Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

Private companies can’t be trusted to implement driverless cars, transport minister warns

John Hayes rejects the idea that ‘all change means progress’

Jon Stone
Political Correspondent
Tuesday 22 November 2016 14:01 GMT
A self-driving vehicle being tested in a pedestrian zone of Milton Keynes last month
A self-driving vehicle being tested in a pedestrian zone of Milton Keynes last month (Getty)

Self-driving cars may not necessarily be a good thing and their implementation should not be left to the free market, a transport minister has warned.

John Hayes said he rejected the “Whiggish assumption that all change means progress” and that while there may be advantages to the new vehicles, the Government would proceed with caution.

He told a parliamentary committee that autonomous vehicles would need to be regulated if they were to be made to work for the whole of society and that the creators of such vehicles would not be “motivated in the first instance by virtue”.

Mr Hayes also said it was unclear whether the vehicles could end up bringing more congestion into Britain’s cities and that the Department for Transport would be studying the issue.

“I was a businessman and I was interested in the commercial success of my business, nothing much more than that,” the minister told the House of Lords Science and Technology Committee.

“We shouldn’t expect, and it’s not reasonable to expect, the technologists and businesses associated with this to take that bigger view, that societal view, that communal view.”

He added: “There is a kind of Whiggish assumption that all change means progress, which I completely refute. Of course the truth is that in each of and all of our lives many things change, some for the better and some for the worse.”

When peers on the committee raised concerns that such vehicles might lead to more congestion because they would encourage people off public transport, foot or bikes and into private cars, Mr Hayes said: “This could lead to more vehicle sharing, a different perception of ownership, of whether to own a vehicle or simply use a vehicle when required, that could have a net effect of the opposite kind, reduce the number of cars on the road.

John Hayes, Transport Minister (House of Lords)

“But there is a simultaneous effect which will bring other people onto the road that aren’t there now, or may bring them from one vehicle to another vehicle – from a bus to a car, or from a tram to a car.

“I’ve asked one question in our modelling: how do we calculate what the likely effects of those two simultaneous and contradictory changes might be.”

Companies ranging from Google to more conventional car manufacturers are investing in technology that could lead to humans abandoning the steering wheel and handing control over to computers.

While consumer products for fully autonomous vehicles are thought to be many years away, transitional technologies are thought to be significantly closer to market.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in