Why are old men hanging out in the comments section of the Guardian crossword

Because you can still smoke while doing a crossword, probably

Adam Withnall
Thursday 06 August 2015 17:00 BST

The internet has by and large become a place where popular discourse is taken over by abusive comments, sarcastic insults and WHOEVER CAN SHOUT THE LOUDEST.

But it seems that there remains at least one precious sanctuary from the noise – hidden away in the comments section of the Guardian’s crossword.

First spotted by Twitter user James Crobag (who has since been overwhelmed by his newfound online fame), the spaces underneath each day’s puzzle are a bit like how you imagine country pubs were on a summer afternoon in “the good old days”.

While discussions hinge upon the crossword itself – because it’s polite to stay on topic – the wizened commenters also talk about their holidays, grandchildren and, of course, the cricket.

There’s no swearing to be heard and set-ups for jokes of a sexual nature are quickly steered in a more prim and proper direction.

Newfangled technology is discussed along with references to “Microsoft stocks”.

How lovely it is to be retired naturally gets a mention.

As do the current affairs of the day.

There’s a real sense of a community feel.

And naturally, lots and lots about cricket.

But at the end of the day, even this safe place can’t avoid a mention of Jeremy Corbyn.

After discovering this online gem, James Crobag begged his Twitter followers to “follow the prime directive when observing the crossword men”. So far at least, people seem to have done just that.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in