David Cameron accused of releasing 'dodgy dossier' in support of EU membership

Iain Duncan Smith has criticised the report

Jon Stone
Wednesday 02 March 2016 10:45
David Cameron supports Britain remaining in the EU
David Cameron supports Britain remaining in the EU

David Cameron has been accused of publishing a “dodgy dossier” to support the case for staying in the European Union.

The Government study, released on Wednesday warns of a serious impact on British business were the UK to leave the EU – but has faced criticism from some Tory eurosceptics.

The research examines different options for the UK outside the EU and argues that “Britain would be weaker, less safe and worse off outside the EU”.

British businesses with supply chains in European countries would particularly suffer, the report says.

Iain Duncan Smith, the Work and Pensions Secretary, criticised the report’s approach – arguing that it was misleading.

“This dodgy dossier won’t fool anyone, and is proof that Remain are in denial about the risks of remaining in a crisis-ridden EU,” the Brexit-supporting minister said.

“The truth is, we won’t copy any other country’s deal. We will have a settlement on our own terms - and one that will return control of our borders, and money to Britain. That’s the safer choice.”

The tension between top Tories follows suggestions by Mr Duncan Smith that Mr Cameron had a "low opinion of the British people" because of his support for remaining in the EU.

Foreign Secretary Philip Hammond defended the report, however – arguing that Britain had a “special status” in the EU.

Iain Duncan Smith has criticised his party leader over Brexit in recent weeks

“Hard-headed analysis shows that every alternative to remaining in a reformed EU would leave Britain weaker, less safe and worse off,” he told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme.

“Working people would pay the price with fewer jobs and rising prices. The report concludes that Britain is stronger, safer and better off in a reformed European Union.

“Our special status gives us the best of both worlds: in the parts of Europe that work for us, but outside those that do not.”

The latest publication comes a day after the Boris Johnson’s chief economist published a report that appeared to contradict the Mayor’s view in favour of Brexit.

That study warned of an “economic shock” of Britain left the EU – depressing economic activity – and higher risks in the long-term for the Capital from Brexit.

Mr Johnson had however written in a newspaper column the day earlier that there were greater risks to staying in – and admonished the Chancellor George Osborne for citing “economic shocks”.

The head of the civil service Jeremy Heywood yesterday told the Public Administration Committee in the House of Commons that it was “common sense” for civil servants to take the Government’s position of supporting EU membership.

His statement follows a row about whether Brexit-supporting ministers would be given access to documents relating to the EU referendum.

The EU referendum will be held on 23 June this year.

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

View comments