Housing Minister blocks thousands of homes at request of Tory MP Philip Davies

Gavin Barwell was accused of suspending the development as a ‘mate’s favour’

Jon Stone
Political Correspondent
Thursday 13 October 2016 22:17 BST
Tory housing minister Gavin Barwell
Tory housing minister Gavin Barwell

The Government’s Housing Minister has been accused of blocking the building of thousands of homes as a “mate’s favour” to a fellow Conservative MP who complained about them.

Gavin Barwell used his powers as a minister to intervene and suspend development plans in Bradford after a request from Tory colleague Philip Davies, putting them under potentially indefinite review.

In a letter seen by The Independent the minister wrote to Bradford Metropolitan District Council to tell them he was using his powers under the Planning Act to direct them not to proceed until he gave them further notice.

The letter explicitly cites complaints by Mr Davies, the MP for Shipley, as the reason for the suspension of the project, which has been nine years in the planning. The minister’s intervention invokes new powers the government granted itself earlier this year.

“The Secretary of State has received a request to intervene in the Bradford Core Strategy Development Plan (“The Plan”) from Philip Davies, MP for Shipley,” the letter to the council says.

“The request raises a number of issues including the proposed release of green belt, particularly in Wharfedale, development of green belt before brownfield land is exhausted … and the appropriate location for development to alleviate housing need and contribute to the regeration of Bradford city centre.”

Mr Barwell continues: “In exercise of his powers under section 21A of the Act (inserted by section 145 of the Housing and Planning Act 2016), the Secretary of State hereby directs City of Bradford Metropolitan District Council not to take any step in connection with the adoption of the Plan, while issues raised in the letters are considered further.

Philip Davies, the MP for Shipley, sparked the suspension of the project after sending a request to Mr Barwell
Philip Davies, the MP for Shipley, sparked the suspension of the project after sending a request to Mr Barwell

“This direction will remain in force until it is withdrawn by the Secretary of State or the Secretary of State gives a direction under section 21 of the 2004 Act in relation to the plan. My officials will be in touch with your officers to discuss next steps and we will keep the Council updates throughout our considerations.”

The core Bradford Plan was drawn up by the city’s council to redevelop the area and includes renovations of the city centre and new housing stock. It sets out broad locations for new housing, businesses, and infrastructure investment across the city but doesn't grant specific planning permission.

Before he was made a minister Mr Barwell also campaigned against a major housing development on Metropolitan Open Land in Croydon, where he is an MP. That borough, which is in South London, suffers from a major housing shortage.

Mr Barwell’s letter prompted Labour’s shadow Housing Minister John Healey to write to Mr Barwell’s boss, Communities Secretary Sajid Javid.

“This week, the Housing Minister in your department wrote to Bradford Council directing them to halt the adoption of their development plan which would build more homes for the people of Bradford. Despite all stages of consultation and approval – from local people, council and Planning Inspector – being completed, this action stops the plan’s adoption in its tracks,” he wrote.

The letter from the minister suspending the development plan
The letter from the minister suspending the development plan (DCLG)

“According to the Housing Minister this decision was taken merely because a fellow Conservative MP wrote in complaint. There is no attempt by the Minister to defend the substance of the complaint. Without justification, his decision to intervene smacks of a political ‘mate’s favour’.

“Given this lack of justification for your Department stopping a plan which has been nine years in the making, and involved extensive consultation with local people, I am writing to ask you to account for this decision.

“Your decision seems particularly extraordinary when on the very same day as the letter was sent, you spoke at some length in the second reading debate on the Neighbourhood Planning Bill about both the importance of building more homes and of local democracy. Your Minister’s letter has overridden both without proper justification.

“I raise this objection with you because this heavy-handed intervention using powers under the new Housing and Planning Act has also been used to halt Birmingham’s development plan.”

A DCLG spokesperson described the suspension of development as a “holding decision” and said it was issued because of concerns about building on greenbelt land.

“This is a totally false claim. No decision has yet been taken on whether to intervene or not,” he said – apparently referencing whether the Bradford plan should be changed or permanently cancelled.

“The holding direction was issued purely because of concerns over development on the Green Belt. This holding direction will allow time for proper consideration of these issues."

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in