Junior doctors: Jeremy Hunt risks 'untold damage' to future generations by imposing new contract, warns BMA

Union's chief negotiator launches fresh attack on ministers, accusing Health Secretary of 'crass' approach to NHS workforce

Charlie Cooper
Whitehall Correspondent
Friday 19 February 2016 20:16
Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt at recent meeting at No 10 Downing Street
Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt at recent meeting at No 10 Downing Street

Jeremy Hunt, the Government and NHS managers are “out of touch” with the reality of working on the frontline of England’s hospitals and have risked “untold damage” to future generations by imposing the junior doctor contract, the British Medical Association has claimed.

As BMA leaders meet on Saturday to plan the next stage of their challenge to the contract, which could include further strike action, Dr Johann Malawana, the union’s chief negotiator, launched a fresh attack on ministers, accusing the Health Secretary of an “incomprehensibly crass” approach to the medical workforce.

Writing for independent.co.uk, Dr Malawana said Mr Hunt’s attempt to link junior doctors’ working hours with evidence of increased weekend mortality in hospitals had been “the final straw” for the profession.

But even before the current dispute, medics’ morale was already low, he writes, with understaffing on wards “simply ignored” by managers focused on “political imperatives”.

The latest salvo in the long-running dispute comes as official figures from the regulator NHS Improvement show hospitals and other services have overspent by £2.3bn in the nine months to December 2015, and are on track for a total year-end deficit of £2.8bn.

Officials said they were hopeful this figure could be brought down to something closer to the Government’s £1.8bn deficit target but it now appears increasingly likely that the Department of Health will breach its expenditure limit this year – an unprecedented situation.

Deepening deficits in hospital budgets demonstrate that that the health service is costing more to run than the funding the Government has allocated for it. Cash over-spent this year will come out of next year’s budget, eating into the £3.8bn funding increase the Government has pledged for 2016/17.

BMA on contract imposition

Although the BMA agreed to enter into negotiations on the junior doctor contract on the basis that new offer would be “cost neutral”, Dr Malawana said that the dispute had highlighted the true cost of running a safe NHS and the extent to which the current workforce has been “overstretched”.

“For many years junior doctors have been highlighting the issue of gaps in rotas,” he writes. “This concept of ‘missing doctors’ has been ignored by a management structure in the NHS that frankly cares very little about the welfare of the staff, focusing instead on the delivery of political imperatives”

He adds: “When morale was already very low, when management seemed be so out of touch with frontline issues, when the lack of any pastoral care of staff had become the norm in most doctors’ working lives, to call into question their professionalism was incomprehensibly crass.”

Sugar 'will bankrupt the NHS'

The Government’s course of action had risked “fatally” undermining the NHS, he writes, risking “untold damage for generations to come”.

The BMA has held seven meetings with junior doctor groups around the country in the past week, and union leaders will meet on Saturday to discuss their response to Mr Hunt’s decision to end negotiations and impose the contract. The Government says that 90 per cent of the terms in the revised contract had been agreed upon by the BMA.

However, BMA sources said that junior doctors attending meetings this week have told the union that they think they contract is “unworkable” for many, in particular part-time doctors and those working in specialties that require the most unsocial hours, such as A&E and maternity. The new contract reduces out-of-hours pay for juniors, in exchange for a basic salary increase of 13.5 per cent.

Responding to the NHS Improvement deficit figures, a Department of Health spokesperson said that increased health spending over the course of the Parliament and a clampdown on spending on agency staff would improve hospital finances.

“But hospital leaders must continue to show grip and swiftly introduce the reforms announced in the review into NHS efficiency published earlier this month, so every penny possible can be invested in frontline patient care,” the spokesperson said.

Register for free to continue reading

Registration is a free and easy way to support our truly independent journalism

By registering, you will also enjoy limited access to Premium articles, exclusive newsletters, commenting, and virtual events with our leading journalists

Already have an account? sign in

By clicking ‘Register’ you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to our Terms of use, Cookie policy and Privacy notice.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy policy and Terms of service apply.

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in