NHS would collapse if it wasn't for immigrants, experts say

Experts want Theresa May to make all EU NHS workers British citizens

Hayden Smith
Thursday 25 August 2016 07:42
comments
A picture of EU nationals working in the NHS, which went viral in July
A picture of EU nationals working in the NHS, which went viral in July

A report warning that the NHS would collapse if it wasn't for EU nationals has urged the Government to make them a "particularly generous citizenship" offer.

The Institute for Public Policy Research says there are currently around 55,000 EU nationals working in the English NHS, and one in 10 of the UK's registered doctors is an EU national.

"Without them, the NHS would collapse," the report said, calling for them to be offered automatic citizenship as part of efforts to head off a "brain drain".

It said all EU nationals who work for, or as locums in, the NHS should be eligible to apply for British citizenship.

The study called for a waiver of fees, English language and "life in the UK" tests, and residency requirements for all staff employed in public healthcare.

IPPR research fellow Chris Murray said: "Britain can ill afford to lose the talents of many EU migrants who have made Britain their home.

"EU migrants who are already here should get indefinite leave to remain. In particular, EU NHS workers should get the automatic right to citizenship. If they left, it would be a crisis for the NHS."

It comes as another study showed nearly half of Britons are doubtful about the Government's chances of meeting its controversial immigration target even after leaving the EU.

There is scepticism concerning the prospects of bringing net migration below 100,000, a survey for British Future suggested.

Sunder Katwala, director of the think-tank, said: "Public trust in governments' competence to manage immigration - including meeting its own targets - is at rock bottom."

The first official immigration figures since the Brexit referendum will be published on Thursday.

In the previous set of figures, net migration - the difference between the numbers arriving to and leaving the UK - was an estimated 333,000 in the year to December.

Britain is expected to seek to introduce controls on free movement rules following the referendum outcome, but details of the system have yet to be outlined.

A poll of more than 2,000 adults for British Future examined attitudes regarding the aim to reduce net migration to five figures.

It found that 37% think the UK is likely to meet the target in the next five years, compared to 44% who consider the chances of reaching the aim unlikely.

The report also said:

  • 12% of people would like to see a reduction in the numbers of highly skilled workers migrating to Britain, while nearly four times as many (46%) would like to see more arriving.
  • People are "less positive" about low-skilled workers moving to the UK, with nearly four in 10 (38%) happy for numbers to stay the same or increase but six in 10 (62%) preferring a reduction.

Mr Katwala said: "The Brexit shake-up could be an opportunity to get immigration policy right - to restore trust in a system that works, and public consent for the immigration that we have."

Loading....

The status of more than three million EU migrants already in Britain came under scrutiny after the Brexit vote.

The Government has said it "fully expects" that the legal status of EU migrants living in this country will be "properly protected" when the UK leaves.

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

View comments