Tory MP Karl McCartney hits out at 'the shrill equal pay brigade'

The ONS paints a complex picture of the gender pay gap

Jon Stone
Wednesday 07 September 2016 16:30 BST
Karl McCartney
Karl McCartney (House of Commons)

Support truly
independent journalism

Our mission is to deliver unbiased, fact-based reporting that holds power to account and exposes the truth.

Whether $5 or $50, every contribution counts.

Support us to deliver journalism without an agenda.

Louise Thomas

Louise Thomas


A Conservative MP has hit out at the “shrill equal pay brigade”, claiming that campaigners are ignoring evidence when they talk about the gender pay gap.

Karl McCartney told the House of Commons that though he supported equal pay, he believed in some cases men were actually the ones at a disadvantage.

“According to the Office for National Statistics, on average men in full-time or part-time work under 29 years of age are paid less per hour on average than similarly aged women,” he said in a Tuesday afternoon debate on boys' educational performance.

“That remarkable transition flies in the face of the shrill equal pay brigade, who while proclaiming the need for equality seem quietly to gloss over that fact when shouting from the rooftops with regard to equal pay.

“I want equal pay for those with equivalent experience and qualifications and skill levels regardless of their gender or age.

The Office for National Statistics paints a complex picture of the gender pay gap.

The ONS says that since 1997 the gender pay gap across all age groups has narrowed for full-time workers but actually widened for part-time workers.

Overall more women work part time than men, meaning women on average are paid less across all employees. 41 per cent of women work part time, compared with only 11 per cent of men.

Older women who work part time are also paid less on average than their male full-time counterparts.

A higher proportion of women are also employed in jobs that tend to be low-paid such as administrative or secretarial work, as well as caring jobs.

The Fawcett Society says this gap is in part due to societal pressures and unequal caring responsibilities between men and women.

“Women continue to play a greater role in caring for children, as well as for sick or elderly relatives. As a result more women work part time, and these jobs are typically lower paid with fewer progression opportunities,” it says.

“The pay gap opens up significantly once women hit their forties. Often as they return from a break to raise children, women find that their male contemporaries are being promoted ahead of them.”

The Government has consulted on mandatory reporting of the gender pay gap in companies and is planning to make the provision compulsory, with Parliament expected to confirm legislation on the issue sometime in the Autumn.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in