Budget spending cuts even bigger than expected and ‘simply unrealistic’, warns Institute for Fiscal Studies

‘Unprotected’ departments to receive staggering 8 per cent less than planned one year ago

Rob Merrick
Deputy Political Editor
Thursday 18 March 2021 13:50
comments

Spending cuts buried in the Budget are even bigger than was thought and “are simply unrealistic”, the Institute for Fiscal Studies is warning.

Departments funding services such as local councils, courts, the police, transport and benefits will receive 8 per cent less than planned one year ago, it has found.

“Most likely these figures are simply unrealistic, and borrowing or taxes will be higher than planned,” the IFS said, after studying the detail of Rishi Sunak’s plans in greater detail.

“If they are adhered to then many public services are due a second, sharp dose of austerity.”

The warning comes after the Chancellor was criticised for denying his plans represented a spending cut – claiming they were simply a “change in forecast”.

His own watchdog, the Office for Budget Responsibility, said the Budget included a £4bn spending cut, creating a total of £15bn to be slashed from departmental spending each year from 2022.

Read more:

Boris Johnson urged to ditch ‘draconian’ policing bill - follow live

Raab compares EU to dictatorship as row over access to vaccines escalates

‘Career graveyard’ of Brussels posting to hit pot-Brexit influence, PM warned 

But the IFS has now concluded that original forecasts of the impact did not account for the Barnett Formula, which calculates knock-on spending in Scotland and Wales.

That meant what was expected to be a 1 per cent real-terms cut was, in fact, 3 per cent – or 8 per cent in cash terms when set against March 2020 plans.

Only spending on the NHS and defence is protected for the next five years – and schools for the next two – leaving other departments badly exposed.

“This poses clear and obvious challenges, not least because of the new pressures created by the pandemic,” said Ben Zaranko, the IFS’s research economist.

“Plans can change, but as things stand, for many public services, the first half of the 2020s could feel like the austerity of the 2010s.”

Last week, Mr Sunak, was warned he should be suffering “sleepless nights” over the looming cuts, but insisted his critics are wrong because spending will “grow in every year”. 

“I think what you’re referring to are changes in forecasts from previous fiscal events – that’s not a cut in spending,” he claimed.

But the IFS said the small print pointed to “perennially squeezed areas” such as the courts system, the Home Office and “further cuts for local government.”

“For departments not fortunate enough to be protected by a pre-existing agreement with the Treasury, the Chancellor’s spending plans are even tighter than they first appeared,” Mr Zaranko added.

Spending on those unprotected services in 2022−23 is set to be 3 per cent lower than a year earlier, and 8 per cent lower than what was planned prior to Covid-19.”

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

View comments