Rupert Murdoch made no attempt to officially lobby ministers to curtail the activities of the BBC during charter renewal process – but The Guardian did

Organisation expressed concerns about Corporation's online activities and how it impacted on its own commercial viability

Oliver Wright
Political Editor
Wednesday 25 May 2016 10:52 BST

Rupert Murdoch made no attempt to lobby ministers to curtail the activities of the BBC during charter renewal process – but The Guardian newspaper did.

At the time and in public The Guardian warned that the BBC seemed at the “mercy of a culture secretary who has never hidden his dislike for what he has called a ‘£4 billion market intervention’”.

But it has now emerged that in private the organisation expressed concerns about the online activities of the Corporation and how it impacted on its own commercial viability.

The Culture Minister Ed Vaizey told the House of Commons that he had met with “regularly” with representatives of the company who expressed concerns about the BBC’s reach.

Mr Vaizey was responding to comments from Paul Blomfield, Labour MP for Sheffield Central, who told the Commons on Monday that the government wanted to reshape the BBC “in line with the views of the Murdochs” — a reference to Rupert Murdoch, owner of The Times, The Sun and The Sunday Times.

But Mr Vaizey replied: “I found it particularly surprising that the honourable member for Sheffield Central . . . dared to suggest that we were somehow shaping our approach to the BBC at the behest of Rupert Murdoch.

“I tell you this, Mr Speaker, with utter sincerity and truthfulness, that the only organisation that has ever lobbied me to clip the wings of the BBC is The Guardian . . . It comes to me regularly — quite legitimately, I have to say — to say that it is trying to make a living, as it were, digitally in the digital world.

He added: “It has been opening websites. It opened an office in Australia and came to complain about the presence of the BBC in Australia taking talent from The Guardian in Australia and paying too much. It lobbied me about the presence of the BBC in the US, where The Guardian also wants to have a presence.”

A spokesman for Guardian News and Media said: “Through the BBC charter review process, Guardian Media Group has made open and public representations to the BBC, BBC Trust, the Department for Culture, Media and Sport and multiple parliamentary select committees regarding its concerns about the lack of transparency and openness of the BBC’s commercial news operations and the BBC’s online presence in the UK.

“We’re pleased that a number of these views have been reflected in recent reports published by the BBC Trust, the DCMS select committee and in the government’s recent white paper.”

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in