation Isis, LGBT individuals can face death by stoning.
(Picture: Purported Isis fighters in Iraq.)
Getty Images
1/8 Russia
Russia’s antipathy towards homosexuality has been well established following the efforts of human rights campaigners. However, while it is legal to be homosexual, LGBT couples are offered no protections from discrimination. They are also actively discriminated against by a 2013 law criminalising LGBT “propaganda” allowing the arrest of numerous Russian LGBT activists.
(Picture: Riot police hold an LGBT activist during a Moscow rall.)
AFP/Getty
2/8 Mauritania
Men who are found having sex with other men face stoning, while lesbians can be imprisoned, under Sharia law. However, the state has not reportedly executed anyone for this ‘crime’ since 1987.
(Picture: Chinguetti Mosque, Mauritania.)
ALAMY
3/8 Sudan
Both male and female same-sex sexual activity is illegal under Sudanese law. Men can be executed on their third offence, women on their fourth.
(Picture: The courthouse in the Haj Yousef district in the Sudanese capital Khartoum.)
Getty Images
4/8 Saudi Arabia
Homosexuality and transgender is illegal and punishable by the death penalty, imprisonment, corporal punishment, whipping and chemical castration.
(Picture: The emblem of Saudi Arabia above the embassy in London.)
Bruno Vincent/Getty Images
5/8 Yemen
The official position within the country is that there are no gays. LGBT inviduals, if discovered by the government, are likely to face intense pressure. Punishments range from flogging to the death penalty.
(Picture: Yemen's southern port of Aden.)
Getty
6/8 Nigeria
Both male and female same-sex sexual activity is illegal and in some northern states punishable with death by stoning. This is not a policy enacted across the entire country, although there is a prevalent anti-LGBT agenda pushed by the government. In 2007 a Pew survey established that 97 per cent of the population felt that homosexuality should not be accepted. It is publishable by 14 years in prison.
(Picture: The northern Nigerian town of Damasak.)
Reuters
7/8 Somalia
Homosexuality was established as a crime in 1888 and under new Somali Penal Code established in 1973 homosexual sex can be punishable by three years in prison.
(Picture: Families use a boat to cross a flooded Shebelle River, in Jowhar.)
Reuters
8/8 Iraq
Although same-sex relationships have been decriminalised, much of the population still suffer from intense discrimination. Additionally, in some of the country over-run by the extremist organisation Isis, LGBT individuals can face death by stoning.
(Picture: Purported Isis fighters in Iraq.)
Getty Images
Legal experts warned at the time that the severity of the jail term created a “dangerous precedent” for transgendered people, pointing out that Newland’s sexual assault jail term was tougher than some given to people convicted of manslaughter or child rape.
Speaking in a recent Transjustice conference in London aimed at creating strategies for addressing urgent issues faced by trans and gender non-conforming people in the criminal justice system, Ms Cook reinforced the issue saying: “At what point should the disclosure be made? As you’re snuggling up in bed? And run the risk of a transphobic assault and potentially worse… Or maybe trans people could be made to wear a handy badge on their clothing identifying their history.
“If trans people have to disclose this why shouldn’t everyone?
“Surely a racist could complain to a judge that he felt used after realising that the woman he slept with had previously had a black partner, or the homophobe object when discovering that his girlfriend had ‘experimented’ with other women at Uni.”
Subscribe to Independent Minds to debate the big issues
Want to discuss real-world problems, be involved in the most engaging discussions and hear from the journalists? Try Independent Minds free for 14 days.
Independent Minds Comments can be posted by members of our membership scheme, Independent Minds.
It allows our most engaged readers to debate the big issues, share their own experiences, discuss
real-world solutions, and more. Our journalists will try to respond by joining the threads when
they can to create a true meeting of independent minds. The most insightful comments on all subjects
will be published daily in dedicated articles. You can also choose to be emailed when someone replies
to your comment.
The existing Open Comments threads will continue to exist for those who do not subscribe to
Independent Minds. Due to the sheer scale of this comment community, we are not able to give each post
the same level of attention, but we have preserved this area in the interests of open debate. Please
continue to respect all commenters and create constructive debates.
Click here to view instructions on how to disable your ad blocker, and help us to keep providing you with free-thinking journalism - for free.
Thank you for your support.
How to disable your ad blocker for independent.co.uk
Adblock / Adblock Plus
Click the Adblock/Adblock Plus icon, which is to the right of your address bar.
On Adblock click "Don't run on pages on this domain".
On Adblock Plus click "Enabled on this site" to disable ad blocking for the current website you are on. If you are in Firefox click "disable on independent.co.uk".
Firefox Tracking Protection
If you are Private Browsing in Firefox, "Tracking Protection" may cause the adblock notice to show. It can be temporarily disabled by clicking the "shield" icon in the address bar.
Ghostery
Click the Ghostery icon.
In versions before 6.0 click "whitelist site".
In version 6.0 click "trust site" or add independent.co.uk to your Trusted Site list.
In versions before 6.0 you will see the message "Site is whitelisted".
Click "reload the page to see your changes".
uBlock
Click the uBlock icon.
Then click the big power button to whitelist the current web site, and its state will be remembered next time you visit the web site.
Comments
Share your thoughts and debate the big issues
Please be respectful when making a comment and adhere to our Community Guidelines.
You can find our Community Guidelines in full here.
Please be respectful when making a comment and adhere to our Community Guidelines.
Community Guidelines
You can find our Community Guidelines in full here.