50,000 disabled people 'have adapted vehicles removed after benefits assessment'

Muscular Dystrophy UK says 900 cars are being taken away every week, as more people are rejected for PIP

Jon Vale
Wednesday 12 April 2017 00:14
More than 3,000 have since rejoined the PIP scheme after the decision to refuse them PIP was overturned
More than 3,000 have since rejoined the PIP scheme after the decision to refuse them PIP was overturned

More than 50,000 disabled people have had specially adapted cars and other vehicles taken away as they move over to a controversial new disability benefit, according to the charity that runs the scheme.

MPs and campaigners are now demanding changes to the Motability programme, so vehicles are not taken away before claimants have had a chance to appeal against their decision.

The latest figures from the Motability charity show 51,000 people have been taken off the scheme after a reassessment for personal independence payments (PIP) since it launched in 2013 – 45 per cent of all cases.

Of these, more than 3,000 have since rejoined after the decision to refuse them PIP was overturned.

The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) says a fraction of PIP decisions are overturned, while those taken off the Motability scheme are eligible for £2,000 of support.

But charity Muscular Dystrophy UK said 900 cars are now being taken away every week, as more people are rejected for PIP.

Conservative MP Peter Bone said: “You need it for mobility purposes and maybe you use it for work, but because you lose your PIP award you lose the car at the same time.

“You appeal against the PIP award and ultimately the tribunal awards you back the PIP, but you've already lost the car and maybe your job because of it.”

Mr Bone said the Government should let people keep their Motability cars until they have gone through the appeal process.

“The Government could quite easily put that right and it wouldn't cost a significant amount of money at all,” he added.

Labour former work and pensions minister Angela Eagle said: “What's happening in the worst cases is from being mobile and being able to get out and about in a car, that's been removed and this may mean people have had their ability to live their life at taken away, and some of them are left housebound.”

The Motability scheme entitles disabled people to lease a new car, scooter or powered wheelchair using part of their benefit.

They are specially adapted for the claimant's individual needs.

Thousands of people are being denied Motability, though, as they transfer over from disability living allowance (DLA) to PIP.

The number of people eligible for Motability funding has halved during the reassessment process since PIP launched in 2013, according to Muscular Dystrophy UK.

It said 126,300 of the 254,200 people who were eligible for Motability funding under DLA and had been reassessed for PIP are now no longer eligible.

DWP figures show that since PIP launched, more than 160,000 people have had their original rejection overturned at mandatory reconsideration or at appeal.

Some 65 per cent of decisions are now overturned at tribunal in the claimant's favour, according to the latest Ministry of Justice statistics.

Nic Bungay, director of campaigns, care and information at Muscular Dystrophy UK, said: “Each of the 51,000 vehicles being taken away is a story about a disabled person's independence being compromised.

“This is having a devastating effect on quality of life.

“The fact that two-thirds of people who contest their PIP award win their case shows that the system isn't working and is in urgent need of reform.”

Muscular Dystrophy UK is now calling on the DWP to reverse a fiercely contested change in the rules.

To qualify for the higher level of the mobility component of PIP, which is needed to get a Motability vehicle, a person must be unable to walk unaided for 20 metres, compared with the previous distance of 50 metres under DLA.

There are now 70,000 more people on the Motability scheme compared with 2010.

Ministers say the Motability charity provides a support package to those who no longer qualify for the scheme, including a £2,000 lump sum.

Plus, if an appeal is successful, PIP arrears are paid in full to the claimant and they can rejoin the Motability scheme immediately if they repay their transitional support money, or else within six months of the date they left the scheme.

A DWP spokeswoman said: “The reality is that, since PIP was introduced in 2013, more than two million decisions have been made; of these just 7% have been appealed and 3% have been overturned.

“But we constantly review our processes, to make sure they are working in the best way possible.

“Most people leaving the Motability scheme are eligible for a one-off payment of £2,000 to meet their needs.”

Motability has already provided more than £50m in support through this transitional package.

MS sufferer's car withdrawn after 'hand tickle' assessment

Sam Adams had her vehicle withdrawn in June after being reassessed for PIP nine months early 

A mother with multiple sclerosis (MS) who was left without her Motability car for nearly a year claims it was taken away based on nothing more than her PIP assessor tickling her hand with a feather.

Sam Adams had her vehicle withdrawn in June after being reassessed for PIP nine months early.

The 41-year-old's MS is so severe that she has collapsed after losing all the power in her legs. However, Ms Adams, from Chesterfield, was still denied the higher rate of the mobility component of PIP after being reassessed last year.

She said: “She'd come to the conclusion I could walk so many metres, but I couldn't walk under so many metres.

“How she came to that conclusion when she's not seen me walk, she's not seen me walk up and down stairs - all she did was tickle my hand with a feather.

“What conclusions she was coming to from tickling my hand with a feather, I'll never know.”

Ms Adams admits she tries to put a brave face on her condition, playing down its impact on her day-to-day life.

But she said at her most recent assessment in March 2016 the assessor was just “typing on her iPad”.

In other assessments Ms Adams said she had been asked to walk up stairs and physically show how mobile she was.

Ms Adams' original PIP award at the higher rate had been due to run out in December, having been awarded in 2014.

She has now overturned this decision through the tribunal process and been awarded the higher rate of mobility, meaning she qualifies for a Motability vehicle.

Ms Adams expects to have a car leased through the scheme by the end of April.

In the meantime, she has been using a car her brother bought to take her children to school, as well as running errands with her mother, who is in her 80s.

Ms Adams said: “If my brother hadn't bought me one I'd have been stuffed, because I can't get anywhere without a car.

“Without a car I honestly could have got depression, not going out - it would drive me up the wall.

“It wouldn't have been very nice, put it that way.”


Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

View comments