Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

Prince Charles has been routinely sent secret Cabinet papers for decades

Revelation after FoI battle follows release of so-called 'black spider memos' sent by the Prince to ministers

Nigel Morris
Deputy Political Editor
Tuesday 15 December 2015 21:17 GMT
Charles has regularly lobbied ministers on pet subjects
Charles has regularly lobbied ministers on pet subjects (Getty Images)

Prince Charles has been routinely sent secret Cabinet papers for decades, giving him privileged access to confidential and market sensitive information, it has emerged.

The arrangement, under which records of ministerial deliberations are automatically released to the Prince of Wales as well as the Queen, has been revealed following a three-year freedom of information battle.

It follows the disclosure that the heir to the throne has regularly lobbied ministers over pet subjects including homeopathy, architecture, rainforests, rural housing and military spending.

Prince Charles dodges questions on Black Spider

The campaign group Republic, which obtained the information, called for the “quite extraordinary and completely unacceptable” practice to be scrapped. It wrote to David Cameron demanding that the prince be removed from the circulation list for the papers, which would normally be kept secret for 20 years.

The Cabinet Office had resisted the release of the so-called “precedent book”, which details the inner workings of the Government, but was ordered by a freedom of information tribunal to publish several parts.

One section of the book, drawn up in 1992, reads: “The documents of the cabinet and ministerial committees are issued primarily to the sovereign, the Prince of Wales, and ministers… The need for secrecy calls for special care in circulation and handling.

“The standard circulation for cabinet memoranda includes the Queen, the Prince of Wales, all members of the cabinet, any other ministers in charge of departments, the attorney general and the chief whip… Ministers of state and junior ministers do not normally receive memoranda.”

The revelation follows the release in May, following another FoI battle, of the so-called “black spider memos” sent by the Prince to ministers over several years. Twenty-seven letters – 10 from Charles to ministers, 14 by ministers and three letters between private secretaries – written between September 2004 and March 2005 were published.

In its letter last night to Mr Cameron, Republic said: “The fact that… Charles has privileged access to Cabinet papers is a further cause for concern as it means he is able to lobby ministers in secret at every stage of policy development process.

“It is plainly wrong Charles can lobby on new policy proposals even before the public are aware of the existence of such proposals. Cabinet papers will include market-sensitive information that would enable a person in possession of the information to use it to further their own financial interests.”

A Cabinet Office spokesman said: “It has been established practice for many years that the sovereign and the heir to the throne receive the minutes of Cabinet meetings. It is important the head of state and her heir are properly briefed.”

Paul Flynn, a Labour member of the Commons public administration and constitutional affairs committee, called for a parliamentary investigation.

“He is not just a figurehead, he has become a participant in national debate and there is no control over his lobbying,” he told The Guardian.

“This means that he is not only the most influential lobbyist, but the best informed and he is lobbying for his own interests, which are not always benign or sensible.”

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in