‘This is illegal’: EU launches legal action against Boris Johnson for breaking international law

Commission says there is ‘no legal nor political justification whatsoever’ for UK approach

Jon Stone
Policy Correspondent
Wednesday 15 June 2022 10:14 BST
‘This is illegal’: EU launches legal action against UK over bypassing NI protocol

Britain’s government says it is “disappointed” that Brussels is taking legal action over plans to overwrite parts of the Brexit agreement.

Ministers had set out to “unilaterally break international law,” European Commission vice president Maros Sefcovic said as he announced the move.

It comes after Boris Johnson published a bill that would give ministers sweeping new powers to override elements of the Northern Ireland protocol, as well as giving themselves new powers over tax and state subsidies in the region without agreement from Brussels.

Mr Johnson’s plan would mean “breaking an agreement that protects peace and stability in Northern Ireland, an agreement reached together only three years ago”, the commissioner said.

Mr Sefcovic added: “Let there be no doubt: there is no legal nor political justification whatsoever for unilaterally changing an international agreement.

“Opening the door to unilaterally changing an international agreement is a breach of international law as well. So let’s call a spade a spade: this is illegal.”

Mr Sefcovic said the UK had not “sat down at the table with us since February” nor seen any constructive ideas since March last year.

The commission vice president said that it was “simply inconceivable” that the UK could determine the kinds of goods that would enter the European single market.

On Monday Mr Johnson said his plans for Northern Ireland were not a “big deal” and amounted to small tweaks to the status quo.

“Frankly, it’s a relatively trivial set of adjustments in the grand scheme of things,” he told broadcasters.

The EU had previously started legal action against the UK on 15 March 2021 for failing to properly implement the Northern Ireland protocol, but had put it on ice “in a spirit of constructive cooperation to create the space to look for joint solutions with the UK”.

However the bloc’s executive in Brussels is now moving the action to its second stage, by issuing a formal “reasoned opinion”.

The UK now has two months to reply, and if it does not then the commission would consider taking the UK to the European Court of Justice, which has full powers and the ability to fine the UK for non-compliance with the agreements.

The commission has also launched two more infringement proceedings against the UK, the first for failing to carry out phytosanitary checks on trade, and the second for failing to provide the EU with trade data required under the protocol.

A spokesperson for the UK government said: “It is disappointing that the EU has chosen to relaunch legal proceedings relating to the grace periods currently in place, which are vital to stop the problems caused by the protocol from getting worse. The UK’s preference remains for a negotiated solution but the proposals set out by the EU today are the same proposals we have been discussing for months and would not solve the problems – in many cases they take us backwards from current arrangements.

“The protocol is undermining the [Good Friday] Agreement – disrupting trade and leading to people in Northern Ireland being treated differently to the rest of the UK. The EU continues to insist it is unwilling to change the protocol itself, so we are obliged to act ourselves to change the parts of the protocol that are causing problems. The legislation we introduced this week delivers practical, reasonable solutions which also protect the EU single market and support north-south trade.”

Irish premier Micheal Martin said the fresh legal action “represents a step up in a response from the European Union”.

“That said, the European Union is still available and wants to bring a resolution to issues arising from the operations of the protocol through substantive negotiations with the United Kingdom government,” he added.

“The only logical and rational way forward is, in my view, to commence these negotiations between the UK government and the European Union, and I would appeal to the UK government to engage in such negotiations.”

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in