Egypt's democracy is a sham, says ElBaradei, as he pulls out of election

Nobel laureate will not run for president

Sarah El Deeb
Sunday 15 January 2012 01:00 GMT
ElBaradei said: 'I cannot run for office unless there is a real democratic framework'
ElBaradei said: 'I cannot run for office unless there is a real democratic framework' (Getty Images)

One of Egypt's leading voices for reform, Mohamed ElBaradei, said yesterday he is pulling out of the country's presidential race in protest at the military's failure to put the country on the path to democracy.

The 69-year-old Nobel laureate, who has been seen as a driving force behind the movement that forced the former president Hosni Mubarak to step down, said in a statement that conditions for a fair presidential election are not in place. He said the military rulers who took over from Mubarak have governed "as if no revolution took place".

His decision to pull out days before the first anniversary of the 25 January uprising reflects the dilemma in which Egypt's revolutionary movement finds itself – caught between a military that, it says, is trying to hold on to power, and a newly elected parliament dominated by the Islamist Muslim Brotherhood, which it fears will give the generals what they want.

The military rulers have said they will transfer power after presidential elections, to be held before the end of June. But many expect a fierce struggle over the military's future privileges.

"I reviewed the best ways to serve the goals of the revolution... and I found none within the official framework, including [running for] the presidency," Mr ElBaradei said. "I had said from the start that my conscience will not allow me to run for any official position unless there is a real democratic framework that upholds the essence of democracy and not only its form."

The Muslim Brotherhood, whose political party looks poised to take more than 40 per cent of seats in the next parliament, has also indicated that it may not field a candidate.

But the Brotherhood, by dominating parliament, is set to control the process by which a committee that will be entrusted with writing the new constitution is picked. Some liberals and youth groups fear this will produce a bargain in which the army continues to control executive power, but allows conservative Islamists to dictate the constitution.

Mr ElBaradei had argued that the constitution should be written before the elections. Many revolutionaries say that the first free vote after decades of dictatorship is unlikely to yield a representative parliament, and have advocated a constitutional committee made up of delegates of political parties, universities, unions and other institutions. Mr ElBaradei admitted the protest movement was in dire straits, but blamed its malaise on the military's failure to respond to its demands. He urged young people to continue their peaceful protests. "The youth are the ones who will rebuild this country... They are the dream, the hope," he said.

Many have criticised Mr ElBaradei's low profile since the revolution, saying he failed to act as the leader of an uprising that began without one but soon found it needed a figure to unify and guide it. His decision to stand down from elections, and not play the army's game, may restore some of his standing.

Ayman Nour, a presidential hopeful, supported Mr ElBaradei's decision, saying it was a "positive shock" to the nation and a new push for the revolutionary groups to demand more radical changes. The activist Omar Elhady wrote on his Twitter account: "ElBaradei's withdrawal proves he is a respectable man. I had stopped supporting him as president a while back. Now I see him as a national leader above official positions."

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in