Stay up to date with notifications from TheĀ Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

Reality check for worshippers who thought they found the blood of Jesus on a wafer

It turns out there's nothing miraculous about red marks found on a communion host at a Catholic church in Indiana

Sarah Harvey
Thursday 27 March 2025 17:41 GMT
A laboratory analysis turned up nothing miraculous about red marks found on a Communion wafer at a Catholic church in Indiana
A laboratory analysis turned up nothing miraculous about red marks found on a Communion wafer at a Catholic church in Indiana (WKRC-TV)

Worshippers at a Catholic church in Indiana thought they had found a miracle when they discovered red marks on a communion wafer – the reality was much less exciting.

The Archdiocese of Indianapolis said the wafer was found when it fell out of a Mass kit and ā€œwhen it was discovered, red spots were presentā€.

Several parishioners were understood to believe the red substance was the blood of Jesus Christ, and therefore a Eucharistic miracle.

The archdiocese said: ā€œThroughout the history of the Catholic Church, there have been well-documented miracles and apparitions, and each has been thoroughly and carefully reviewed.ā€

But, a scientific analysis debunked claims of a miracle at St Anthony of Padua Catholic Church in Morris.

The archdiocese announced on Monday that a biochemical analysis revealed the marks were caused by "fungus and three different species of bacteria, all of which are commonly found on human hands."

The analysis confirmed that no blood was present on the wafer.

The Catholic faith teaches that wine and a bread wafer signify the body and blood of Jesus Christ. Typically, they're consecrated by a priest at Mass.

St. Anthony of Padua Church, where a Communion wafer with red marks was discovered
St. Anthony of Padua Church, where a Communion wafer with red marks was discovered

The host, or bread, with red marks had fallen out of a Mass kit at St. Anthony Church.

Before the analysis, some members of St. Anthony Church were excited about what might be found.

ā€œWe have such a little town. You can drive through and blink and you’re through it,ā€ Shari Strassell, a church member, told WKRC-TV.

ā€œIt means the world, it does, and I think there is something special about our church up here.ā€

It comes as Assisi, the medieval Italian town revered as the home of Saints Francis and Clare, is experiencing a new wave of pilgrim fervour.

The focus of this burgeoning devotion is Carlo Acutis, a millennial teenager set to be canonised on April 27.

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in