Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

Women forced out of jobs by rising cost of childcare

A combination of cuts to public sector jobs and to family credits means many mothers can not afford to go out to work. Jane Merrick reports

Sunday 07 August 2011 00:00 BST
Jenni Dyer, 37, from Upminster, Essex, works for the Institute of Physics, and 80 per cent of her income goes on childcare for her daughter
Jenni Dyer, 37, from Upminster, Essex, works for the Institute of Physics, and 80 per cent of her income goes on childcare for her daughter

Many women are being priced out of the jobs market because of the soaring cost of childcare, as new figures show female unemployment in Britain exceeding one million, a report warns today.

The combination of cuts to benefits for families and the impact public sector job losses are having on women's employment is causing many mothers to choose to look after their children rather than seek paid work, the centre-left think tank IPPR suggests. Its analysis of official statistics shows that, while unemployment overall has fallen in the past year, among women it has risen by 42,000.

The findings, which suggest that the UK is about to see a new generation of stay-at-home mothers, come at a time when ministers are trying to encourage more people to work, in an attempt to slash the welfare bill. While many mothers who lose their jobs have little choice about being unemployed, there is growing evidence that some simply decide that it is more cost-effective to stay at home than tp pay for childcare, the report says.

"Women are increasingly joining the ranks of the long-term unemployed, and the prospects for female employment are likely to remain gloomy for some time to come," said Dalia Ben-Galim, associate director of the IPPR. "Cuts to childcare tax credits mean that for some women, work no longer pays and they are better off staying at home."

Nick Clegg will tomorrow attempt to win back female support for the coalition with a speech setting out what the Government is doing about childcare and raising the income tax threshold. At the same time, the Secretary of State for Work and Pensions, Iain Duncan Smith, is planning to make it more cost-effective for women to work part-time than to stay at home.

Some 268,000 women have been unemployed for more than a year, Office for National Statistics figures show. The UK's jobless total is 2.45 million, 20,000 fewer than last year. But the number of women out of work has risen to 1,026,000. More than 40 per cent of redundancies in the last quarter were among women, up from just over 30 per cent. The IPPR analysis shows that 143,000 job losses in the public sector, where more women than men are employed, are disproportionately affecting women. By contrast, 520,000 new jobs were created in the private sector last year.

According to the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, the UK has some of the most expensive childcare in the world. The average cost is £97 a week for 25 hours, rising to an average of £115 a week in London and the South-east.

Before April this year, families with household incomes below £30,000 could reclaim 80 per cent of the cost of childcare, up to a maximum of £175 per week for one child and £300 for two or more. As ministers attempt to cut welfare costs, families can now reclaim only 70 per cent, affecting nearly half a million families. The Resolution Foundation think tank, which campaigns for the so-called "squeezed middle", says that the change has led to the average family losing £436 a year, with some losing as much as £1,300.

The Government is planning to scrap existing benefits and replace them with a Universal Credit, which is expected to leave many families worse off.

Anand Shukla, the chief executive of Daycare Trust, said: "Parents in Britain contribute more towards childcare than any other OECD country, which results in many women being priced out of the job market, and having to give up careers they are committed to, simply because it costs them money to work. This situation will only get worse with the reduction in the amount of childcare costs covered through working tax credits in April this year, which effectively added an extra £546 to the annual childcare bill for many families."

Labour's deputy leader, Harriet Harman, said: "Women's employment is key to the household budget. It is important in lone-parent households as a role for their children to see the world of work, and it is important to the economy.

"The cost of childcare going up, while at the same time their pay does not go up, becomes economically unviable. The price that will be paid is paid by the wider economy, but also by families."

Case Studies

Jenni Dyer, Part-time equality and diversity manager

Jenni Dyer, 37, from Upminster, Essex, works for the Institute of Physics, and 80 per cent of her income goes on childcare for her daughter (four), and son (two), who go to nursery three days a week from 7.30am to 6.30pm. She and her husband Peter, a project manager for a construction company, are expecting their third child next month, when Mrs Dyer is considering giving up work, because the costs are so high - nearly £1,000 a month in nursery fees, even after the Government's 15 free hours a week. "I have just enough left over to justify me working, but not a lot. When my daughter starts school costs will remain high, because there is after-school club to pay for. My job is about encouraging more women into science, and my employer has been very supportive. It is tragic that this report finds women are being priced out of work – so many skills are being lost."

Rey, Teacher

Rey, 32, is a qualified secondary school RE teacher, married to Andrew, 33, operation manager in the ambulance service. They have a seven-year-old daughter and twin boys, aged two-and-a-half. She gave up work when her twins were 18 months old, because the cost of childcare would have left her family worse off. "It was a huge decision for me because I loved my job," she says. "It is lovely being at home with my children, but things are quite difficult. My husband has to do overtime to make up the money that I have lost. We lost child tax credit because he earns around £35,000.

"I get to go to all of my daughter's sports days, and being at home with the boys is great, but there needs to be a bit of a balance. I would like to work part-time, but we cannot afford for me to do that."

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in