Labour rules out working with Theresa May on Brexit until she dumps 'no deal' rhetoric

Exclusive: Top shadow cabinet minister says Government must be ‘honest’ about devastating impact of no EU deal

Joe Watts
Political Editor
Tuesday 13 June 2017 21:34
Jeremy Corbyn's Labour will not work with the Tories on Brexit unless Theresa May ditches her 'no deal' rhetoric
Jeremy Corbyn's Labour will not work with the Tories on Brexit unless Theresa May ditches her 'no deal' rhetoric

There will be no cross-party British approach to Brexit while Theresa May refuses to be “honest” about the devastating impact of leaving the EU without a deal, The Independent has learnt.

Labour will not agree a Brexit consensus with the Conservatives until the Prime Minister ditches her “no deal is better than a bad deal” rhetoric and agrees bulletproof guarantees for workers’ rights and environmental protections.

In the wake of their poor election performance, top Conservatives have called for a cross-party approach to withdrawal negotiations. But in a sign of deepening Tory splits, Brexit-backing cabinet ministers warn it will not mean any softening of Ms May’s tough stance.

In an exclusive interview with The Independent, Labour’s Barry Gardiner branded media reports that talks between his party and the Tories are already taking place as “a joke”, adding “it’s just not happening”.

The shadow Business and shadow Trade Secretary said: “If the Government knows what it’s doing, and wants to put it before Parliament, then Parliament will take a view.

“The idea that they can coral opposition into rubber stamping whatever bad deal they come up with is a joke.”

Claiming that the Conservatives are not being straight with people about the potential impacts of leaving with no deal, he said: “There is not going to be a consensus, unless there is honesty.”

On Tuesday ex-foreign secretary Sir William Hague called for a cross-party commission to come to a Brexit consensus, while Scottish Tory leader Ruth Davidson has also said other parties should be involved.

While Mr Gardiner said Labour wants a successful Brexit, he went on: “When Governments are in a fix they say ‘let’s have a royal commission’ or ‘we need to consult other parties about this’.

“What that means is ‘shit, we don’t know what to do, so let’s rope others into this so they can share the blame’.

“The point is this – Labour wants Brexit to be a success. The Government, in terms of what it keeps on saying about ‘no deal’ and in terms of regulation and alignment, is heading for bad deal.”

Some Conservative MPs like George Freeman and Anna Soubry have called for a new approach to the customs union and single market.

But Brexit-backer Michael Gove – newly returned to the frontbench – has made clear there will be no softening of Ms May’s core Brexit demands, despite saying there should be a more “open” discussion.

Brexit Secretary David Davis has also refused to abandon the idea that Britain will walk away without a deal.

Mr Gardiner said that until a visible shift in the Conservative position on ‘no deal’ occurs, a cross-party consensus is untenable.

Barry Gardiner said: 'There is not going to be a consensus, unless there is honesty.'

He explained: “The thing that is really important to nail, is that there is somehow a trump card up Theresa May’s sleeve that she can sling on the table – that ‘if you don’t give us a deal, we will walk away on WTO rules’ – that is a nonsense.

“The Article 50 process says that if, after two years, you don’t have a deal, then you are ejected onto WTO rules. It’s not a trump card to play. It’s a cliff edge over which you are pushed.”

He argued the UK being forced to trade with the EU on WTO rules would be “devastating” for the economy, would mean queues at ports and tariffs on goods.

He pointed out that the outcome had also been roundly rejected by business groups like the CBI and FSB.

David Davis 'cannot quantify the outcome' of leaving EU with no deal

The shadow cabinet minister, one of the most prominent voices of Labour’s election campaign, went on: “The Government needs to be honest. What it is doing at the moment is swimming in a morass.…at the moment we need clarity and honesty from the Government.

“They are providing neither.”

Turning to another area where Ms May’s position negates a consensus, he said the Conservatives' de-regulatory agenda for leaving the EU is “really frightening”.

He highlighted plans for the Great Repeal Bill, which will see all current rights and protections currently enshrined in EU law, absorbed into British law on Brexit day.

The Government has promised no rights currently afforded workers, or protections for the environment, would be weakened in the process. But Mr Gardiner said ministers would need to enshrine them all in primary legislation.

He said: “When they talk about their Great Repeal Bill, absorbing these rights into UK law, there is also a lack of honesty in what they are saying.

“Because there are many thousands of regulations being brought across. The Government will not put them all in primary legislation, but that means these rights and protections are only safe as long as a secretary of state doesn’t change their mind on them.

May’s inflation rate was the highest since June 2013

“People cannot have confidence they will be as strong. Many current cabinet ministers have expressed for years a desire to get rid of many of these environmental and social protections.”

With the UK Government still in flux, inflation jumped unexpectedly to 2.9 per cent in May, its highest level in nearly four years, as the slump in the pound in the wake of last year’s Brexit vote continues to feed through into price increases.

City of London analysts had expected the annual rate of price increases to remain steady at 2.7 per cent.

Meanwhile, the EU’s Brexit negotiator Michel Barnier told Ms May to get on with appointing a negotiating team for talks that are supposed to take place next week.

Theresa May should admit result is a rejection of hard Brexit, says EU negotiator

The European Parliament’s chief negotiator Guy Verhofstadt claimed the election represented a refusal of hard Brexit.

He told the Tory party: “For years now already, your internal catfight, that started under Cameron, has taken the EU hostage and has been hampering your as our economy.

“It is blocking us from further reforming and modernizing the Union. Frankly, we have seen enough of it.”

Mr Verhofstadt added: “I am impatiently waiting for the negotiating position of the UK government that I hope will be more in line with the will and the interests of the British citizens.”

Register for free to continue reading

Registration is a free and easy way to support our truly independent journalism

By registering, you will also enjoy limited access to Premium articles, exclusive newsletters, commenting, and virtual events with our leading journalists

Already have an account? sign in

By clicking ‘Register’ you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to our Terms of use, Cookie policy and Privacy notice.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy policy and Terms of service apply.

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in