Brexit: 24 hours to save EU summit as negotiators scramble to break deadlock

Gibraltar and fishing rights could yet sink the deal and cancel summit

Jon Stone
Wednesday 21 November 2018 17:22
Theresa May on what she achieved with president Junker: 'We have made further progress and as a result, we have given sufficient direction to our negotiators'

Negotiators have just 24 hours left to resolve outstanding issues with the Brexit deal if a summit on Sunday is to go ahead, Brussels has warned.

A senior EU official said on Wednesday that time was running out to produce a final text in time for the planned summit, with last-minute concerns around fishing rights and Gibraltar threatening to sink the plan.

Although Britain and the European Commission struck a draft withdrawal agreement and future relationship plan last week, a number of member states have raised significant concerns with the proposals and declined to sign off.

Angela Merkel has now also threatened to pull out of the summit if no agreement is ready in time for the meeting, according to diplomats in Brussels. The ultimatum is being interpreted as a bid to avoid late-night sessions of face-to-face negotiations between leaders.

The commission is keen that the Sunday summit be little more than a glorified rubber-stamp, with the deal having been signed off beforehand – but the stipulation appears to be risking the entire meeting.

Commission vice president Valdis Dombrovskis told reporters in Brussels that a final agreement would have to be done before a key meeting of national officials on Friday at the latest, if it was to be ready for the Sunday summit.

“We will need to have agreed beforehand on the political declaration on the future relationship and we are not there yet,” he said, addressing the issue of the summit.

“Sherpas are due to meet on Friday. Of course they will need to see a final text before then and the commission stands ready to consider the text and take any action at any time.”

Asked if Sunday’s special EU summit to sign off the Brexit deal could be cancelled because of the deadlock, the prime minister’s spokesman said: “A summit has been called, an agenda has been published and we look forward to attending.”

Theresa May travelled to Brussels on Wednesday evening to meet with commission president Jean-Claude Juncker in the hope of resolving the impasse. She told reporters after the meeting that she would return on Saturday for another meeting with Mr Juncker, and that there ”are some further issues that need resolution” that she hoped could be resolved.

“We have had a very good meeting this evening. We have made further progress and as a result, we have given sufficient direction to our negotiators,” the PM said. ”I hope for them to be able to resolve the remaining issues and that work will start immediately.”

A commission spokesperson said: “Very good progress was made in the meeting between President Juncker and Prime Minister Theresa May. Work is continuing.”

We will need to have agreed beforehand on the political declaration on the future relationship and we are not there yet

Valdis Dombrovskis, EU commission vice president

The prime minister is under pressure at home from MPs in her own party who see the deal as too tough on Britain, but in Brussels she is also facing opposition from member states who feel the EU has given away too much already. A failure to gain more concessions from Europe is expected to see her cabinet again rocked by yet more resignations.

Spain in particular has raised concerns about Gibraltar’s treatment under the draft plan - prime minister Pedro Sanchez insisted he would vote against the draft deal unless he wins assurances over the disputed peninsula of Gibraltar.

On Wednesday night, Ms May spoke to Mr Sanchez and "there had been good engagement between the UK, the Government of Spain and the Government of Gibraltar," May's office said, adding that the UK and Gibraltar "looked forward to these discussions continuing."

Meanwhile other member states such as France, Denmark, Spain, Portugal and the Netherlands are concerned that the commission did not secure access for their fishing fleets to British waters.

The fishing section of the agreement commits the EU and UK to negotiating a fishing agreement by July 2020, during the transition period. But the group of discontent member states, led by France, is concerned that the EU has given Britain access to the benefits of the customs union through the Northern Ireland backstop without securing access for its fleets first.

The situation is particularly sensitive because Brexiteers also want to reopen the deal, but have been told they cannot do so. Reopening it to make it harsher on Britain would probably enrage them further – and add to the 70-plus Tory MPs who have now suggested they cannot vote for the plan.

Diplomats familiar with the situation suggested the changes could be accommodated by so-called “side-declarations” that would avoid reopening talks on the agreement but give clear stipulations about how the EU expected the legal text to be interpreted.

Aside from the fishing issue, Spain is demanding concessions for Gibraltar, with Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez warning: “If there are no changes regarding Gibraltar, Spain will vote no to the agreement on Brexit.”

Spanish foreign minister Josep Borrell: Spain will not back Brexit deal over issue of Gibraltar

The country takes issue with a clause added to the withdrawal agreement at the last minute – article 184. The article says the EU and the UK will seek to “negotiate rapidly the agreements governing their future relationship” before the end of the transition.

But Spain wants an addition to the text specifying that Gibraltar will not be covered by that agreement, and that it is for Spain and Britain to negotiate the future of the territory bilaterally.

Neither side appears willing to give ground on the issue, with Theresa May telling MPs on Wednesday: “Gibraltar is covered by our exit negotiations … We are seeking a deal that works for the whole UK family and that deal must work for Gibraltar too.”

The withdrawal agreement must be approved by a qualified majority vote of the European Council, meaning Spain alone cannot sink the deal without the support of other countries – although it could cause serious trouble down the line and veto a future trade agreement if the issue is not resolved now.

If Spain and the fishing states joined forces, they would have the numbers to block the agreement.

Spain has long resented Britain’s claims on Gibraltar, a British overseas territory that is home to around 30,000 people, and has previously threatened to use Brexit to wrest concessions on the issue.

The upsurge in interest in the Gibraltar issue could be down to the fact that the Spanish region of Andalusia has local elections scheduled for 2 December – just a week after the final Brexit summit.

Andalusia borders Gibraltar, and includes the county of Camp de Gibraltar – or “countryside of Gibraltar”. Around 10,000 Spanish people cross the border into the British overseas territory every day to work, so their livelihoods are connected to Brexit talks.

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

View comments